Film details
Merry Christmas 2005
Joyeux Noel
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Benno Furmann
-
-
Gary Lewis
-
Ian Richardson
-
Daniel Bruhl
-
Guillaume Canet
-
Dany Boon
-
Alex Ferns
-
Michel Serrault
-
Christopher Fulford
-
Frank Witter
-
Steven Robertson
Synopsis
Christmas Eve 1914, and on the Western Front the war is raging, and thousands of soldiers are suffering the horrors of trench warfare. In the afternoon battalions of German, French and Scottish soldiers all cease fire and put down their arms. Tentatively they venture out into the no-man's-land between their trenches, shaking hands and trying to converse in their respective languages. They sing carols, show each other photographs of the families they have left behind, share drinks and cigarettes. The impromptu ceasefire is also used as an opportunity to retrieve their dead and give them some form of burial. Among those involved are Nikolaus Sprink, a prominent German opera singer who is also a friend of the Crown Prince. He is being visited at the front by Anna Sorensen, his Danish lover who is kept far away from the violence and horror of the front line. On the French side is Lieutenant Audebert, whose family are trapped behind the German lines in occupied France. Among the Scots are Palmer, a non-combatant priest who acts as a stretcher bearer and medical orderly, and the determined Lieutenant Gordon. Viewing the proceedings with mixed feelings is Lieutenant Horstmayer, a German of Jewish descent. Palmer gives a sermon which emphasises brotherhood and the settling of differences, but news of the ceasefire and fraternisation gets back to the military hierarchy and they threaten the junior officers with court martial if they do not return to their own lines and resume hostilities. His conscience being badly affected, Sprink surrenders to the French soldiers before the ceasefire is called off. Another French soldier, on a mission of mercy involving Audebert's beleaguered family, is accidentally shot by his own side in a case of mistaken identity. Palmer is personally dressed down by his bishop and told to leave the front line and return to his parish, his presence being regarded as a distraction. On Christmas Day, the shooting and shelling starts once more.
Production
- Director
- Christian Carion
- Producer
- Christophe Rossignon
- Art Director
- Vraciu Eduard Daniel
- Editor
- Andrea Sedlackova
- Music
- Philippe Rombi
- Screenplay
- Christian Carion
- Director of Photography
- Walther van den Ende
Review
The Christmas Eve truce of 1914 has spawned many books and even a tolerable single by Paul McCartney (Pipes Of Peace), the video for which illustrated the no-man's-land truce, but while the servicemen and ordinary soldiers were fraternising and taking a respite from the horrors of trench warfare, the officers on all sides, far away from the front line obviously, were not impressed and demanded a return to hostilities immediately. Director Christian Carion handles the situation with gravity and manages to avoid a lot of the awkward conventions of war movies by having the characters largely speaking in their own languages, subtitled when necessary. Some of the characters, such as the opera singer Nikolas Sprink, are based on fact, even if the idea that his lover, Anna Sorenson (Diana Kruger - Troy / Wicker Park) is visiting him at the front seems far-fetched. Carion also manages to keep the heroics to a minimum, the real acts of heroism coming from defiance - Palmer preaching for friendship and unity, an act which could be construed as treason by the top brass, and an officer trying to get at least a message to Audebert's besieged family. The film recreates the hellish conditions, which are surely familiar to most war movie viewers by now, but doesn't have a lasting image, such as the hand reaching out to the butterfly in Milestone's All Quiet On The Western Front, which defines it and its' view. The message is sadly old, that war is hell and the officers are the ones who send the truly brave to their deaths, but Carion's film is sincere and genuine, and a fine remembrance of the events of that particular Christmas Eve.