Film details

Separate Lies  2005

A Way Through The Wood
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

James Manning, a successful and influential City solicitor, and his wife Anne have a small weekend retreat in Maidleigh, a small country town in Buckinghamshire. During the week they both live in London, retiring to the cottage for most weekends. Joe, the husband of Maggie, their cleaner, is killed by a hit-and-run driver, knocked off his bike into a ditch where he dies, and after finding a scratch on the Range Rover driven by his friend, Bill Bule, James deduces that Bill was the driver responsible. Confronting him, James makes Bill admit that he was indeed responsible, and tells James he will turn himself over to the Police, but James is unconvinced, telling Anne what he has uncovered, and is stunned when she reveals that she was driving the Range Rover at the time, and that she and Bill have been having an affair. He demands that she ends their relationship, but after attending Joe's funeral James is returning home when he sees Bill's car coming out of their drive. Anne tells him that she cannot give Bill up, and has to be with him, the pair shortly afterwards leaving for Paris together, leaving James both surprised and infuriated. James in interviewed about what he knows of the accident by Inspector Marshall, Maggie having identified Bill's car as the vehicle which hit her husband, but her testimony is overshadowed by the fact that she was sacked by the Bule family after being accused of theft, and could not find any work until Anne hired her. The Police see this as a reason for wanting to implicate Bill Bule in the hit-and-run. Months pass, and on a trip to Paris James and Anne meet in a bar, where she tells him she intends to stay with Bill and not return. James returns to London. He begins to sleep with his secretary, Sarah, but still pines for Anne, who returns to England in order to confess to Maggie, her conscience plaguing her with the guilt she fells about the accident. She phones Inspector Marshall to tell him to meet them at Maggie's cottage, but once there Maggie tells the Policeman that Maggie only returned to know if there were any further developments in the case, causing Marshall to leave but with his suspicions about Anne's involvement intact. More time passes until James hears from a mutual friend that Bill is dying, but Anne is staying in Paris in order to nurse him. He wonders what will happen when Bill finally succumbs to the cancer which is killing him, an harbours a tiny hope that Anne will one day return to him.

Production

Director
Julian Fellowes
Producer
Christian Colson and Steve Clark-Hall
Art Director
Niall Moroney
Editor
Alex Mackie and Martin Walsh
Music
Stanislas Syrewicz
Screenplay
Julian Fellowes, based on the novel A Way Through The Wood by Nigel Balchin
Director of Photography
Tony Pierce-Roberts

Review

Although now largely forgotten, with most of his work out of print, Nigel Balchin was a writer of some fame and reknown in the 40s and 50s, working on the scripts of such films as Malta Story and the adaptation of the Howard Spring novel Fame Is the Spur, and achieving success with his own novels, such as The Small Back Room, filmed by Powell and Pressburger, and Mine Own Executioner, itself filmed in 1959, and it is strangely apt that Oscar-winning writer Julian Fellowes. who himself seems at times to be a stock player out of a Gainsborough film of the 1940s, should choose his work with which to make his directorial debut, the source material, to which Fellowes is surprisingly faithful, being Balchin's 1951 novel A Way Through The Wood. Updating the story to the present day, Fellowes manages to make what some may see as a solid, old-fashioned drama, but when the cast is this good, and the handling so assured then old-fashioned; in this context, becomes a compliment rather than any form of slight. He is helped tremendously by his cast, with Tom Wilkinson, a very fine actor for decades before, amusingly, male strippers and Jackie Chan made him a real box-office star, gives another typically fine performance as the tormented James, the lawyer who finds his marriage collapsing after a hit-and-run accident which he initially blames on neighbour Bill Bule (Rupert Everett, giving the sort of slightly sneering, conceited character performance which actually suits him well), finding the evidence on his Range Rover, but to his horror it is his wife, Anne (Emily Watson - Breaking The Waves), who is guilty, not only driving the vehicle when the accident occurs, but also having an affair with the younger man. The Home Counties setting is perfect for the intense emotions which are almost confronted but never allowed to break out, and Wilkinson's performance is beautifully nuanced as his character suffers agonising pain, but is never allowed to show it, no matter how surprisingly brutal and thoughtless his wife's behaviour. Although once the triangular set-up is established it is not difficult to see the betrayal coming, there is a nice reversal in which it is Anne who is most tormented by her guilt, seeming to want to confess to the Police, but being stopped by Maggie (Linda Bassett - Calendar Girls), the widow of the victim, much to the annoyance of Inspector Marshall (David Harewood - Blood Diamond) who suspects Anne's involvement but has no proof. A downbeat ending is brightened by the slightest glimmer of hope, but one is aware that it is only hope from the point of view of James, and that the eventual outcome may be far less than happy. A very solid drama, handled with confidence by the debuting director, and it seems to be a perfect combination of helmer and material, but one wonders how he would handle something perhaps less conventional and, as with most of his scripts, less concerned with the constrictions of class.