Film details

Hell  2005

L'enfer / L'inferno
Film still

Cast

  • Emmanuelle Beart
  • Karin Viard
  • Marie Gillain
  • Guillaume Canet
  • Jacques Gamblin
  • Jacques Perrin
  • Miki Manojlovic
  • Jean Rochefort
  • Maryam D'Abo
  • Gaelle Bona
  • Georges Slatdis

Synopsis

Sophie, Celine and Anne are three sisters, living very seperate lives in Paris. All three remember the events of twenty years previously when their father, just released from prison, confronted their mother, an event which eventually led to his suicide and their mother having a catatonic breakdown, spending her years wheelchair-bound and unable to speak. The three have grown apart, not knowing the others' addresses or what has happened to their siblings in the years that have passed. Sophie is married to Pierre, a photographer who has had several extra-marital affairs and shows no signs of changing his ways. Celine is devoted to their mother, and has abandoned all ambitions for herself, regularly taking long train journeys to the sanatorium where she resides, Celine reading to her from The Guinness Book Of World Records. The youngest, Anne, is an architecture student who has discovered she is pregnant by her much older professor, she having just ended the affair. Celine starts to believe she is being followed by Sebastien, a man who is a ticket collector on the train Celine frequently takes, but once they meet she discovers that he has information about the traumatic event in their family history. When Celine finds out what Sebastien has to tell her she makes efforts to find her siblings, determined to confront their mother with this new, and disturbing revelation.

Production

Director
Danis Tanovic
Producer
Drazen Bosnjak, Cedomir Kolar and Marc Baschet
Art Director
Aline Bonetto
Editor
Francesca Calvelli
Music
Dusko Segvic and Danis Tanovic
Screenplay
Krzysctof Piesewicz, based on the trilogy Le Paradis, L'Enfer Et Le Purgatore by Krzysctof Klesowsky and Krzysctof Piesewicz
Director of Photography
Laurent Dailland

Review

Not to be confused with the Claude Chabrol film, L'Enfer, also confusingly starring Emmanuelle Beart, Hell is the second in a trilogy of films made from three scripts left unfilmed Krzysctof Klesowsky (The Dekalog / the Three Colours series) at the time of his death, the first, Heaven, having already been made by German director Tom Tykwer. Whereas Heaven had some intriguing ideas, well handled by Tykwer, Hell, directed by Danis Tanovic (No Man's Land) is problematic by telling the stories of three French sisters (Beart, Karin Viard and Marie Gillain) who deliberately have no contact with one another, and apart from their parentage have very little in common. Thus there are three separate plot threads with three distinct styles, brought together by what can only be regarded as some serious coincidences. Whereas Klesowsky could show the intricate minutie of lives and events in detail, such as in The Double Life Of Veronique, and make them integral to both plot and character, Tanovic's handling of the lives of Sophie, Celine and Anne just makes them into three disparate characters, brought together for last-reel revelations for a resolution which neither rings true or believable. Of course the film has it compensations, and Beart (rapidly becoming one of France's fines actresses) and Viard (Time Out) give strong performances, even if the audience is unsure of just who they are for the first couple of reels, smaller roles for veterans Jacques Perrin and Jean Rochefort, and Paris looks a cold and occasionally chilly city under the lens of DoP Laurent Dailland. Unfortunately although these replacement directors may have the words Klesowsky left, it appears they are unsure how to interpret them properly.