Film details
The Aristocrats 2005
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Penn Jilette
-
Teller
-
-
Jon Stewart
-
George Carlin
-
Billy Connelly
-
-
Steven Wright
-
-
Emo Phillips
-
Richard Lewis
-
Paul Reiser
Synopsis
A documentary concerning the joke / story known in the world of stand-up comedians as 'The Aristocrats', a long and rambling story involving a performer approaching a vaudeville agent with the details of an act he and his family have devised. A catalogue of perversion, bestiality, incest and every vile deviation possible follows, stunning the agent. When he finally recovers the capacity to speak he asks the man the name of the act, only to get the reply 'The Aristocrats'..... Once rarely a joke performed in public, it is seen as a peer-to-peer challenge, with fellow comedians seeing who can get the most bizarre, outrageous and inventive spin on the oft-told story. A range of comedians tell their own version and give their theories on why it is seen as a testing ground for comics. George Carlin, the veteran whose most famous routine is 'The seven words you can't say on television' uses them all, and more, in his rapid-fire version. Steven Wright delivers his in his trademark deadpan style. Other performers include Billy Connelly, Jon Stewart (TV's The Today Show), Chris Rock (Madagascar), Eddie Izzard, Dana Carvey (Wayne's World), Hank Azaria (TV's The Simpsons) and Howie Mandel, now interestingly the host of the US version of TV game show Deal Or No Deal. American stand-up Gilbert Gottfried is seen delivering the joke at a function celebrating Hugh Hefner in September 2001. That Gottfried's delivery was hugely successful, with some audience members actually on the floor with laughter is all the more remarkable given that he had just made a badly judged 9-11 remark and felt they were turning on him. The most elaborate and purely physical variation on the theme is given by the silent comedian Billy The Mime.
Production
- Director
- Paul Provenza and Penn Jillette
- Producer
- Peter Alan Golden
- Editor
- Emery Emery and Paul Provenza
- Music
- Gary Stockdale
- Director of Photography
- Paul Provenza, Michael Lynn, Tristan Prescott and others
Review
To call a comedy a one joke movie is generally an insult, but with The Aristocrats it can't help being the term applied. Long known within comedic circles as almost a rites of passage joke, the story at the heart of the film was better known for being passed around comedians rather than performed for the public. One may think the movie, co-directed by Penn Jillette of Penn and Teller fame may be repetitive but it is part of the joke's attraction that it gives itself over to infinite variation, tailored to the individual comic's style, although perhaps the contribution from Billy The Mime is an idea which shouldn't have made the final cut. What sets the story apart from a lot of other gags is the fact that it is essentially totally free form between the initial set-up and the unvarying punchline, allowing the teller to take the story wherever he or she pleases within the boundaries of their imaginations. Interestingly the gag still has power to provoke and shock after the ten or twentieth telling, such is the latitude given and the inventiveness involved. Of course part of the fun comes with seeing famous faces coming out with such a vile and often scatological joke, with George Carlin using all the seven words you can't use on TV, and a few more besides, and it's a surprise to see well established faces such as Paul Reisner (TV's anodyne Crazy About You), Drew Carey and even veteran Larry Storch (the vintage TV series F Troop) coming out with material which would get them thrown off TV for good. Similarly several Christopher Guest collaborators, such Michael McKean, Harry Shearer and Fred Willard, show just why they fit in so well to Guest's barely-scripted productions. Funny certainly, shocking definitely, and it goes without saying, not one for the prudish. Would love to see the US network TV version of this one....