Film details

Brothers  2004

Brødre / Brôdrè
Film still

Cast

  • Connie Nielsen
  • Nikolaj Lie Kaas
  • Sarah Juel Werner
  • Rebecca Løgstrup Soltau
  • Bent Mejding
  • Solbjørg Høejfeldt
  • Niels Henriksen
  • Lars Ranthe
  • André Babikian
  • Lene Maria Christensen
  • Laura Bro
  • Henrik Koefoed
  • Tom Mannion
  • Karzan Sherbayani
  • William El-gardi
  • Alex Caan
  • Sam Vincenti
  • Hossein Karimbeik
  • Hassani Shapi
  • Bjarne Antonisen
  • Morten Kirkskov
  • Claus Flygare
  • Niels Lund Boesen
  • Morten Hebsgaard
  • Michael Asmussen
  • Alexis Rodney
  • Philip Bulcock
  • Thomas Magnussen
  • Scott Farrell

Synopsis

Michael, a Danish army major seconded to the UN for peacekeeping duties in Afghanistan, picks up his brother Jannik from prison after he has served a term for armed robbery. A reunion dinner that night with Michael's family and Jannik's parents is tense and uncomfortable, the parents' disappointment with Jannik being unmistakable. Michael leaves for Afghanistan the next day, and having been sent into the field to find a missing radar operator, Niels Peter, his helicopter is shot down. Captured by the Taliban, having survived the crash, he is put in a cell with Niels Peter, although the message gets back to his wife, Sarah, that he is missing in action, believed killed. Still trying to get over the loss of her husband, Sarah asks Jannik to help her when some building chores need to be done in the kitchen and, despite previously having a guarded, wary relationship, they start to be drawn to one another. Jannik starts to become friendly with Sarah's two young daughters, and also makes contact once more with his father. Months pass and Michael and Niels are still incarcerated together until their captors enter their cell one day and tell Michael to kill Niels, or die himself. Michael manages to force himself to do so, but is riven by guilt and violent sickness afterwards. British troops storm the building where he is being held and, having been freed, he is de-briefed as to what happened, but claims he did not find Niels Peter on the search. Finally returning home, Sarah is stunned by his arrival, seeing the changes in him both physically and emotionally. He asks both Sarah and Jannik, separately, if they slept together, but he turns on Sarah when she denies it, half strangling her. His guilt also forces him to visit Niels Peter's widow, Gitte, and tell her, falsely that he thinks her husband may be still alive, wanting to give her something to believe in. His mental state crumbles to the point where Sarah is frightened to be in the same house as Michael, and after another violent incident she phones both Jannik and the Police, but Michael is now out of control and trying any tactic to try to find some sort of redemption.

Production

Director
Susanne Bier
Producer
Peter Aalbaek Jensen and Sisse Graum Olsen
Art Director
Viggo Bentzon
Editor
Adam Nielsen and Pernille Bach Christensen
Music
Johan Soderqvist
Screenplay
Anders Thomas Jensen, based on an original idea by Susanne Bier
Director of Photography
Morten Søborg

Review

Directed by Suzanne Bier, whose previous Open Hearts was a strong and impressive drama made under the Dogme manifesto, Brothers is made in the style for which the movement was formed to act as an alternative. Complex editing, camera effects, helicopter shots, elaborate locations, evocative use of music and sound effects, all are used to create an emotional drama which tries very hard to engage both the head and the heart and succeeds, to a limited degree, on both levels. Danish actress Connie Nielsen (Gladiator / One-Hour Photo) here surprisingly acting for the first time in her native language, is the central character of the story, the wife of and mother to Michael's children, but also drawn to his brother when it seems her husband is dead thousands of miles away. Ulrich Thomson gives a very strong performance as Michael, returning when least expected, but the whole set-up, collecting his brother on the eve of his mission to Afghanistan, seems a little forced, and there is a delicious irony in the fact that he is officially a peacekeeper, when all his return instigates is violence and fear. Director Bier is a little too concerned with the symmetry of the piece, both the beginning and end feature a character in prison, although some of the screenplay is sharply effective, such as the scene where Michael visits the widow of the man he was forced to kill and lies to her, determined to give her some shred of hope. It seems like a cruel scene, and one is unsure whether it is a cold taunting on his part or an attempt to truly give her something to hope for, even though it is nothing but a lie. Brothers is a dense film, and Bier is obviously using camera techniques and film making tools which were unavailable to her under the Dogme rules, but she comes up with a sometimes distressing tale of a very difficult triangle of love, fidelity and terrible familial bonds.