Film details

Four Brothers  2005

Film still

Cast

  • Tyrese Gibson
  • Andre Benjamin
  • Garrett Hedlund
  • Terrance Dashon Howard
  • Josh Charles
  • Sofia Vergara
  • Chiwetal Ejiofor
  • Taraji P. Henson
  • Barry Shakara Henley
  • Kenneth Welsh

Synopsis

Evelyn Mercer, an elderly Detroit resident, is shopping in her local convenience store where she is caught up in a robbery and shot dead. Her funeral reunites for the first time in years her four adopted sons, Angel and Jeremiah, who are both black, and the white Bobby and Jack. The boys are visited by Police Detective Fowler and Lieutenant Green, Green having grown up on the streets with the four, and after they hear the official Police version of events the brothers decide to investigate her death themselves. Following leads and tip-offs from the streets, the four manage to track down the two gunmen involved, and after a dangerous chase on the ice-encrusted roads, the two criminals are killed. But their death just exposes a connection with a corrupt city politician, and from there to flamboyant crime lord Victor Sweet. Bobby, Jack and Angel make the alarming discovery that Jeremiah, a construction worker, was heavily in debt to Sweet, and was also the sole beneficiary of Evelyn's insurance policy. The three believe he may have been involved somehow in their mother's death but Jeremiah explains that Sweet has so many criminal activities in the city that any company working in the city has to deal with him, Sweet's political connections only increasing his leverage and power. Lieutenant Green tells the boys that their mother had been trying to expose some of Sweet's corrupt dealings, and Sweet ordered Evelyn to be killed after she started investigating his operations in her neighbourhood. He then confronts Detective Fowler, who he has found is also in league with Sweet. Fowler kills his partner without compunction. The four realise that Sweet and his minions have huge influence over the city, and will wipe out any one who tries to stand in their way, but decide that, in memory of Evelyn, they are going to try to take him down once and for all.

Production

Director
John Singleton
Producer
Lorenzo Di Bonaventura
Art Director
Andrew M.Stern
Editor
Bruce Cannon and Billy Fox
Music
David Arnold and Edward Shearmur
Screenplay
David Elliott and Paul Lovett
Director of Photography
Peter Menzies Jr.

Review

John Singleton has had one of the stranger careers in Hollywood, after being lauded as a new fresh voice in black cinema with his groundbreaking Boyz In The Hood through misfires such as Higher Learning, little-seen and poorly reviewed attempts to return to urban movies such as Baby Boy, and flirtations with big-budget cinema-fillers such as the Shaft remake and 2 Fast 2 Furious, all of which seem to indicate a filmmaker trying to balance cinematic integrity with broad box-office appeal. With the contrived Four Brothers he is a actually helming an uncredited remake of the 1965 John Wayne western The Sons Of Katie Elder, in which four disparate sons are reunited after their mother is murdered. Whereas the Wayne picture is a strong and unjustly neglected entry in his filmography, Singleton tries to shift the story to a gritty inner city setting but also mixes elements of comedy into what should be a cold and ruthless revenge story, and the plot device of having the 'brothers' adopted merely allows a mixed cast for a wider audience demographic. Four Brothers believes itself to be a tough story of revenge but fluffs its' opportunities to show real violence or the corrosiveness of vengeance, in parts turning into an awkwardly structured buddy movie, and the casting of such actors as Mark Whalberg (the Italian Job remake) and OutKast's Andre Benjamin, capable actors but rarely able to convey hint of menace or danger, doesn't help. Indeed Whalberg's role as a hitman in Kirk Wong's The Big Hit was predicated on the fact that he was actually a sweet and lovable guy, undercutting the hard-man image. One gets the feeling that instead of being closely bonded, these four would have trouble being in the same room as each other for any length of time, such is way the script treats their characters. British actor Chiwetal Ejiofor (Dirty Pretty Things / Serenity) stands out as the villainous Victor Sweet, simply because he seems to be willing to give a brash and flashy performance, well needed in a film of surprisingly low-key deliveries. Singleton has a couple of nice ideas, such as a car chase through the permanently snowy streets of Detroit, but this is better in theory than execution. The saddest element is that Singleton has now blended himself, through his choice of material, into the large number of workmanlike directors who can helm virtually any genre professionally, but with little real spark or innovation.