Film details
Good Night, and Good Luck 2005
Still unavailable
Cast
-
David Strathairn
-
-
Robert Downey Jr
-
Frank Langella
-
-
Jeff Daniels
-
Ray Wise
-
Reed Diamond
-
Tate Donovan
-
Grant Heslov
-
Thomas McCarthy
-
Synopsis
October, 1953, and the CBS weekly evening news programme, See It Now, is fronted by respected journalist and broadcaster Edward R. Murrow, who works with a small team in Studio 41, alongside his producer, Fred Friendly. The case of an Irish-American US Navy pilot, Milo Radulovich, is brought to his attention, having been discharged from the Navy for being declared a security risk, secret evidence being presented at his trial and not disclosed within the courtroom. Murrow and Friendly decide to make the story their lead, despite the trial being part of the ongoing 'witch-hunt' trials being led by Junior Senator Joseph McCarthy, a man seemingly obsessed with proving Communist infiltration in the US Government, armed forces and media; William Paley, the head of CBS, backs their decision, but warns them that the programme's sponsors, ALCOR, a large aluminium manufacturer, may not be pleased. Friendly is visited by two military officers, Colonels Anderson and Jenkins, concerning the report, making thinly veiled threats, but he refuses to bend to their demand to approve the film before transmission. The programme goes out and is highly praised in some papers, including the influential New York Times, but others, urged by McCarthy, review it badly, and make smears and accusations against Murrow and his affiliations, none of which are true, and also attack his colleagues, one of whom, TV anchor and reporter Dan Hollenbeck, is suffering due to his wife leaving him. Murrow responds with a programme dealing directly with McCarthy, using film of him to expose his lies, hypocrisy, bullying and harassing tactics which go completely against the US Constitution. At McCarthy's behest the press attack Murrow's friends and associates, again coming in for smears and abuse. Dan Hollenbeck, already depressed, commits suicide after a particularly vitriolic attack. McCarthy produces his response to Murrow, which is broadcast on the programme, calling Murrow and those in his team part of the 'jackal pack' and calling them known Communist sympathisers and fellow travellers, all of which is false. McCarthy brings to trial Annie Lee Moss, a lowly Pentagon office worker he claims has been intercepting secret messages in the coderoom of the Pentagon, and tries to bully and threaten the middle-aged woman, previously a canteen worker. She denies everything, telling him that she has never so much as been in the coderoom and the crowd realise that McCarthy obviously has the wrong person, and take against his threats against this slight black woman, having banned her defence counsel from speaking in the trial chamber. McCarthy quickly and rapidly excuses himself after just seven questions, claiming an appointment in the evening, causing another, Senator John McClennan, to furiously and loudly turn against the other members of the hearing, calling what they are doing and what they stand for 'evil'. The news team hear that Milo Radulovich is to be reinstated, the court changing their mind on the validity of secret evidence. The news breaks that McCarthy is to be investigated himself for his actions when trying to bring major Army figures to trial, the Senator having finally fatally overreached himself. The See It Now team are vindicated. Bill Paley calls Murrow and Friendly into his office. The main sponsors, ALCOR, have pulled out of supporting the programme, and they do not believe they will be able to find new sponsors. Paley has plans for See It Now, and Murrow knows that bringing down McCarthy has come at a large price.
Production
- Director
- George Clooney
- Producer
- Grant Heslov
- Art Director
- Christa Munro
- Editor
- Stephen Mirrione
- Music
- Various
- Screenplay
- George Clooney and Grant Heslov
- Director of Photography
- Robert Elswit
Review
The second directorial outing for George Clooney, the small-scale and compactly made and edited Good Night, And Good Luck is both a superb exercise in style and a very serious and openly political film, mixing genuine drama with a cogent sub-text, and what one imagines may be a lesson for many viewers, just how utterly pernicuous and genuinely sinister the 'witch-hunt' led by the extraordinary Senator Joseph McCarthy really was and the ends to which he was willing to go in order to implement what he saw was virtually a holy war against perceived Communists. Never mind evidence or proof, these were mere details to be ignored in McCarthy's quest, and when Ed Murrow and his news team on his programme See It Now dared to expose his unconstitutional, bullying methods, and the fact that when, as with so many cases, there was no evidence against the accused, McCarthy and his cabal just invented claims and accusations, it quickly transpired that Murrow and his team, including his producer Fred Friendly (played with an admirable limiting of his own screen time by director Clooney himself), were to be targeted ruthlessly, through the right-wing press and the Senator's own rantings. Clooney has called it a celebration of a period in television when the news was actually regarded as something important, to be taken seriously because it dealt with serious subjects, important to everyone, and the film is bracketed with Murrow (a superb performance from David Strathairn - The Bourne Ultimatum / The Uninvited) addressing an audience of TV reporters and producers, already decrying what he sees has happened to TV news in the four years which have passed since his dealings with McCarthy in 1953 / 54. Clooney keeps the drama very tight, and as if to add to the intimate feel of the piece, shot in crisp black and white by Robert Elswit (Tomorrow Never Dies / There Will Be Blood), there are no exteriors in the entire movie, and most of it takes place in CBS Studio 41 where the team was based, jammed into the control room, huddled over small monitors, and with Friendly being hidden under Murrow's desk in order to give him live cues by tapping his leg with a pen. What comes across was how powerful McCarthy was, having gained power because anyone who stood in his way was immediately denounced as a 'pinko' or a Communist, and how Murrow was literally risking his entire career and reputation, including his famous reports from London during the Battle of Britain, on his belief that McCarthy was doing the country incredible damage, and had to be stopped by using the most dangerous weapon of all - the truth. A device of having the soundtrack composed of jazz standards, impeccably sung by Dianne Reeves, through having them being recorded in the CBS Studios, is a cleverly unobtrusive way of getting them into the film, and if a couple of Murrow's references, particularly to US foreign policy in the Middle East, seem incongruous, screenplay writers Clooney and Grant Heslov point to the fact that all Murrow's 'on-air' speeches are taken from transcripts and recordings. Where Clooney shows real restraint is in letting two major sequences, McCarthy's response to Murrow on his programme, and the questioning of Annie Lee Ross, where he just gets up and excuses himself after just seven questions, seeing how completely wildly inaccurate and false his accusations are, and the Committee is then furiously harangued and lambasted by Senator John McClennan, are largely shown as real news footage, the latter shown almost in its' entirety, which only adds to its' considerable power as a pivotal moment where McCarthy realises the tide was turning against him. The makers make a good choice in not having an actor portray McCarthy, instead only having him seen in genuine news footage, a slovenly man with a bizarre self-righteous regard, an opportunist on the make, pandering to Reds-under-the-bed hysteria, and the scenes of him facing his own witch-hunt in the Army / McCarthy hearings are satisfying indeed. Clooney casts well and gets excellent performances across the board, particularly from Strathairn, Robert Downey Jr (returning to Hollywood before Iron Man made his comeback official), Frank Langella, very fine as the tolerant but increasingly pressured head of CBS Bill Paley, and some fine scenes from Ray Wise (TV's Reaper) as the tragic Dan Hollenbeck, although the role played by Jeff Daniels, as CBS executive Sigfried Mickelson, seems to have been curtailed in the cutting room. With a title which was Murrow's traditional sign-off line, he of course did not bring down the large-scale investigations by himself, but the film is a fine tribute to a courageous man, who would die in 1965 of lung cancer, and when one sees the incredible amount of smoking down in the film it comes as no real surprise, and another indication that Clooney is a truly talented director, with a real feel for actors and genuine drama.