Film details

Capote  2005

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

15th November 1959, and news breaks of a multiple killing in the small town of Holcomb in Kansas. The victims are four members of the Clutter family, found brutally murdered at their farmhouse home. An investigation is launched under the command of veteran cop Alvin Dewey. Writer Truman Capote reads of the murders in The New York Times, and contacts William Shawn, editor of the renowned New Yorker magazine suggesting he goes to Holcomb to cover the murders, to use as a piece on how such a small community reacts to such a crime within their midst and also to form the basis of his next book, describing it as a 'non-fiction novel', telling Shawn he expects it to be the best thing he has ever written. Capote travels to the town with his close friend Nelle Harper Lee, also a writer and, after making contact with chief investigator Dewey, Capote trying to flatter the police officer into parting with sensitive information, he starts to interview those involved with the discovery of the bodies. On 30th December, two suspects are arrested in Las Vegas. They are Perry Smith and Dick Hickcock, both young ex-convicts. The trial is quickly organised and in March 1960 both men are found guilty and are sentenced to death. Capote is a constant visitor to to the pair on death row, trying to prise every last gruesome details out of them concerning the murders, Capote becoming captivated by the vicious but cunning Perry Smith. He pretends to befriend them and hires an appeal lawyer on their behalf, all with the ulterior motive of keeping them alive so he can extract more and more information for the book. The multiple appeal process eventually lasts five years, and Capote finds himself trapped by what he has engineered. Having decided on a title for his book, In Cold Blood, which Dewey asks if it refers to the murders or Capote's manipulation of Smith and Hickcock, he is unable to finish it until the trial verdict is finally decided. He starts to drink even heaver than usual and is constantly battling self-doubt, for the first time in his life, and severe depression. Harper Lee also turns against him, berating him when she realises how he tried to control the process of law for his own ends. The final appeal fails and a date for the executions is set, and although this seems to be the end for Capote and the tortuous path his book has taken to completion, he knows the personal cost has been too high.

Production

Director
Bennett Miller
Producer
Caroline Baron, Michael Ohoven and William Vince
Art Director
Gordon Peterson
Editor
Christopher Tellefsen
Music
Mychael Danna
Screenplay
Dan Futterman, based on the book by Gerald Clarke
Director of Photography
Adam Kimmel

Review

Avoiding the sympathetic angle taken by both Iris and Sylvia, both recent literary film biographies, which felt empathy with their central characters, Bennett Miller's Capote takes a very different and probably much more accurate view of its' protagonist, casting Truman Capote as a pariah who swooped on the Clutter family murder case in order to essentially make a quick buck, but soon found himself consumed by not only the story and circumstances but also the protagonists, particularly Perry Smith, the film hinting that his attraction to Smith kept him involved with the case, which eventually destroyed him. Not immediately but gradually, considering that he never wrote another book, just magazine articles, turned to drink and drugs even more heavily than usual, and essentially turned into a parody of himself, itself a feat considering his appearance and demeanour, all though what he experienced while writing what became In Cold Blood. Capote is a film which holds many surprises, from the intelligent and incisive screenplay by actor Dan Futterman (Shooting Fish / The Birdcage) to the remarkable, and eventually Oscar-winning performance from Philip Seymour Hoffman, which seems outlandish casting when one considers their comparative heights and girths, Capote being small and owlish where Hoffman is tall, burly and wide-shouldered, but director Miller manages to frame the scenes so that this is generally not noticeable. Hoffman also manages to get Capote's piping, high-pitched voice just right, turning every sentence into a wheedling drone, which is entirely accurate. But Hoffman is only one of a collection of excellent performances ranging from the veteran cop Alvin Dewey (Chris Cooper - Silver City), who sees through Capote and his motives, to Clifton Collins Jr. (Babel) as Perry Smith, with whom it becomes obvious Capote is entranced. Catherine Keener (Being John Malkovich) is also impressive as Harper Lee who, oddly, had a parallel career to Capote in publishing only one book, but in her case it was the seminal To Kill A Mockingbird, and Lee's retreat from the public eye was purely of her own choosing. An exemplary case of how to handle the literary biography, Capote debunks the man without undue malice but rather by focusing on the machinations which eventually turned him into what he was, in his dealing with the two murderers, and his seeding of false hope by handling their appeals, he became nearly as much of a monster as those he wrote about.