Film details

Conversations With Other Women  2005

Film still

Cast

  • Aaron Eckhert
  • Brian Gerheghty
  • Brianna Brown
  • Thomas Lennon
  • Erik Eidem
  • David Franklin
  • Yury Tsykun
  • Nora Zehetner
  • Cerina Vincent
  • Philip Littell

Synopsis

A wedding in present-day New York. As the speeches are made one of the male guests, a man in his late thirties, finds himself watching one of the other guests, a woman of around his age who is acting as a bridesmaid, and trying to find somewhere to have a cigarette in the non-smoking hotel. Taking her a glass of champagne they start to talk, but this seems to be no chance meeting, and she has answers and put-downs for both his questions and seemingly pointed remarks. The two discuss their lives, and both have been previously married. She has remarried since her divorce, and moved to London with her new husband, a cardiologist who is a few years older than herself. He refers constantly to his new girlfriend, a dancer, but constantly mentions her age, twenty-two, rather than her actual name. It becomes apparent that the two know each other, possibly intimately, and are talking about their past lives in a guarded manner, as if trying not to reveal anything too sensitive or emotional. As the reception draws to an end he persuades her to have the last dance with him, and the pair, staying in the same hotel, share the lift. She becomes hesitant as it seems they will spend the night together. A bridesmaid joins them in the lift and talks to the man about his girlfriend, who she evidently knows, and he seems embarrassed. The couple make their way to one of their rooms and spend the night together, and it seems they may once have been married to each other. Her husband has left her a telephone message, which she intends to answer, but as she does so the man cannot resist doing something which seems spiteful rather than playful, but perhaps reflects the longing he still really feels...

Production

Director
Hans Canosa
Producer
Kerry Boirden, Ram Bergman and Bill McCutchen
Art Director
Scott MacDonald
Editor
Hans Canosa
Music
Jeff Eden Fair and Starr Parodi
Screenplay
Gabrielle Zevin
Director of Photography
Steve Yeadin

Review

Little is made easy in Hans Canosa's Conversations With Other Women, even if the set-up is deceptively simple, as leads Aaron Eckhert (The Core) and Helena Bonham Carter (Sleepy Hollow) play a couple who meet at a wedding reception and appear to almost immediately fall for each other, eventually slipping out of the venue to a hotel room, where their relationship gets rather more complex. Following the example of such films as Sally Potter's Yes they are only ever known as The Man and The Woman, with everyone else at the party just being 'A Guest' or 'The Barman', and nothing is explained, although it seems as if the central pair seem to have a shared history, or perhaps have been lovers in the past, but the screenplay by Gabrielle Zevin steadfastly refuses to actually make anything concrete. In addition the entire film is shot in a split-screen with every shot being covered from two points-of-view, showing one event or piece of dialogue from two aspects, but which emphasises the screenplay's core, that every story has two sides, and often people only hear or understand, or perhaps choose to understand, one side of any tale. It's a daunting idea, and one that perhaps would seem better suited to theatre rather than cinema, but the director has cast the piece very well. Eckhart and Bonham Carter expertly handle what could have just become ciphers or mouthpieces, drawing the audience into this couple's intimate secrets and getting empathy, a remarkable achievement considering just how much, or little, we really know or discover about them. Some may be exasperated at the lack of explanation, even with the film running a scant eighty minutes, but it is certainly an enterprising idea, and the pairing of Eckhert and Bonham Carter, both fine actors, is a rewarding one for those willing to stay with the concept.