Film details

Zodiac  2007

Cast

Synopsis

1969. Vallejo, California, and Mike Mageau and his married lover Darlene Ferrin are shot in her car, Mageau surviving while Ferrin dies. Claiming to be their killer, and to have murdered another couple a year earlier in Benicia, Betty Lou Jensen and David Faraday, 'Zodiac' writes to three local newspapers, The San Francisco Chronicle, The San Francisco Examiner and The Vallego Time-Herald, with coded clues and pictograms, threatening to kill more unless the papers publish his message and pictograms in full. Robert Greysmith, the political cartoonist on the Chronicle, works on decoding the 408 various symbols, which Zodiac claims will reveal a message, finally translating them with the help of several others interested in cyphers, and earns the grudging respect of Paul Avery, the paper's hard-drinking and rebellious chief crime reporter. Bryan Hartness and Cecilia Shepherd are attacked and repeatedly stabbed by a hooded man on the banks of Lake Berryessa, Napa County, only Hartness surviving his multiple injuries. In what seems to be an unrelated attack, cab driver Paul Stein is shot in his vehicle late one evening, Zodiac admitting to the killing as homicide detectives Inspectors David Toschi and Bill Armstrong are brought into the case, liaising with other detectives in the areas of the killings, including Jack Mulanax in Vallejo and Ken Narlow in Napa, pooling their information and leads. On October 14 Zodiac sends a letter to Chronicle with a piece of Paul Stein's shirt tail, telling them he may attack a school bus and shoot out its' tires, then shoot the children as they leave the crashed bus. A man claiming to be Zodiac contacts the press and insists he will talk to celebrity lawyer Marvin Belli if he appears on a live evening news show, and makes the call, Belli offering to meet him at a rendezvous which the Police have suggested, but Zodiac does not show, and the call is later traced to a patient in a mental facility. 1970, and Katherine Jones, travelling with her young baby near Nodesto, accepts a lift from a passing stranger after her car breaks down, only be told by the driver he is going to kill her and throw her child out of the window. She leaps from the car with her baby, but doubt is later expressed that she is a victim of Zodiac. The following year, compiling evidence against a suspect, Arthur Leigh Allen, Toschi, Armstrong and Mulanax interrogate him, but Sherwood Morrill, a handwriting expert, tells them that Allen did not write the Zodiac letters. Avery, becoming ever more erratic and drink-dependent, leaves the paper. 1972, and Toschi and Armstrong search Allen's trailer while he is away, but find nothing. Four years later, with still no developments on the case, Armstrong leaves the homicide division. 1977, and Greysmith is still investigating the case although official Police interest seems to have dwindled until Toschi is accused of forging a new letter attributed to Zodiac and is demoted. 1979, and Greysmith's interest has become an obsession, believing he has found a new, viable suspect, Rick Marshall. His wife Melanie leaves him, taking their children with her. Greysmith talks to Bob Vaughn, a cinema silent-film organist, what Vaughn tells him adding weight to his theory about Marshall. Visiting Linda, Darlene Ferrin's jailed sister, she tells Greysmith that her sister was very frightened of a volatile man named Lee, which he interprets to mean Arthur Leigh Allen. Zodiac becomes just another unsolved case on the files, but in 1983 Greysmith, knowing here Allen works, goes to the shop, wanting to see the man he suspects of being the multiple murderer. End captions detail the events of 1991 and 1992, and the current status of the Zodiac case in the various jurisdictions, as well as what happened to several of those involved.

Production

Director
David Fincher
Producer
Cean Chattin, Brad Fischer, Mike Medavoy, Arnold Messer and James Vanderbilt
Art Director
Keith P. Cunningham
Editor
Angus Wall
Music
David Shire
Screenplay
James Vanderbilt, based on the book by Robert Greysmith
Director of Photography
Harris Savides

