Film details
Just Like Heaven 2005
If Only It Were True
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Mark Ruffalo
-
Donal Logue
-
Dina Waters
-
Ben Shenkman
-
Jon Heder
-
Ivena Milicevic
-
Caroline Aaron
-
Rosalind Chao
-
Ron Canada
-
Willie Garson
-
Gabrielle Made
Synopsis
Elizabeth Masterson, a dedicated Doctor in a San Francisco ER, is driving home after a long shift when she is involved in a head-on collision and killed. David, a landscape gardener, still grieving the loss of his wife, finds an advert for sub-letting Elizabeth's apartment blowing on the wind, and moves in, and is amazed to find her spirit still within the flat, not realising that she is dead. They argue about who should be the tenant until David manages to convince Elizabeth that she has died, and is standing in the middle of a table, having passed through the solid wood. Seeing she is stunned and upset, and seemingly unable to let go of her earthly ties, David offers to help her pass over to whatever spirit world lies on the other side, but despite the efforts of various psychics and exorcists, none of them are able to see her, and Elizabeth remains firmly in the real world, forcing the pair to believe that in some way Elizabeth cannot be really dead. With memories of her past life returning slowly, she recalls being a doctor, and she and David visit the hospital where she worked, only to find that she is there in a deep, seemingly irreversible coma. Realising she can only be liberated if her mortal body is allowed to die, David approaches her sister, Abby, asking for permission to turn off her life-support machine, claiming to know that it is what she would have wanted but she refuses. When he tries to explain that he is in contact with her spirit, caught in an earthly limbo, she refuses to believe him. Although Abby changes her mind, and decides to have her taken off life-support, David and Jack, his psychiatrist friend, steal her body from the hospital, David having a crazy idea that he may be able to somehow bring her back to life, but they are stopped as they try to escape with her body, and David knows he has to risk everything to bring her back from the edge of death.
Production
- Director
- Mark Waters
- Producer
- Laurie MacDonald and Walter F.Parkes
- Art Director
- Maria Baker
- Editor
- Bruce Green
- Music
- Rolfe Kent
- Screenplay
- Peter Toland and Leslie Dixon, based on the novel If Only It Were True / Et Si C'Etait Vrai.... by Marc Levy
- Director of Photography
- Daryn Okada
Review
Although based on a novel by French writer Marc Levy, published under the original title If Only It Were True / Et Si C'Etait Vrai.... in 1999, Just Like Heaven is a pleasant, amiable and utterly derivative romantic comedy which borrows wholesale from the likes of Ghost and the hugely popular Topper series of the 40s, carried heavily by the leading trio of Reese Witherspoon (Legally Blonde), Mark Ruffalo (We Don't Live Here Anymore) and Donal Logue (TV's Grounded For Life / E.R.), which make it far more watchable than the occasionally twee story may merit. The winsome Witherspoon plays Elizabeth, a dedicated ER doctor who hits the emergency room herself after tangling with a truck, and not even the tender ministrations of her colleagues can save her. But she refuses to believe she's dead, returning to her own apartment, now being let by the emotionally wrought David (Ruffalo), who is coping with emotional trauma of his own following the death of his wife. He's also the only one who can see Elizabeth and has to try to convince her she's no longer in the land of the living, to no avail, so has to bring in a variety of exorcists and mediums (a la Ghost) to finally give her whatever impetus she needs to move on, until he finally, by about the seventh reel wonders if there is a reason why she seems so spectral, yet so Earthbound. There are a couple of nice touches, such as the inference that, in different ways, they are both trapped by their emotions and have to somehow try to move on, and director Mark Waters has had a couple of solid hits with the remake of Freaky Friday and the Lindsay Lohan starrer Mean Girls, and can handle the sometimes very sharp and clever exchanges between the two, each believing, with good reason, that they are the one in the right, but there is no escaping that, literary origins aside, there is rather a lot here which has turned up in every spectral comedy from The Ghost And Mrs. Muir onwards, and Ruffalo's performance is at times a little too intense for what should be an essentially light-hearted story, David being trapped between life and death in ways very similar to Elizabeth. The strength of the performances cover a lot of the plot's deficiencies, and Witherspoon once again shows she has a truly sparkling screen presence, but this has very much all been seen before, just not all in the same place at the same time.