Film details

Stay  2005

Film still

Cast

  • Naomi Watts
  • Ryan Gosling
  • Janeane Garofalo
  • Kate Burton
  • B.D. Wong
  • Elizabeth Reaser
  • Michael Gaston
  • Mark Margolis
  • John Tormey
  • Amy Sidaris

Synopsis

Having set fire to his own car on Brooklyn Bridge, suicidal student Henry Letham is saved from the wreck and assigned to be examined by Sam Foster, a psychiatrist covering for his colleague Dr. Beth Levy, who is away on leave. Henry calmly tells him he plans to commit suicide at midnight on the forthcoming Saturday. In their ongoing meetings Sam discovers a few facts about Henry, that his parents are dead, that he is still mourning the end of a relationship with Anthea, a drama student who is supporting herself working as a waitress, and that he is obsessed with an artist who committed suicide on Brooklyn Bridge, having declared the act as his ultimate art work. Lisa Culpepper, Sam's girlfriend and a woman who also once attempted suicide, becomes interested in Henry's case when she reads Sam's notes. Sam regularly plays chess with Dr. Leon Patterson, an elderly man who has fallen blind, but when Henry comes across them playing one of their regular games he claims to Sam that Leon is actually his father. Sam realises that Henry is in need of residential care, but when he goes to his apartment to have him sectioned he is shocked to find a message from himself on Henry's answering machine, one he cannot remember leaving. Having returned to the city, Beth advises an alarmed Sam to contact Henry's mother, who she believes is alive. He arranges to meet the woman, but once in the apartment she starts to bleed from a head wound, Sam being attacked by the woman's dog. At the station, the Police later tell an increasingly nervous Sam that Henry's mother has been dead for months, killed in a car accident. Henry tracks Sam down and holds him at gunpoint, claiming that he had been lying and killed his own parents years previously. He makes his escape, leaving Sam unharmed but distraught. He tries to find Henry's girlfriend but she seems to have left the city. Leon's home is broken into by Henry, who magically seems to cure him of his blindness before leaving. Sam follows Henry to the bridge on Saturday night, hoping to stop him from carrying out his threat, but Henry is trying to bring everything to a violent and dramatic conclusion.

Production

Director
Marc Forster
Producer
Eric Kopeloff and Tom Lassally
Art Director
Jonathan Arkin
Editor
Matt Chesse
Music
Asche & Spencer
Screenplay
David Benioff
Director of Photography
Roberto Schaefer

Review

Swiss-born Marc Forster has proved to be a director with an intriguing choice of projects in recent years, from the small-scale drama of Everything Put Together, to the award-winning Monster's Ball and the genuinely moving Finding Neverland, he has also been a director who it has been difficult to pin down to any particular style or genre. With Stay he appears to be delving into the sort of psychological semi-horror story which suggests another variation on The Sixth Sense but which also brings to mind, rather worryingly, Nicolas Roeg's baffling Cold Heaven, a strange and confusing piece which effectively put the director's feature career on hold for a couple of years. As with his other films Forster gets a terrific cast together, including Ewan McGregor (Trainspotting / the revived Star Wars trilogy), Naomi Watts (21 Grams / King Kong) and Ryan Gosling (The Believer), and small roles for a fine array of talent from Bob Hoskins to B.D. Wong, working from a script by David Benioff (The 25th Hour), and what seems to be a relatively conventional psychological drama, as a psychiatrist tries to delve into the past of a young man who claims he will commit suicide, successfully this time, on Saturday night. But almost immediately Forster and Benioff start to throw in the coincidences and non-sequiters, hinting that Sam and Henry are perhaps the same person, separated in time, and is Hoskins' Dr. Patterson actually Henry's father, and indeed is he actually blind? Did Henry's mother die months previously, and if so who was it Sam met in her apartment? Who exactly is Lisa, who has also attempted suicide? Why is Janeane Garofalo's Dr. Levy not in the city when Henry's initial car wreck happens, and why does McGregor's Sam never wear any socks? As with the Roeg film, and more recently David Lynch's Lost Highway, there are hints that characters may have changed identities, that Sam may be the one in need of psychiatric help instead of Henry, and that all, some or none of what is being seen may be happening. 'I don't know what's real anymore', says Sam towards the end of the movie. And if he doesn't, what possible chance have the audience? Forster is still a fascinating director, but the wilful obscurity of Stay will ensure that very few will stay the course.