Film details
In Her Shoes 2005
In Den Schuhen Meiner Schwester
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Toni Collette
-
-
Mark Feuerstein
-
Richard Burgi
-
Anson Mount
-
Francine Beers
-
Candice Azzara
-
Brooke Smith
-
Norman Lloyd
-
Dorothy Kelly
-
Ken Howard
Synopsis
Rose, a lawyer in a Philadelphia law office, is called away mid-seduction of her work colleague Jim, in order to rescue her sister, Maggie, from her high school reunion, Maggie having a drink problem which makes her an embarrassing and aggressive drunk. This is the last straw for their stepmother, their biological mother having died when the girls were very young, and she won't let Maggie back into the house, so Rose is forced to put her up at her own apartment and let her sleep on her couch. Maggie, who claims to be dyslexic, had never been able to hold down a job, and when she auditions to be an MTV on-screen host finds she has trouble reading the teleprompter. Going to her father and stepmother's house to get some belongings, Maggie comes across some cards sent by Ella, their maternal grandmother, and takes them with her. Borrowing Rose's car without asking her, the car is towed when she parks it carelessly, and at the pound escapes a brush with a man who seems to be a potential rapist. Finding her car has been impounded, Rose insists Maggie leaves her apartment, but arrives home from work to find her sister and Jim having sex in her bed. Realising she can no longer stay in the city, Maggie travels to Florida to find Ella. Needing a break from her office, Rose takes a leave of absence, starting her own dog-walking service and pursuing a romance with Simon, another work colleague. In Florida Maggie finds a job as a hospice orderly, and receives encouragement from a blind patient to whom she reads soothing poetry, as well as finding another job as a personal shopper, at which she seems to be exceptionally gifted. Rose gets engaged to Simon, but becomes increasingly worried about her sister, not knowing where she is, but does not tell Simon her concerns. He starts to feel she is concealing something major from him and their relationship grows tense, causing Simon to call off their engagement. Discovering that Maggie is with Ella in Florida, Rose travels there to see them, knowing that their reconciliation is hugely important to both of them, especially when Ella tells them what actually happened before their mother's suicide all those years ago.
Production
- Director
- Curtis Hanson
- Producer
- Ridley Scott, Carol Fenelon, Lisa Ellzey and Curtis Hanson
- Art Director
- John Warnke and Jesse Rosenthal
- Editor
- Craig Kitson and Lisa Zeno Churgin
- Music
- Mark Isham
- Screenplay
- Susannah Grant, based on the novel by Jennifer Weiner
- Director of Photography
- Terry Stacey
Review
Curtis Hanson is a director who obviously wants to dabble at least once in every genre, from the perfectly judged noir of L.A. Confidential, the perfectly judged intelligent comedy Wonder Boys, and the bizarre mish-mash which was Lucky You. In her Shoes is his version of a chick-lit adaptation, the screenplay by Susannah Grant being based on the novel by Jennifer Weiner, and although ostensibly a comedy revolving around two very mismatched sisters, thrown together only through familial loyalty and obligation rather than any true sisterly feelings, the result is an initially agreeably acid comedy which gets increasingly sentimental the further the film goes, implausibility mounting with every development. Audiences may have trouble in accepting Toni Collette (Little Miss Sunshine / the Shaft remake) and Cameron Diaz (The Mask / There's Something About Mary) as sisters, or indeed that Diaz, who still looks dazzling even as Hanson and the make-up crew try to make her 'down' rather than 'up', hasn't been employed for more than a few days in any line of work, but Diaz's Maggie manages to make herself so irritating, and with such blindly callous behaviour, such as bedding her sister's potential boyfriend, that the emotions she stirs in others, such as her stepmother finally barring her from her house, are uttlerly understandable. Not that Collette's Rose is at times any more rational, giving up her high-powered lawyer's job to become a dog-walker, but stability of character is not exactly a strength in the script, since once the previously selfish and self-obsessed Maggie, who has left a trail of destruction behind her, arrives at the Florida hospice she is suddenly transformed into almost an angel of mercy, taking a job as a carer and altering almost out of all recognition. The shoes of the title reflect the script's chick-lit origins, with Rose's cherished shoe collection representing a lot of her memories, with incidents in her past associated with various pairs, and the idea of memory lingers through the script, but rest assured that once the past is faced even such traits as self-destructive alcoholism can be easily put behind one. Diaz and Collette have some fine scenes sparring against each other, although just why Rose doesn't take the bread knife to her sibling remains a mystery, and the scenes with an increasingly offbeat Shirley MacLaine as grandma Ella are just this side of mawkish, but if one is familiar with the conventions of the large majority of feelgood chick-lit, then nothing in the screenplay should surprise you.