Review

David Fincher returns to the dark territory of Se7en for another story of a serial killer, but this time a frighteningly true one, Zodiac, or The Zodiac Killer, who stalked North California with at least four confirmed kills between December 1968 and October 1969, although as the evidence presented here, and James Vanderbilt's screenplay is very keen to state that much of the evidence comes from court and Police documents, there is an ambiguity as to how many he actually killed, with the possibility of copycat killings and or victims not connected with his modus operandi not being ruled out. Fincher's film focuses on the efforts to find him, after he sent letters to the press which included four strange cryptograms, only one of which was ever deciphered, and who taunted both the Police and media with letters in which he claimed were codes leading to his identity. Cartoonist Robert Greysmith (Jake Gyllenhaal - Jarhead) follows the case as more bodies are found but the Police are reluctant to attribute them to Zodiac, and Greysmith, nicknamed 'Retard' by his own workmates through his social ineptitude and difficulty in making small talk or conversation, sticks to the task, and Fincher very cleverly shows the passage of time in deft strokes. In one scene Greysmith is on a blind date with the seemingly equally socially inexperienced Melanie (Chloe Sevigny - Kids) and a while later he is married to Melanie and they have two children, the audience having to essentially fill in the details themselves. What is remarkable is that a film running 157 minutes is utterly gripping from beginning to end while lacking so many thriller staples. No gun fights, chases, on foot or by car, no lingering autopsies of the victims, the CSI fallback which can pad out the slenderest script, and an admirable reticence to concentrate on the killings, which are swift and harrowing, each handled in a different style by Fincher. What makes the story so compelling is the performances, and there is a truly excellent cast of very strong actors here, with Jake Gyllenhaal sympathetic as the awkward outsider Greysmith, on whose book the script is based, even though over half a dozen books, both factual and using the subject as the base for fiction, have been written on the subject, Robert Downey Jr (Iron Man) is excellent as the determined and drink-driven Avery, eventually giving up to a life of booze and bitter resentment in one of the film's more unexpected developments. Mark Ruffalo (Collateral) seems at times to be playing a younger version of Peter Falk's Columbo as the unkempt, annoying Toschi, and the truly impressive supporting cast includes such dependables as Anthony Edwards (TV's ER), Brian Cox (X-Men 2), Elias Koteas (Apt Pupil), Donal Logue (Max Payne), John Terry (TV's 24) and John Getz (The Fly / The Fly II), What is also fascinating is that although the film is about the hunt for a murderer, it isn't really any sort of whodunnit or Police procedural, instead being about the puzzle itself, and how the pursuit of a solution can be so all consuming and destructive, eventually costing Greysmith his marriage and Avery his career, especially as it is well known that the killer was never caught, although the script very much all but convicts who they believe was Zodiac, Arthur Leigh Allen, believably and creepily played by John Carroll Lynch (Gran Torino), setting him up as the most probably suspect although also offering the evidence against as well, possibly not wanting to defame a man who died in 1992, interestingly just as the Police were planning to arrest him, and a final collection of end captions sums up what happened to those involved, and heavily indicated that the case is still theoretically open. several involved forces still accepting information and tips on their websites. Despite its' length Zodiac remains compelling throughout, and shows how just four decades ago a case which these days, fictionally, would be cleared up by any of the CSI incarnations by the second ad break, had to be approached by Police using true investigation techniques, questioning hundreds of witnesses and collating and re-checking their evidence, and the press, who would have to follow the same sort of procedure, Would any popular newspaper provide such exhaustive coverage now? No, simply because there was too much work involved, and although Paul Avery is portrayed as a sometimes objectional drunk, he was also a totally dedicated newspaper man, determined to find the truth no matter how much work it took. Fincher has to be praised for simply how he refuses to dip into sensationalism, as brutal and sadistic as the attacks were, and only near the end does he venture into traditional horror / thriller territory when the naive Greysmith investigates a lead on his own, going to house of a former cinema organist, at night, and finds himself in the mouldering, cliched cobwebby cellar, as the sinister man looks for one of his ledgers, a moment which is strangely out of kilter with the otherwise visually drab settings, which is not to say that the cinematography by Harris Savides (American Gangster / Milk) is not impressive, shot digitally on the Viper camera and confounding those who have claimed that period pieces cannot be shot digitally. A remarkable story, grippingly told, and with not a spare frame in the entire running time. In all a thriller which demands to be seen.