Film details

School For Scoundrels  2006

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Roger, a shy New York traffic warden, lacks confidence, especially when it comes to dealing with women, so attends a self-help course run by the persuasive Dr. P and his huge, hulking sidekick Lesher. The classes include various supposedly character-building exercises such as talking to women, Dr. P telling them that any man can find love if he is willing to lie, and an outdoor paintballing session, in which other class members such as Eli, Diego and Walsh are brutalised by Lesher before Roger manages to spring an ambush on him and take him out of the game. Although warned that Dr. P gets jealous of those students who do particularly well after his tutelage, Roger starts to date his attractive neighbour Amanda, only to find that the Doctor engineers a chance meeting with Amanda and also begins seeing her. The rivalry between the two men starts to escalate, and Dr. P starts to sabotage Roger at every turn, framing him for sexual harassment of a male colleague, which causes him to lose his traffic warden job, and spray-painting Amanda's job, similarly framing Roger for the bizarre act which makes her believe him to be demented. Roger makes contact with Lonnie, a broken, disillusioned man who was once one of the Doc's star pupils, but was destroyed mentally and physically by him once he too became his star student. Lonnie hands Roger the research he has done on Dr. P, revealing details of his multiple personality syndrome problem, his wife and his criminal activities. When P invites Amanda to a conference in Miami, Roger draws up a plan with Lonnie, Diego, Eli and Walsh to abduct Lesher and then introduce Amanda to P's wife to show her she has been duped, but P thwarts their plan by telling Roger that he has won, and gives Roger the plane ticket to go with Amanda to Miami. But Roger finds out it is he who has been tricked, and the ticket is for a different destination. He finally confronts the pair and claims that the so-called Doctor is a total fraud and a charlatan. P protests, but Roger, having learned at the hands of a master, has a very dirty trick up his sleeve....

Production

Director
Todd Phillips
Producer
Todd Phillips, Daniel Goldberg and J. Geyer Kosinski
Art Director
Scott Meehan
Editor
Leslie Jones and Daniel Schalk
Music
Christophe Beck
Screenplay
Todd Phillips and Scot Armstrong, based, uncredited, on the 1959 film School For Scoundrels, written by Patricia Moyes and Hal E. Chester, based on the works of Stephen Potter
Director of Photography
Jonathan Brown

Review

That The Ladykillers should be remade, with such strange results, by the well respected Coen Brothers is one thing. but for Robert Hamer's joyous, and sadly for him final, 1959 movie School For Scoundrels to be used, uncredited in the finished print, as the source material for a film by Todd Phillips, director of the distinctly downmarket Old School, should be regarded as the basis for diplomatic intervention. Despite starring Billy Bob Thornton, a actor with a fine way with a sharp line, when the mood takes him, Phillips' film is actually rather reticent in getting to the whole point of the story, what it is to be a man, and how to achieve it, perhaps an indication that Phillips and co-writer Scot Armstrong just didn't really understand the black-and-white Terry Thomas and Ian Carmichael starrer at all. In essence Thornton and Jon Heder find themselves essentially playing reworked and diluted versions of two of their other roles, the scabrous Bad Santa and Napoleon Dynamite respectively. Whereas the Potter books essentially pitted their characters against the world in general, arming them with the tricks and touches which make life easier and more successful, Phillips' film merely pits the two characters against each other, with little reason being given for P's rivalry with Roger other than the fact that he always wants to annihilate his most successful pupil, and Amanda (Jacinda Barrett) becomes less of a love interest and more a trophy to be fought for and won, with no taking of her feelings on the matter being considered. The various tricks and schemes are little more than advanced high school pranks, and some of the odder comedy angles, such as the group's fears that the immense Lecher (Michael Clarke Duncan - The Green Mile) actually sexually assaults failing class members seems oddly out of place in the script, and as is mandatory in US comedies, having been passed by the Senate or something similar, there's a cameo from Ben Stiller, while other fine actors such as Luis Guzman (Boogie Nights) and Todd Louiso (High Fidelity) are largely wasted. Sadly Thornton's bawling Dr. P is also no match for the charm, and cheery menace, of Alastair Sim in the original. Not so much a missed opportunity as a misconceived idea from the beginning, resulting in a film which doesn't know if it is a remake, a homage, or something new entirely, and Jon Heder's limitations are becoming more and more obvious.