Film details

Bee Season  2005

Film still

Cast

  • Flora Cross
  • Max Minghella
  • Kate Bosworth
  • Corey Fischer
  • Sam Zuckerman
  • Joan Mankin
  • Piers MacKenzie
  • Lorri Holt
  • Brian Leonard
  • Kathy McGraw

Synopsis

Eliza Naumann, the daughter of a religious and scholarly family living in Oakland, California, feels neglected by her seemingly distracted parents in favour of her brother, Aaron, who is a musical prodigy. Her father Saul, a professor of religious studies, and her mother Miriam, a scientist, seem more involved with their own problems rather than Eliza's, and are surprised when she wins a school spelling bee contest. Competing in the district competition, her family are there when Eliza wins. Saul sees that she seems to enter a trance like state when she spells the required words, claiming she hears a word's 'voice' as she spells it, and he starts to coach her himself, using techniques connected with the cult of Kabbala. Miriam is worried about Eliza, and how deeply she seems to become involved in the contests, as well as suffering crippling flashbacks about her own parent's death in a car crash, her mental state forcing her into acts of kleptomania, escalating into breaking into stranger's houses to steal worthless trinkets. No longer the focus of the family's attention, Aaron finds himself attracted by a Hare Krishna group, one of their devotees, a young woman called Chali, in particular. As Eliza progresses through further spelling bee rounds, Saul start to induct her in arcane and bizarre religious chanting rituals, believing it will open up parts of her mind to hidden knowledge, Saul increasingly ignoring Miriam, who is hospitalised after being found in a stranger's home, being sent to a mental institution. As Miriam's condition is examined, Saul is shown the evidence of just how far her mental state had imploded when he sees what she had stolen and what she had done with it, as Aaron leaves home for the Hare Krishna centre and Eliza qualified for the national spelling bee final. Realising how fragmented and unhappy her family are, Eliza knows what she has to do to reunite them.

Production

Director
Scott McGehee and David Siegel
Producer
Albert Berger and Ron Yerxa
Art Director
Michael E. Goldman
Editor
Lauren Zuckerman and Martin Walsh
Music
Peter Nashel
Screenplay
Naomi Foner Gyllenhaal, based on the novel by Myla Goldberg
Director of Photography
Gilles Nuttgens

Review

Directed by Scott McGehee and David Siegel, who helmed the excruciating Suture and the slightly less indulgent The Deep End, and taken from a 2000 bestseller, Bee Season isn't, as the title may suggest, a Pixar-style cartoon revolving around a hive and its inhabitants but a drama revolving around that typically American obsession the spelling bee, the subject of the hit documentary Spellbound. Unfortunately, like Suture, while the film may be technically slick and skilfully efficient, its' also slightly hollow and cold, the audience never connecting with any of the characters which also asks us to believe Richard Gere is Saul Neumann, a Jewish biblical scholar who is becoming involved with Kabbalah, Madonna's now passe branch of designer Judaism. He's unable to leave the job at the office, neglecting Miriam (Juliette Binoche in a role which asks her to descend into not totally convincing madness) and his children Eliza and Aaron, although the latter gets his attention through his musical ability. Eleven year old Eliza (Flora Cross - Margot At The Wedding) is involved in spelling bees, eventually rising to the national finals, Saul diverting his obsession to Eliza so that she will win, but son Aaron develops a sudden and rather unbelievable interest in the Hare Krishna faith and Miriam has started visiting strange houses late at night, stealing small items, the manifestations of a far more severe mental condition. It's a complex story, but considerably simplified from the novel, which delves far deeper into the religious and theological aspects of the story, but while the co-directors handle it perfectly professionally and efficiently, there is actually very little sympathy to be felt for almost anybody in the family bar young Eliza, having to put up with parents who only notice her when she threatens to become academically famous, albeit tangentally, Gere's seemingly devoted scholar becoming particularly creepily involved with her, making her chant strange Kabbalistic rhymes which he claims will lead her nearer to God. Obviously wanting to be more than just the story of a family whose child becomes involved in a high-profile contest, the script by Naomi Foner Gyllenhaal wants to add additional layers at every juncture, and despite the precise and honed filmmaking, Bee Season starts to get less and less involving the more complex and entwined it becomes.