Film details

A History of Violence  2005

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Tom Stall lives in the quiet town of Millbrook, Indiana, married to Edie, a local lawyer, and having two children, teenage son Jack and Sarah, their six-year-old daughter. After brutally murdering the staff of a motel, just another stop on their murder spree, psychotic killers Lealand Jones and Billy Onser enter the diner Tom owns in the middle of town just as it is closing and attempt to rob it, threatening his staff, but Tom manages to turn the tables on them, killing both men with a staggering efficency and violence. Tom becomes a national celebrity for his courage and bravery while he tries to play it down. Life is getting back to normal when several men in dark suits arrive in town, entering Tom's diner. Their leader is Carl Fogerty, a scarred and disfigured gangster who claims to know Tom or, as he calls him, Joey, insisting Tom is in fact a Philadelphia hood called Joey Cusack, and the man who caused Fogerty's disfigurement. They tell him his brother Richie, a powerful crime lord, wants to meet him again, years after they last saw each other. Tom insists they have the wrong man but rushes home to ensure his family is safe. Finding that his son Jack has turned on a bully who has been tormenting him, giving him a remorseless beating, Tom warns him about using violence, Jack resenting what his father is telling him. Fogerty and his hoods arrive at the house, insisting 'Joey' returns with them to Philadelphia to see Richie. Fogerty and his men pull guns but Tom once more gets the drop on them, taking out the henchmen before facing an armed and lethal Fogerty. The scarred gangster is shotgunned by Jack, who saves his father's life. Wounded and in hospital, Tom is confronted by Edie, who wants the truth. Tom confesses that he actually is Joey Cusack, but turned his back on crime years previously, making a new life for himself as 'Tom Stall'. Leaving hospital the atmosphere with his family is fraught, and Edie refuses to be in the same room with him, although an argument turns into animalistic sex. Tom / Joey knows what he has to do, and when he receives a phone call from Philadelphia he climbs into his car to confront his past once and for all.

Production

Director
David Cronenberg
Producer
Chris Bender and J.C. Spink
Art Director
Carol Spier
Editor
Ronald Sanders
Music
Howard Shore
Screenplay
Josh Olson, based on the graphic novel by John Wagner and Vince Locke
Director of Photography
Peter Suschitzky

Review

Avoiding some of Cronenberg's earlier and little-seen movies, such as 1979's car race movie Fast Company, A History of Violence, adapted from a rightly-praised graphic novel, is perhaps his most commercially accessible film in many years, since The Dead Zone, despite the bursts of violence which Cronenberg is keen to show not only as acts of brutality and finality but also makes the audience see the consequences, and an early shot on one of the diner robbers after Viggo Mortenson\\s Tom has dealt with him is unflinching and uncomfortable. For once not directing from his own script, A History Of Violence is also surprisingly linear, but in typical Cronenberg style one starts to dread what may occur rather than that which does, although he is not afraid to show exactly what his 'hero' Tom / Joey is capable of, and the revelation of Tom's real identity is actually not too much of a surprise after seeing him 'in action'. Cronenberg also establishes his central character's credentials early. We have seen what the murderous pair of psychos are capable of while the credits are still rolling, but even they with their guns and mania are essentailly no match for Mortensen, which leads to feelings of true dread which the director, cleverly and tellingly, uses in the family scenes, building tension so that the merest family disagreement threatens to detonate into another few seconds of sickening violence. Mortensen gives a very good performance as the man who has been hiding for years, having subsumed his own murderous identity so far that he now has a wife and family who are unaware of his previous life, and even when this is exposed there is still an animalistic attraction between himself and Edie, scenes which end in telling self-disgust on behalf of his wife. Apart from an uncomfortable discussion with the local Sheriff, who is suspicious that Tom is not telling the full story of what has happened, one can excuse the lack of Police intervention by the fact that the events of the film happen over a comparatively short period of time, Stall / Cusack forced into action after years of being hidden away in another identity. William Hurt's Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination is a surprise, given his actual amount of screen time, although he is involved in perhaps the only humorous moment of the film, darkly comic though it is, when the contributions of Maria Bello, superb as the confused and frightened Edie, and Ed Harris as the scary Fogerty would seem to be far more deserving of such a consideration. The movie may not have the graphic bodily horror of the director's earlier films, or the sheer perversity of Crash, but, as with his criminally underrated Spider, shows that David Cronenberg is one of the most skilled and talented directors currently working.