Film details

The Black Dahlia  2006

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Los Angeles, 1946, and two cops, Dwight 'Bucky' Bleichart and Lee Blanchard, both ex-boxers, are paired together for a charity exhibition bout, the pair eventually becoming close friends when they are partnered together on patrol. Lee shares an apartment with Kay Lake, a former good-time-girl who has returned to college, and tells Bucky the pair are definitely not having an affair. Months later the bisected and eviscerated body of Elizabeth Short is found on waste land, and Bucky and Lee are assigned to the case. Hearing Bobby De Witt, a psychopath who once attacked and scarred Kay, is being paroled, Lee panics and starts to take large amounts of benzedrine, leaving Bucky to investigate the Short case. Getting a lead to a lesbian nightclub, he sees a woman, Madeleine Linscott, dressed identically to how Elizabeth Short usually dressed, all in black. He questions her and she begs to be kept out of any publicity since she is the daughter of a powerful and prominent L.A. society family. Bucky starts to date Madeleine, becoming captivated by her, and meets her eccentric family, all of whom seem to have secrets, especially her father, Emmett who, with an old friend, George Tilden, got involved with Mack Sennett in the early days of the movie business, and were involved in constructing fire-trap houses with lumber taken from the movie studios. Now intimate with Bucky, Madeleine tells him that she also had sex with Elizabeth Short, causing Bucky to storm out. At the squad room the cops screen an 8mm stag movie which features Elizabeth Short with an under-aged girl, but Lee goes berserk and tries to destroy the celluloid, being stopped by the other officers. Hearing De Witt is to do a drug deal with a local Mafia boss, Morrie Friedman, Bucky goes to the location but De Witt is shot before Bucky can arrest him. At the top of a spiral staircase he sees Lee being strangled by an unknown assailant, but before he can help him another man appears, stabs both men, and the pair fall to their deaths. Bucky is knocked unconscious and comes to just as Friedman is about to set fire to the bodies. Bucky relates his version of events to his superior, Russ Millard, and takes him to Lee's secret hideout, a room where the walls are plastered with clippings about the Dahlia murder. Telling Kay he feels responsible for Lee's death, he and Kay start to sleep together, and he movies into Lee's apartment. Finding evidence which proves Lee framed De Witt for a robbery, he finds that Kay knew about the miscarriage of justice. Shocked, he goes to see Madeleine, and realises that a painting on one of the walls bears a strange parallel to a particular detail of the Dahlia murder. Suspecting that the stag film perhaps holds another clue, which was why Lee wanted it destroyed, Bucky runs it from the point where it was stopped, the crude end credits providing a vital name which seems to be hanging over the investigation, but the twists and turns of the Black Dahlia case are to become more grotesque and gruesome that Bucky could have ever imagined.

Production

Director
Brian De Palma
Producer
Avi Lerner, Rudy Cohen, Moshe Diamant and Art Linson
Art Director
Christopher Tandon, Puer-Luigi Basile and Dan Ross
Editor
Bill Pankow
Music
Mark Isham
Screenplay
Josh Friedman, based on the novel The Big Nowhere by James Ellroy
Director of Photography
Vilmos Zsigmond

Review

Originally to have been directed by David Fincher (Se7en), who eventually dropped out after over a year of pre-production, Brian De Palma's take on The Big Nowhere, the first and most autobiographical book in James Ellroy's 'L.A. Quartet', shows both how difficult it is to transfer Ellroy's scabrous and hate-powered prose to the screen, and how remarkably well Curtis Hanson managed it with his multi-Oscar winning version of L.A. Confidential, even if quite a lot of Ellroy's original was jettisoned along the way. Taking as its' basis the infamous Black Dahlia murder case, in which the body of aspiring actress and part-time hooker Elizabeth Short was found on a backlot, bisected at the waist, drained of blood and eviscerated by someone who had at least some surgical skill, Ellroy's novel was often almost hallucinatory in its' dive into the very seamiest parts of Los Angeles and the dirt and filth behind the glitter and tinsel, and De Palma would seem to be a good choice as director, but the enterprise his sunk by fatally bad casting. Josh Harknett is certainly no Russell Crowe, and can't convince as a dedicated cop with a guilty conscience, and Aaron Eckhart also lacks gravity as his sidekick. Hilary Swank may be a double~Oscar-winner, and some check the records after hearing that piece of information, but a seductive and dangerous femme fatale she isn't, and Scarlett Johansson has many talents, but when she's miscast, as in the action pic The Island, its' horribly obvious. The problem is that they are all six or seven years too young, and too photogenic, for the parts they are playing, which makes nothing they do or say the least believable, making the artifice of the plot all the more obvious. Fiona Shaw's plain embarrassing turn as the crazed matriarch Ramona Linscott makes one wonder if De Palma at one time was thinking of turning this into a parody a la Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid, or perhaps he just wasn't on set when Shaw was squawking and gurning. There are compensations, such as the perfectly recreated period details and locations, remarkably shot in Bulgaria, superbly designed by veteran Dante Ferretti, excellent camerawork by the masterly Vilmos Zsigmond, and a creepy feeling of unease even as the plot piles twist upon twist and absurdity upon confusion, and De Palma fans will be pleased to see a small role for one-time De Palma regular William Finley, making his first screen appearance in many years. Ellroy's work is complex, dark and frequently mentally demanding, and the problems with The Black Dahlia show that the only way to get them onto the screen, as seen with L.A. Confidential, is to take out a lot of what make them so uniquely Ellroy.