Film details

Proof  2004

Film still

Cast

  • Jake Gyllenhaal
  • Hope Davis
  • Danny McCarthy
  • Tobiacz Daszkiewicz
  • Gary Houston
  • Anne Whitman
  • Colin Stinton
  • Leigh Zimmerman
  • John Keefe
  • Damiel Hatkoff

Synopsis

Chicago mathematician Catherine is still mourning the death of her father Robert, a mathematician widely regarded by a genius but whose last years were plagued by increasingly serious mental illness. Catherine is concerned not only with his death, but the feat that she believes she has only a fraction of his talents, and many have inherited the same debilitating mental condition. Hal, one of Robert's ex-students and regarded as an aspiring scholar himself, manages to get hold of Robert's copious notebooks, but to his disappointment finds they contain pages and pages of what appears to be gibberish. Catherine accuses Hal of stealing the notebooks and calls the Police, only to refuse to press charges when they arrive and behave strangely aggressively towards them. Her sister Claire, a New York currency analyst, arrives in Chicago for the funeral, and harbours hopes that once everything is sorted out with their father's estate Catherine will come back to New York with her. At the funeral Catherine's oratory turns on the congregation as she accuses them of abandoning her father when he became ill, and that night she sleeps with Hal. The next morning she shows him her father's cluttered desk and gives him another notebook which seems to contain, in legible script and calculations, the proof of the solution to a long-held mathematical quandary, a potential breakthrough in the field. Caroline claims authorship of the proof, but both Hal and Claire have their doubts, believing it to be one of her father's which she is passing off as her own. Hal takes to notebook to his university, hoping to establish authenticity, and Catherine, hurt by what she sees as betrayal, agrees to join Claire in New York. Catherine thinks back to her time with her father when he was in remission in his illness and she was working at Chicago's Northwestern University, but knows now that those days, and the work they produced together, may ultimately prove to be worthless....

Production

Director
John Madden
Producer
John T.Hart, Jeff Sharp, Alison Owen and Robert Kessel
Art Director
Keith Slote
Editor
Mick Audsley
Music
Stephen Warbeck
Screenplay
Rebecca Miller and David Auburn, based on the stage play by David Auburn
Director of Photography
Alwin Kuchler

Review

The collaboration of director John Madden and actress Gwyneth Paltrow has already borne fruit, in the excellent Shakespeare In Love in 1998 and the stage version of Proof, which gained admiring reviews when mounted in London's West End in 2002. The stage version was a much smaller production, and more concerned with the conversations between the increasingly self-doubting and self-loathing Catherine, and her father, Robert, here played by Anthony Hopkins in a performance which constantly threatens to topple into bathos but which eventually narrowly avoids doing so. The core subject, mathematics, is such an uncinematic topic that the narrative generally revolves around the private life of the mathematician rather than the subject itself, as with A Beautiful Mind and Good Will Hunting, as well as the BBC production of Squaring The Circle, dealing with the life of Alan Turing, have shown. Unfortunately it seems that Proof seem to require the intimacy of a small theatre and close audience, as when opened up, both in terms of scope and script, the whole film revolves around a battered notebook, and what lies within it, and although that which it claims to prove is very important in the realm of maths itself, its' very difficult to get a non-dedicated audience too interested. In some ways Proof uses shorthand to explain its' characters - Robert's desk is a mess of papers, pens, notes and jottings, reflecting his increasingly scrambled state of mind; Catherine's hair is a mess and she dresses dowdily (but not so much that she still isn't recognisably Gwyneth Paltrow) to indicate her falling self-esteem. She's the tormented genius in waiting, and Hope Davis (The Matador) is welcome light relief as her sister Claire, but one has to wonder just why she would want such a mopey sibling to return home with her. Proof keeps one watching, mostly because it does eventually become a drama which hinges on something which few would understand, or indeed realise its' importance, and the final revelation of Catherine and Robert's last days together is touching, explaining a lot of what went before, but it remains a piece which seems to need the framing of the prosthenium arch.