Film details

Orwell Rolls in His Grave  2004

Still unavailable

Cast

  • Charles Lewis
  • Robert W. McChesney
  • Mark Crispin Miller
  • Bernie Sanders
  • Mark Lloyd
  • Greg Palast
  • Vincent Bugliosi
  • Aurora Wallace
  • Michael Moore
  • Jeff Chester
  • John Nichols

Synopsis

A documentary concerning the small number of media giants in the US which are responsible for the large majority of news and media outlets, and their pedalling of their political views in the guise of news and current affairs programmes. Companies such as Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation, owners of a huge number of newspapers around the world as well as Twentieth Century Fox and the derided Fox News, are examined for their criteria of what is considered suitable for inclusion in their news programmes and papers, how certain politicians and organisations considered contrary to the Bush government are singled out for damning copy or articles based on rumour and supposition, while members of the Bush cabinet and the Republican Party are given a far easier ride, and how certain stories, such as the hard drug abuse problem of a famous right-wing 'shock jock', or the huge increase in American poverty after President Bush's massive tax cuts for the highest earners only, are ignored or suppressed. A press conference held in September 2002 by relatives of 9-11 victims against the invasion of Iraq is singled out as an event totally ignored by the media corporations. Interviewees include Charles Lewis, a former producer for the respected US TV programme 60 Minutes, who resigned his post after what he saw as excessive political bias being imposed on his programme, and set up the pressure group The Centre For Public Integrity; John Nichols, Washington correspondent for the African-American oriented The Nation newspaper, and Bernie Sanders, an independent Vermont Congressman whose particular bone of contention is the widening gap between rich and poor in the US, and why the major organisations such as Fox News refuse to report on it. The interviewees discuss a number of topics, from the relationship between the news networks and their sponsors and advertisers, dumping any stories which may reflect badly on corporations who have bought advertising time, or the handling of the disputed Presidential election and the all-important Florida recount, especially the political pressure applied on individuals by Governor Jed Bush.

Production

Director
Robert Kane Pappas
Producer
Miriam Foley
Editor
Robert Kane Pappas
Music
Paul Chapin
Screenplay
Robert Kane Pappas
Director of Photography
Robert Kane Pappas

Review

One of the cruellest things which can happen to the contemporary documentary, dealing with events and subjects which are broadly within a range of the present day to perhaps a decade or two ago, as opposed to those dealing with more remote history, is time, and time has rendered some of Orwell Rolls In His Grave, a reference to the news-management, propaganda and twisted world of 'Newspeak' in the author's 1984, either dated or, in certain scenes, speculatively optimistic. Rarely is this better crystalisied as in some of the scenes of the 2004 election, where Michael Moore, in news footage, gravely intones the end of the Bush tenure and the ousting of the Republicans from the White House. Unfortunately the film, as well intentioned as it is, just takes on too wide a canvas, unlike the rather more successful Outfoxed, which focused exclusively on Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation and their links to the Republicans and major American corporations. Director Robert Kane Pappas makes some good points, such as the media's substitution of 'Iraqis' for Saudis as the 9/11 hijackers, thus giving President Bush a proxy vote for the invasion of Iraq in many American minds, and the quite blatant suppressing of any contrary views, any dissidents, such as actor Tim Robbins and other activists, being personally and professionally attacked in a systematic and relentless manner. The timing of the film has also missed two of Fox News' grossest excesses - one of the news anchors actually saying 'A shame it wasn't Paris' on air during a news report on the London 7/7 bombings, and their lawsuits to keep their hilariously absurd tag-line; 'Fox News - Fair And Balanced'. As critics have noted, when a news organisation has to emphasise such a fact you know it isn't. Robert Kane Pappas is obviously sincere about what he sees as corruption in the state of the U.S. media, but as with so much in an information-led era, it's yesterday's news.