Film details

The Proposition  2005

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

The late 1880s, and in the Australian Outback two outlaws, Charlie Burns and his brother Mike, only fourteen years old, are captured after a violent gunfight, British law enforcer Captain Stanley leading the mission to catch them. The pair face charges of rape and murder, as does their older brother, Arthur. In prison Stanley makes Charlie a proposition - to bring in Arthur Burns, who has a reputation for insane and psychotic violence, dead or alive, or Mike will be hanged on Christmas Day, which is only nine days away. Charlie reluctantly agrees, knowing that the ruthless, dedicated Stanley will carry out his threat, and rides out. Finding out from an eccentric bounty hunter, Jellon Lamb, that Arthur is in the mountains, Lamb tells him that Arthur has gone native. Eden Fletcher, a local landowner, hears of the deal that Stanley has brokered, and turns the townspeople against him, demanding Mike to be dragged out before the mob to be mercilessly flogged, an action to which Stanley has to reluctantly agree. Returning home to his wife, Martha, Stanley is surprised to find he approves of the flogging, since her close friend, who was heavily pregnant, was one of the Burns' victims, but Stanley knows that this will only incite the Burns brothers, both Charlie and Arthur, yet further. Riding deep into the outback, Charlie is attacked by murderous Aboriginals, but Charlie arrives and saves him, killing several in the process. Taken to Charlie's gang hideout, deep in a rocky outcrop, Charlie sees that his brother has edged ever further into all-out madness, while Arthur surprises him by telling Charlie he knows he is here to kill him, and instead proposes that they indeed work together to spring Mike from jail and kill Stanley. The Captain sends out a troop of men to track down the Aboriginals, who have been attacking white settlers, but Arthur and Charlie ambush them, taking their uniforms and killing the soldiers. Disguised as the soldiers they arrive back in the town on Christmas Day, preparing to free Mike and attack Stanley, but what they discover sends Arthur into an insane rage as he attacks Stanley and Martha in their home as they settle down to Christmas dinner, and Charlie realises that a desperate and final choice has to be made.

Production

Director
John Hillcoat
Producer
Chris Brown, Chiara Manage, Jackie O'Sullivan and Cat Villiers
Art Director
Bill Booth and Marita Mussett
Editor
Jon Gregory
Music
Nick Cave and Warren Ellis
Screenplay
Nick Cave
Director of Photography
Benoit Delhomme

Review

Essentially a Western in form, The Proposition reminds one that even as the West was being tamed and mythologised, there was an equally dangerous frontier, comprising settlers, natives and a decided blurring of law and justice happening on the other side of the world, as Australia became the newest frontier and which, unlike the USA, still has vast tracts which are largely unexplored, and certainly uninhabited by anybody but the true Aboriginals even today. Directed by John Hillcoat (1988's Ghosts Of The Civil Dead), this represents a reunion with the always fascinating musician Nick Cave, who wrote the surprisingly compelling screenplay, having appeared in Civil Dead and co-written the script. Recreating the period brilliantly. Australia is shown as an unforgiving land, where the sheer bleakness of the barren landscapes, and the fact that the settlers have literally had to build everything from scratch has made them bitter and despondent. The Burns brothers, who would have been eulogised in American outlaw mythology, are thugs, plain and simple, with Arthur (a simmering performance from the always impressive Danny Huston) having becoming uncontrollably sadistic and savage, while even the fourteen year old Mike (Noah Taylor) has seemingly joined in the family trade of robbery, violence and rape. Guy Pearce's gaunt looks are well suited to the torn Charlie, wanting to save both brothers but slowly realising that Arthur is almost too dangerous to be left alive, while the real surprise is Ray Winstone as the Captain. All too often being cast as a loud, shouting ranter, Winstone provides a performance of genuine quiet strength, truly loving his wife (an underused Emily Watson - Breaking The Waves) but also wanting to uphold high standards of the law, yet knowing that his deal with Charlie Burns is going to end badly. Stanley manages to come over as hard as nails and yet deeply sensitive at the same time, with Winstone giving a real sad depth to the man. Hillcoat gets good performances from all the cast, even if John Hurt is allowed to be a little too broad as the eccentric yet dangerous and duplicitous bounty hunter Jellon Lamb. Cave's screenplay paces the piece very well, maintaining tension and using the sporadic violence extremely well, delivering it with maximum impact, and the sudden jolt of an Aboriginal literally having half his head shot away is truly effective in showing the finality of violence and death. Hillcoat also builds towards a certain finality, with the Burns descending on the Stanley household as they settle down to as traditional Christmas as best they can manage in ninety degree weather, and the final scenes are remorselessly cruel, with the inevitable aftermath of what has transpired being a burden the characters will somehow have to carry. Beautifully shot on genuine locations by the very talented Benoit Delhomme (Cyclo / 1408), and with terrific performances throughout, The Proposition is a brutal, slowly-building piece of work which truly rewards the viewer who perseveres, although some may find it a proposition they resist through the very real and rawly depicted but sadly inevitable brutality involved.