Film details
Manderlay 2005
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Bryce Dallas Howard
-
-
-
Isaach De Bankole
-
Zeljko Ivanek
-
Lauren Bacall
-
Jean-Marc Barr
-
Jeremy Davies
-
Clive Rowe
-
-
Udo Keir
-
Synopsis
America, 1933. After taking revenge on the town of Dogville, whose inhabitants raped her and kept her in slavery, Grace and her father, a gangster, arrive in Alabama, finding the Manderlay cotton plantation where slavery is still practiced, more than seventy years after abolition in the rest of the US. Her father leaves but Grace, shocked by what she sees, remains, teaching the slaves about democracy and bringing about their release and emancipation from their 'owners'. The cotton crop is ruined by a dust storm but the workers finds a sense of common purpose and work harder. Grace organises the rationing of food so that Clare, a young child with pneumonia, will have enough to help her recover. Grace also steps in and saves Timothy, a young slave, from a whipping. Clare dies and it is found that Wilma, an old woman, has stolen her food. Using Grace's principles of democracy, a vote is taken and the decision is that Wilma be executed, Grace carrying out the sentence herself in the interests of the majority. The harvest is taken in and, to everyone's surprise, is a bumper crop. Grace and Timothy become involved with each other. Order in the camp goes wild when it is discovered that the money earned by selling the crop has gone missing and the workers riot, killing a man suspected of taking the cash, although he is soon proved to have been innocent. Grace makes two alarming discoveries: that it was Timothy who stole the money, and some of the workers were in collusion with the previous slave regime at Manderlay, maintaining the status quo in order to have some level of power over the others. A vote is taken by the workers, who tell Grace that they have voted for a new 'owner' for the plantation, and that it is to be her. Grace is already planning to leave Manderlay and travel with her father once more, but before she does so she engineers revenge on Timothy, having him framed for a crime he did not commit, and announcing a cruel and antiquated punishment.
Production
- Director
- Lars von Trier
- Producer
- Vibeke Windeløv
- Art Director
- Peter Grant
- Editor
- Molly Marlene Stensgård
- Music
- Young Americans by David Bowie
- Screenplay
- Lars von Trier
- Director of Photography
- Anthony Dod Mantle
Review
Having made a truly striking and original film in Dogville, the first in director Lars von Trier's proposed 'American trilogy', his second entry in the saga, Manderlay, retains the production strictures of the first, with no actual set in the studio in which everything is filmed, building and rooms being delineated by lines on the floor of the stage, with characters miming the actions of opening and closing doors and going about their daily business. Many of the crew remain the same, and returning from Dogville are such cast members as Zeljko Ivanek, Lauren Bacall and Jean-Marc Barr, while the gravel tones of John Hurt are heard on the soundtrack as the impassive narrator. But the lead roles are changed, with Bryce Dallas Howard (The Village) and Willem Dafoe (Platoon) replacing Nicole Kidman and James Caan as central character Grace and her gangster father, last seen getting merciless revenge on the town of Dogville and its' inhabitants. Such is Von Trier's rabid antagonism towards the US that one doesn't have to look too far for the implicit message of Manderlay, as an interloper comes into a community offering freedom and liberation, only to eventually bring only suspicion and aggression, violence being given a legitimacy by being voted upon, thus an elderly woman may be executed with impunity since it is a majority decision. By the end of the film Grace has become the worker's new 'owner', and has once more instigated the whip, the most obvious sign and weapon of the oppressor, as the preferred tool of punishment. Von Trier's device of having no sets actually allows for several scenarios to run at once, as other characters can be seen as they go about their business, not knowing that in other houses they are being plotted against, thus the elderly Wilma is seen oblivious to her fate as her execution is agreed upon. Von Trier again gets remarkable performances to go with the bravura presentation, Danny Glover being as impressive as ever as elderly slave Wilheim, and Isaach De Bankole (Night On Earth) as Timothy, initially Grace's lover but eventually revealed to be untrustworthy, prompting a violent revenge from Grace. As with Dogville, the film ends with Young Americans by David Bowie, over a montage of photographs of US aggression, both at home and abroad. Not everybody will appreciate, or even tolerate, the production style and the mimed movements, but as with Dogville this is soon forgotten as the viewer is drawn in. Dallas Howard perhaps lacks some of the intensity of Nicole Kidman in the original, but by using a different and younger actress Von Trier is perhaps trying to see Grace as starting anew after her ordeal in Dogville, only to find another hell of her own creation. Von Trier, his work and his attitudes are certainly not for everyone, but he is making some remarkable, striking and important films.