Film details

Munich  2005

Still unavailable

Cast

  • Ciaran Hinds
  • Mathieu Kazzovicz
  • Hanns Zischler
  • Josse-Marie Corze
  • Ayelet Zurer
  • Michel Lonsdale
  • Mortiz Bleibtreu
  • Yvan Attal
  • Amos Lavie

Synopsis

After eleven members of the Israeli Olympic team are held hostage in Munich in 1972, all the athletes, as well as their kidnappers, members of the Palestinian Black September movement, are killed in a disastrous shoot-out at Munich Airport. Avner, a former bodyguard of Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir, is recruited by Ephraim, a Mossad officer to be part of a special covert unit to go to Europe to hunt down eleven men they claim were involved with the organisation and implementation of the Munich attack. Avner, married to the now-pregnant Daphna, is reluctant to leave her for what could be a mission lasting many months, but is finally coerced into agreeing. With funds paid into a bank account in Switzerland, he is told that should they be caught or killed there is no record of them, and they are on their own. The rules are few, except chasing their targets into Arab countries. In Germany Avner meets the other members of the team - Robert, a Belgian bomb maker; Hans, a communications expert and forger; Carl, an older man, seemingly the organiser and overseer, and Steve, their driver, a South African Jew with a bloodthirsty ruthless streak. They find their first victim in Rome, Zwaiter, a Palestinian organiser, and shoot him in the foyer of his building, In Paris, Avner meets the mysterious Louis, who claims to represent an organisation which sells secret and sensitive information to any body except governments. Louis demands huge amounts of money but also locates several of the men they are after, the team carrying out kills in both Paris, firstly financier Hamshari, planting a bomb in the man's apartment and only just avoiding killing his young daughter, and another in Cyprus. Avner makes an unauthorised return to Israel to see his newly-born daughter, and also to tell Daphna to leave Israel and move to New York, telling her she will be safer there and it will also be easier for him to visit them. Avner hears from Louis that three of their most important targets are currently in Beirut, Avner then telling Ephraim, who informs the Israeli Army. A commando raid is carried out but goes wrong, the covert operation ending in a hugely public shoot-out on the streets, although the three Palestinian targets are killed. Louis is furious that Avner passed the information onto the Israeli government, and coerces him to come to see his 'superior', in actuality his father, Papa, on his quiet and idyllic farm. Papa explains that he is an ex-French resistance fighter, and how no more 'infractions' of what he sees as his rule will be tolerated without severe consequences. Tracking a target to Athens, the team find that the safe house Louis has arranged for them has been 'double-booked' with several others, all Palestinians, on an undisclosed mission, and they agree to share for the one overlapping night, Avner talking to their leader, Ali, and realising that both sides, Arab and Israeli, are only waning the same things for themselves and their families, to have a peaceful homeland. The following night the team launch an attack on their next target in his hotel, but Robert's bomb fails to detonate, causing Hans to have to enter the building and kill the man himself, but a gun battle rages in the street below, Avner being forced to kill Ali, who had been one of the man's bodyguards. In Paris Louis tells an increasingly suspicious Avner that people have been seeking information about him and his team, and that one of their victims in the Athens attack was a KGB officer. Finding their number one target, Ali Hassan Salameh, is in London, they travel there, but their attempt on his life is thwarted. That night at the hotel, Avner is propositioned by a Dutch prostitute, Jeanette, but rejects her advances. Later that night Carl is found dead in his room and Avner realises that he has been murdered by the Dutch woman. He finds from Louis that she is non-political, but will kill for the highest bidder, and he, Steve and Hans travel to her houseboat in Amsterdam and kill her in retaliation. Robert, his nerves now in tatters through the strain of the mission, asks for some time off and returns home. That night Hans is founded stabbed to death in a public park and Robert dies when his house is destroyed in a explosion which may have been intentional or accidental. Avner starts to worry that his men are being killed by his own side, because of what they know, and abandons the mission after another failed attempt on Salameh, going to New York to be with his wife and child, but he starts to believe he is being followed, and from Ephraim discovers some horrifying truths about the Munich revenge mission.

