Film details

Fateless  2005

Sorstalanság / Fateless - Roman Eines Schicksallosen
Film still

Cast

  • Marcell Nagy
  • Béla Dóra
  • Bálint Péntek
  • Áron Dimény
  • Péter Fancsikai
  • Zsolt Dér
  • András M. Kecskés
  • Dani Szabó
  • Tibor Mertz
  • Péter Vida
  • Endre Harkányi
  • Márton Brezina
  • Jozsef Gyabronka
  • Janos Ban
  • Judith Schel

Synopsis

Gyura Koves, a fourteen year old boy living in Budapest in 1944, says goodbye to his father, who is on his way to a German labour camp. The war is entering its' final and most destructive phase in Europe. Gyura has a girlfriend his own age, Annamarie, and she is concerned that she is Jewish and what this may lead to, a situation which Gyura is blissfully unaware of, not realising the significance of her religion in such a time. On the way to the factory where he works due to the shortage of labour, Gyura is surprised to be ordered off the bus which takes him to the works and to be herded together with a bunch of others, all strangers to him. He finds himself being shipped to the Auschwitz concentration camp. Overcoming his initial confusion, he decides to cope with the situation by sticking to the rules laid down by the guards and not thinking of his possible fate. He makes friends with a young boy, Moskovich, smaller than himself and bespectacled, but a number of inmates are selected to be transferred to another camp, Buchenwald. Moskovich is not among them, and Gyura understands what this means and that his friend will probably shortly be dead. A brief spell at the camp leads to yet another transfer, this time to the Zeitz camp. Gyura meets another young man from Budapest, Bandi Citrom, and the two share memories of the city and their lives there, neither wishing to believe they may never see it again. Citrom also helps him by telling him the strict camp rules and warns him to adhere to them at all times, discipline being particularly strict at Zeitz. Gyura gets a leg wound which becomes badly infected, and hunger starts to affect him badly, the rations at the camp getting ever smaller. He falls badly ill, but hears of the collapse of the Reich and the continuing liberation of Europe, but he wonders that even if he is rescued, is there anything left to return to?

Production

Director
Lajos Koltai
Producer
Andras Hamon, Peter Barbalics, Iidiko Kemeny and Jonathan Olsberg
Art Director
Zsuzsa Borvendeg, Judit Csak and Natajia Meier
Editor
Hajnal Sello
Music
Ennio Morricone
Screenplay
Imre Kertész, based on his novel Sorstalansag
Director of Photography
Gyula Pados

Review

The first directorial feature by Lajos Koltai, a major cinematographer in Hungary, Fateless breaks several unspoken rules of the Holocaust genre by actually having scenes of beauty amid the desperation and inhuman cruelty, with Koltai managing to shoot the countryside around the recreations of such abominations as Auschwitz, Buchenwald and the less known Zeitz with a pastoral calm. This is of course to disarm the audience. The countryside around the compounds may shimmer under crisp snow, or almost glow in the spring sunshine, but this is just the setting for the unspeakable acts occurring within. Using a non-professional actor in the lead, Marcell Nagy playing the young Gyura, Fateless, based on the largely autobiographical novel by Imre Kertesz, is brave enough to take a completely isolated character and show his reaction to the death camps. Gyura suffers from starvation, and an infected leg, but he survives, and finds that he is not particularly traumatised or scarred by the experience. He has survived on his own terms by accepting the strictures enforced on him, and thus has little in common with many other survivors who cannot escape their memories of their time in the camps. He does not mourn deaths because he does not get to know anyone well enough. Gyura is more worried about what is going to happen now that he is free and alone and the advice given by a liberating American soldier (a small and surprising pre-Casino Royale cameo from Daniel Craig, the only non-Hungarian actor in the cast) is not to go home. It is advice he ignores, and regrets it. Koltai's film is brave for the juxtaposition of the realities and the accepted 'lore' of the Holocaust. Many survived and got over it, going on to live their lives without carrying it as a burden, a view the likes of Primo Levi could never accept. Koltai has made a challenging film which is often oddly beautiful, in photography and composition, even if the addition of a lush Ennio Morricone score would perhaps more suited to a film not so carefully shot, so as to bolster the deficient visuals.