Film details
Noel 2004
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
-
-
-
Marcus Thomas
-
John Doman
-
Daniel Sunjata
-
Sonny Marinelli
-
Billy Porter
-
Carmen Ejogo
-
-
Synopsis
Christmas Eve in New York City. Rose Collins, a woman in her forties, visits the hospital to see her mother, who is stricken with Alzheimer's Disease. At the hospital she meets Charlie Boyd, who is also visiting, and later goes on a date with Marco, a younger colleague at the publishers where she works but Rose does not feel her life is settled enough for a serious relationship. In another part of the city Mike Riley, an NYPD officer, has sex with Nina Vasquez, his fiancee, but after dropping her off at work glimpses her in the embrace of another man. Meeting his patrol partner Dennis at a diner, he has to deal with the good natured banter and inuendo of Artie, the owner. Finding the man he saw with Nina, Mike violently assaults him. Nina runs out of her office to stop Mike, telling him that he is an old friend of hers, and gay. She breaks off their relationship. Mike goes home, where he is visited by Artie and is amazed when Artie tells him he believes Mike is the reincarnation of his dead wife. Mike gets violent with him, triggering a heart attack which has Artie rushed to hospital. Nina meets Rose and realises they are both having trouble with their relationships, the two women going to a diner together. Over dinner Rose confesses that she hates the holiday period because her child was stillborn on Christmas Day. At the hospital where Arnie has been taken, Mike meets Jules, a young man in the emergency ward who has deliberately had his hands broken so he can spend Christmas Day in hospital, where as a child he once spent a warm and loving Christmas. Mike is told by Dennis that Artie actually killed his wife's lover in a rage, and was responsible for his spouse's own death. Knowing he is still riven by guilt, Mike pretends to go along with Artie's delusion, pretending to be his wife, and forgives him for what he did. Realising what jealousy can do, Mike asks Nina to forgive him for what he did to her friend. Weighed down by her feelings about Christmas, her mother and the death of her child, Rose goes to the edge of the Hudson River, and considers ending it all.
Production
- Director
- Chazz Palminteri
- Producer
- Bart Rosenblatt, Eugene Musso, Al Corley and Zvi Howard Rosenman
- Art Director
- Andre Chamberland
- Editor
- Susan E. Morse
- Music
- Alan Menken
- Screenplay
- David Hubbard
- Director of Photography
- Russell Carpenter
Review
Christmas is a difficult time for many people, whether they be within families or on their own, but surely not quite as difficult as it is for the characters in Noel, the feature directorial debut of actor and writer Chazz Palminteri, which is obviously building to an It's A Wonderful Life-style last-reel turnaround, even involving possibly angelic intervention, and one's blood freezes when one realises that an uncredited Robin Williams is also in the cast. Gosh, wonder when he'll turn up, and as who? The problem is that the characters are largely unsympathetic. Susan Sarandon's Rose complains about being lonely, yet rejects a perfectly innocent date with a younger man, and Paul walker's cop Mike is virtually on a hair trigger, lashing out at a man, who turns out to be gay, something the film seems to find funny, after seeing him with his girlfriend (Penelope Cruz in an underwritten role). The major misjudgement comes with the character of Artie (Alan Arkin, a talented actor and comedian who choice of film roles has often been disastrous), who comes onto Mike in his diner, another opportunity for snickers from the filmmakers, only to be revealed to be both in a state of dementia about the loss of his wife, and believing Mike to be her reincarnation, and then revealed to be a killer, having killed his wife's lover. Quite a packed Christmas Eve, all in all, and you thought you had problems in finding that last-minute present for your mum. Palminteri is obviously trying to cover all the bases, from drama to pathos to absurdist comedy, and spreads his directorial talent pretty thin in trying to handle so much, and by the time Rose ventures down to the river a rather inevitable and cloying ending is on the cards. He is also certainly sloppy in the continuity department, and more than one critic has noticed that Penelope Cruz changes her costume four times over a four hour period, but this is a very minor problem indeed when compared with the messy, unfocused script, and the ever-present spectre of Robin Williams appearing as an angel in the last reel.