Production

Director
Steven Spielberg
Producer
Kathleen Kennedy, Barry Mendel, Steven Spielberg and Colin Wilson
Art Director
Rod McLean (supervisor)
Editor
Michael Kahn
Music
John Williams
Screenplay
Tony Kushner and Eric Roth, based on the book Vengeance by George Jonas
Director of Photography
Janusz Kaminski

Review

If nothing else Munich should remind one that Steven Spielberg, when truly committed to a project and managing to avoid the sentimentality which so often poisons the last few minutes of his films, is a quite remarkable filmmaker, one who truly understands drama and narrative, and who, despite being more associated with lighter material such as E.T., Jurassic Park and the Raiders series, isn't afraid to take on uncompromising material. What makes Munich so interesting is that Spielberg, who made Schindler's List and has donated considerably to the establishment of a Holocaust Museum, found himself being called a traitor, and far worse, by a section of American Jews simply because he challenged the Mossad response to the Munich massacre, the widely-held intimation being that it was used as a scapegoat for the bureau to simply go after any targets they wanted all over the world, much in the way of the US post 9-11, and even has the temerity, in some eyes, of having a conversation between lead character Avner (Eric Bana - Hulk / Troy) and who can be seen as his Palestinian counterpart, Ali (Omar Metwally), in a slightly contrived scene which brings them together in an Athens safe house, and although some of the plot developments, the script by Tony Kushner and Eric Roth, being adapted from the book Vengeance by George Jonas, seem extraordinary, they have also never been disproved, or even challenged by the Israeli government, who have constantly restated that their enemies will not be safe anywhere in the world, be it in either friendly or hostile countries. Interestingly the film allows a lot of room for doubt in what is the accepted version of events. Although the Munich kidnapping has been superbly covered in Kevin Macdonald's excellent Oscar-winning documentary One Day In September (1999), and rather less credibly in the exploitation pic 21 Hours At Munich (1976), the staging of both the siege and the disastrous events at Munich airport are quite brilliantly covered, with mushc of the action happens behind the genuine news coverage, largely seen on TVs and monitors and brilliantly selected and integrated, which perfectly sets the tone and the atmosphere of an event happening live on the world's stage, and the actual shoot-out which ended in the deaths of everybody concerned, was started by what are believed to be two jumpy West German Police snipers. Once the film moves into Europe, after some slightly lame comic business with a Mossad paymaster who insists on receipts for all their expenditure, the structure of their mission starts to form, with the five men, who have never before met and who have very different attitudes and objectives, being given almost unlimited licence to travel through Europe and make all contacts, and payments, necessary in order to track down and kill their targets. Although seemingly structured like a traditional spy movie, Munich is a great deal colder and more ruthless than that, and it is only at the one hundred minute mark exactly that one of their number, Carl (a fine performance from Ciaran Hinds - The Road To Perdition) mentions how many laws they have broken in various European countries. Certain details are so off-beam that they have to be true, such as bombmaker Robert (a very subdued performance from Mathieu Kassovitz - La Haine) actually being a toy maker, and his devices have a Heath Robinson air to them until one sees the destruction and death they cause. Things become more complex with the introduction of the character of Louis (Mathieu Amalric - Quantum Of Solace), ostensibly an information provider, but one which adds another messy tangent to the moral dimension involved in the mission. Who does he, and his avuncular father, played by the excellent Michel Lonsdale (Ronin), actually represent, apart perhaps from themselves, but they also mean that the team are dealing with yet another morally dubious group in order to fulfil their own ends. Spielberg also isn't flinching at the violence here, showing a ruthlessness which has previously been absent from his work with some extremely ruthless and gruesome killings, the initial seizure of the athletes being particularly vicious, and also surprises the audience with the equally cold and efficient killing of prostitute Jeanette (Josee-Marie Croze - Tell No One), through its' sheer businesslike callousness. The casting is generally very good, with Hinds impressing as the calm but dedicated Carl, and Daniel Craig shows touches of the coldly cruel 007 he would later be and eventually face off against Mathieu Amalric although they share no scenes here, while Geoffrey Rush (Shine / Quills) is believably duplicitous as the manipulative Ephraim. Oddly the weakest performance comes from Bana, whose Avner seems at times either to be remarkably naive or a complete dupe. He finds he cannot actually handle weapons particularly well, and in the three killings in which he is directly involved he is incompetent, shaking uncontrollably when shooting Zwaiter in Rome, unable to finally despatch Jeanette, and even running and throwing away his sniper rifle when the attack on Salameh's Spanish retreat goes wrong. Once out of the mission, he discovers several things which have been withheld for him which only grow to feed his paranoid about being spied upon and possibly targeted by his own side, as the film intimates, with good reason. The closing scenes of a final callous rebuff by Ephraim, ending on one of the most superbly subtle and subdued shots Spielberg has ever ended a film, commendably not succumbing to a happy family scene, perfectly caps a truly enveloping and brilliantly made drama. Munich may not please everyone, and to some seem almost a betrayal after Schindler's List, but it is a remarkably tense and dramatic film which has the courage to make some uncomfortable accusations concerning the real nature of revenge itself, and how those who seek it are so often manipulated by others, and will in time possibly be seen as one of the most important films Spielberg will ever make.