Film details

Must Love Dogs  2005

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Sarah Nolan, a pre-school teacher living in Los Angeles, is recently divorced and under pressure from her family to start dating again, although Sarah herself is extremely reluctant. In another part of the city boat builder Jake Anderson is also under pressure, from his friend Charlie who is determined to set him up with a girlfriend. Persuaded to try online dating, Sarah's first attempt is a disaster when the liaison she arranges turns out to be with her own widowed father, Bill, who has a string of more mature girlfriends. Her sisters work on Sarah's profile, to be posted online, and add the stipulation 'must love dogs'. The men she meets through the internet are a collection of losers, paranoids and the plain frightening, while she becomes interested in Bob Connor, the single parent of one of her pupils, although knowing that to start a relationship with him wouldn't be strictly ethical. Spotting Sarah's profile, Charlie answers it, pretending to be Jake. Sarah responds and she and Jake meet, and it is an awkward but interesting evening, arranging to see each other again, but the mutual passion of their second date fizzles when Jake does not have a condom on him. Invited by her father Bill to meet his latest girlfriend, the glamourous Dolly, Bob also arrives at the gathering, being one of Dolly's neighbours, and immediately charms Sarah's family. Sarah decides to drop in on Bob later that evening, to find him with one of her school co-workers. She returns home, only to find Jake in the company of his brother, who has been thrown out by his wife and is totally drunk, calling in on Jake for help just as Jake was on his way to see Sarah. She lets Jake take his brother into the house, just as Bob arrives to apologise, kissing Sarah on the porch. Seeing this, Jake leaves. Sarah and Bob start to date, but after they have slept together Bob seems to be less and less interested in her, Sarah finishing with him when she accepts that he just sees her as another conquest. Not knowing who the other is, Jake and Bill meet, and Jake talks of the women he fell for and lost. Meeting Sarah, Bill casually tells her of the young man he met and what he said, making Sarah realise that Jake really cared for her, but can she win him back after what happened between herself and Bob?

Production

Director
Gary David Goldberg
Producer
Gary David Goldberg, Jennifer Rodd and Suzanne Todd
Art Director
Kevin Kavanaugh
Editor
Roger Bondelli and Eric A. Sears
Music
Craig Armstrong
Screenplay
Gary Daviod Goldberg, based on the novel by Claire Cook
Director of Photography
John Bailey

Review

The big and scary world of dating, especially in the new age of online profiles and cyber-flirting, is explored in Must Love Dogs, a romantic comedy aimed at a slightly older audience than teen romances. The pic focuses on the plight of those in their thirties, and in the case of Christopher Plummer's seemingly incorigable Bill, much older, who having been told there's plenty more fish in the sea, have to dip their toes in the water again to find new relationships after divorce or the break up of a partnership. Actually the title, used as a stipulation in the online profile of Sarah (Diane Lane, who seems to have found the antidote to aging), is barely employed once contact is made with sensitive Jake (John Cusack - Grosse Point Blank / Identity), and we know he's sensitive because he's a boat builder, rather than an engineer or abattoir worker. Of course once these two meet the ending is never in doubt, but writer and director Gary David Goldberg (TV's underrated Spin City) throws several spanners in the works, such as Sarah's on-off relationship with single dad Bob (Dermot Mulroney - Young Guns / The Wedding Date) and Jake's lack of a condom on their second date, starting a passion between them which seems to fizzle out rather quickly within the timescale of the plot. Goldberg throws in a few nicely offbeat elements, such as Plummer's suave aging lothario, and Sarah's family's overwhelming obsession in finding their sister a new suitor, but this is slick and professionally made, tailored for a certain audience and quite pleasing even if you are far ahead of the script. Both Lane and Cusack have done far better, but they make a pleasant enough pair, even if it takes them a surprising amount of time to finally get together.