Film details

The Perfect Catch  2005

Fever Pitch
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Lindsey Meeks, a business consultant working in Boston, is a career-oriented lady, but becomes interested in Ben Wrightman, a school teacher who takes his class on a tour of her office for educational purposes. They plan a date, even though that night she is stricken with sudden and explosive food poisoning, which Ben uncomplainingly cleans up. Their relationship develops, and as spring approaches Ben has to confess to Lindsey his darkest, most deeply held secret - that he is an obsessionally devoted fan of the Boston Red Sox, one of the worst baseball teams in the league and rumoured to be suffering under The Curse Of The Bambino, incurred in 1920 when they sold the iconic Babe Ruth to sworn vehement rivals the New York Yankees. Lindsey agrees to accompany him to matches, never quite getting the fervour with which he follows the team, but is insulted when he refuses to go on a romantic weekend to Paris with her, preferring to attend a Red Sox game. Ben is forced into accepting that his obsession with the Sox is out of kilter with the rest of his life, and agrees to miss a home game for the first time in eleven years to go to a party with Lindsey, the theme being F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby. The couple have a terrific time but when Ben discovers the result, a remarkable turnabout victory after trailing by a major deficit, he becomes angry at missing the game, deeply wounding Lindsey who starts to realise where his priorities really lie. Starting to wonder if he many have lost Lindsey for good, Ben realises the enormity of what he has done with his overriding Sox addiction. Knowing that an associate of Lindsey, her close friend's wealthy husband, is willing to pay almost anything for Red Sox season tickets, Ben offers them to him for $125,000. Lindsey wins promotion within her office but hears what Ben is willing to do to prove he is not obsessed by the club, and races to the Fenway Stadium to try to stop Ben selling the tickets. She realises they are probably made for each other, but as ever the path of true love certainly does not run smooth....

Production

Director
Bobby Farrelly and Peter Farrelly
Producer
Drew Barrymore, Alan Greenspan, Nancy Juvonen, Gil Netter, Amanda Posey and Bradley Thomas
Art Director
Brandt Gordon
Editor
Alan Baumgarten
Music
Craig Armstrong
Screenplay
Lowell Ganz and Babaloo Mandel, based on the novel Fever Pitch by Nick Hornby
Director of Photography
Matthew F. Leonetti

Review

One of the British films which would least lend itself to an American remake, Fever Pitch, becomes The Perfect Catch which takes the bare bones of the bestseller by Nick Hornby, an inexplicable bestseller which gave inspiration to small, bald, nasal and boring one-trick-ponies everywhere, and transfers it to Boston. The country, city and sport may be different, the Boston Red Sox replacing Hornby's beloved Arsenal, and Fenway Stadium replacing Highbury, but the essence is the same, some men's overwhelming devotion to sport. Interestingly both film versions have taken a different angle than Hornby's original, looking at the relationship between the central character with his girlfriend rather than the club itself and both thankfully dump the whining self-pity which makes the later chapters in the book so unpleasant. And with such a male-oriented story it is of course the female character who comes over all the stronger, Drew Barrymore showing just why she is such a good choice for this sort of role, easily compensating for the bland performance of Jimmy Fallon, another example of why the phrase 'ex-Saturday Night Live' is now something of a threat rather than a recommendation. That Fallon's Ben is such an unbelievably kind and understanding man, and a teacher to boot, only becoming selfish and rapacious whenever his beloved Sox are involved is another element in the Farrelly formula, their films having moved away from the grossouts of Kingpin and There's Something About Mary to being rather kinder and more amiable feelgood movies, even if dealing with dubious material, such as the conjoined twins comedy Stuck On You. There's also an interesting class strand running through their relationship, he an orphan whose best friends are the fans in the seats around his while her friends are lawyers and graduates, and the pretentious party scene is very well judged. Light and frothy, and managing to keep the more obsessive side of Ben's personality both slightly alarming and constantly amusing, the Farrelly's seemed to have worked magic on the Red Sox, for decades a national joke, since the film's script had to be rewritten mid-shoot when the team, inexplicably, started winning, eventually seizing the championship for the first time since the glory days of the 20s.