Film details
Melinda and Melinda 2004
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Radha Mitchell
-
Chiwetel Ejiofor
-
Jonny Lee Miller
-
Amanda Peet
-
-
-
Wallace Shawn
-
Vinessa Shaw
-
Gene Saks
-
Sabrina Lloyd
-
Josh Brolin
-
Andy Borowitz
-
Stephen Carell
Synopsis
Sy, a New York playwright, has a genuine belief that all life is in fact tragic, and tells the story of a woman called Melinda in order to prove his point. His friend, disagreeing, tells the same story but giving it a comic slant to prove all life is a comedy. In Sy's version of the story Melinda is invited to a dinner party by her friends Laurel and Lee, a frustrated actor who has not worked in many months. They know she is estranged from her children and has attempted suicide and, after discussing her current mental state, she moves in with her friends. She starts to date a musician, Ellis Moonsong, as Lee is passed over for an acting job after what he believes to be a good audition, the real reason being his increasing drinking. Laurel is upset at Lee's behaviour and Miranda and Ellis invite her out with them. Laurel returns realising Ellis is strongly attracted to her. Melinda attempts a legal attempt to retrieve her children but this fails, and her suspicion that Ellis and Laurel are having an affair further destablises her, leading Melinda to a terrible and final confrontation. In the counter-version of the story Melinda arrives at the dinner party thrown by her friends Susan and Hobie, and confesses she has overdosed on tablets after being jilted. Hobie and Susan take care of her in the following days, Hobie developing an infatuation with Melinda and then finding Susan has been having an affair, an event which he realises can work, perversely, in his favour. Hobie is about to tell Melinda what he feels about her but before he can speak she tells him she has met another man, a musician. Hobie tries to console himself by taking another woman, Stacey, to a party, but Stacey becomes hysterical and makes a farcical suicide attempt. Melinda finally arrives at the party and gives Hobie the news he has been dying to hear.
Production
- Director
- Woody Allen
- Producer
- Letty Aronson
- Art Director
- Tom Warren
- Editor
- Alisa Lepselter
- Screenplay
- Woody Allen
- Director of Photography
- Vilmos Zsigmond
Review
That sound you hear is the increasingly dwindling cadre of Woody Allen fans insisting that his new movie is 'a return to form'. With Melinda And Melinda he wants it both ways - to show that he can still make comedies as well as his 'dramas'. When one considers that his dramas contain such dry-as-dust tedium as September, Another Woman and Interiors this is more of a threat than a promise. The trouble is that the episodes seem to be oddly crossed. The comedic episode is filled with frankly annoying characters, especially Will Ferrell's Hobie, is scant on humour and ends on a laughably romantic and illogical note while the serious episode is another of Allen's attempts at Ingmar Bergman and is so po-faced and portentous that the only response to such a gloomy-laden scenario is a smirk. Radha Mitchell (Pitch Black / Silent Hill) plays the titular Melinda in both, sporting a different hairstyle in each section, but is pretty much the victim in each. The serious part sees her a suicidal, neurotic mother, parted from her children and apparently unable to keep her hands off any man she meets. The 'funny' version sees her as a vacuous, suicidal neurotic, and both story strands end in a suicide attempt, which Allen tries to handle in both styles. One of the main troubles is that the stories are so polarised - deathly serious with not a shred of humour for one, and frantic, loud and ridiculously upbeat down to the ridiculous conclusion in the other, and only Allen with his view of women would consider a wife having an affair 'good news' so a husband can make his move on another woman. Interestingly the film contains Woody Allen's first major black character, surprising for a filmmaker who has lived for all his life in New York City, but even here the ludicrously named Ellis Moonsong is played by British actor Chiwetel Ejiofor, as if Allen couldn't find a US black actor up to the job. Allen is still getting s strong ensemble cast for his films, this time around including Jonny Lee Miller (Trainspotting), Amanda Peet (Identity), Wallace Shawn (My Dinner with Andre), and veteran film director Gene Saks, but now his casting is really the only element of true interest in Allen's work.