Film details
The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things 2004
Ingannevole E Il Cuore Piu Di Ogni Cosa / Le Livre De Jeremie
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Asia Argento
-
Dylan Sprouse
-
Cole Sprouse
-
Kip Pardue
-
-
Jeremy Sisto
-
Ornella Muti
-
Matt Schulze
-
Peter Fonda
-
-
Lydia Lunch
-
Marilyn Manson
Synopsis
Asia Argento has already had one severely diversified career for someone so young, from appearing since a child in the films of her father, revered cult director Dario, branching off on her own for some well respected European films before breaking into the English language market with the flawed but interesting B.Monkey and moving onto blockbusters by appearing as almost the only saving grace of XXX. Along the way she has also become a writer and director even if her debut feature in these capacities, Scarlet Diva, wasn't actually the scandalous production the pre-publicity would have one believe. This appears to be another departure, being a serious drama with the woman herself playing Sarah, a mother who manages to get her six-year-old son Jeremiah back from the foster parents who are taking care of him, Sarah, being deemed an unfit mother, and takes him with her as she travels through the deep South, Jeremiah eventually becoming a teenager confused as to his sexual identity. It certainly isn't the sort of production she is normally associated with, but she has a fine and varied cast to support her including Kip Pardue (Driven), Winona Ryder in her first role post the courtroom unpleasantness, Jeremy Sisto (One Point 0), and in some very imaginative casting, Italian icon Ornella Muti and Peter Fonda as Sarah's parents. In small roles, controversy never really being too far away from Ms.Argento, are bizarre performance artist Lydia Lunch and rather tiresome shock-rocker Marilyn Manson. The role of the little lad is played by identical twins Dylan and Cole Sprouse, a way of getting more available hours of filming, the rules on how long a young child can act in front of the camera being particularly strict in the US.
Production
- Director
- Asia Argento
- Producer
- Roberta Hanley, Brian Young, Alain De La Mata and Chris Hanley
- Art Director
- Max Biscoe
- Editor
- Jim Mol
- Music
- Billy Corgan
- Screenplay
- Asia Argento and Allesandro Magania, based on short stories by J.T. LeRoy
- Director of Photography
- Eric Alan Edwards
Review
Having first made her name in the films of her director father Dario, appearing as a child in such films as The Church before taking leading roles in Trauma and The Phantom Of The Opera, then moving onto Hollywood blockbusters such as XXX while directing herself in the overwrought Scarlet Diva, Asia Argento certainly has the credentials to tackle this film version of the supposedly autobiographical short stories by J.T. LeRoy, the publication of which caused minor ripples when first published in 2001, aided by a clever marketing campaign and an author all too keen to be in the limelight. But the tone of the film does not match the written work, the authenticity of which is severely under scrutiny now the initial publicity has died away, in which LeRoy looks back on his life with a mordant black humour, almost a sense of detachment, at times quietly amazed that he actually survived such a turbulent upbringing, if indeed it happened at all. The film instead details the torments and humiliations of his life without providing any emotional reflection or standpoint. LeRoy's life is certainly eventful, in all the unpleasant ways that word can suggest, but the sheer number of people willing to use or abuse him becomes dizzying, and oddly repetitive, each outrage lessening the emotional impact. Some of Argento's touches are too calculated, such as including scenes cut in from some obscure East European animation to show Jeremiah's disintegrating psyche, but she also handles the three different actors who play Jeremiah at different stages in his life very well, making his a believable character in unbelievable circumstances. The source material certainly makes this for a specialised audience, but Asia Argento has shown that she is a capable, controlled director, something one would not have though after her directorial debut.