Film details

The Squid and the Whale  2005

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Having been married for years and raised two sons, Walt, 16, and Frank, 12, writers Walter and Joan Berkman, who live in the prosperous Park Slope area of Brooklyn, decide to finally split up. They tell their sons of their decision and of their new domestic arrangements where they will share custody, Joan staying in the family home while Bernard moves to a new apartment is a less salubrious suburb, the boys spending time between them. Walt stays close to his father, and after Bernard casually remarks that Joan had repeated affairs during their marriage he confronts his mother with the accusation. He starts to date Sophie Greenberg, a classmate, even though he seems clumsy around girls, and his father strongly advises him to have nothing to do with women and try to remain single and independent. Lili, a student in the creative writing class Bernard teaches, moves into the spare rom in Bernard's apartment, and Walt finds himself drawn to her also. Frank's distress at the situation manifests itself in him starting to drink, and to masturbate on school property, and he makes an unexpected discovery when he calls on his mother's house unexpectedly to find her with ivan, her tennis coach. Bernard and Lili begin sleeping together, to Walt's discomfort. He enters the school talent competition with a song he claims to have written, Hey You, and wins, without anyone realising that the song is in fact by Pink Floyd. Enervated he insults both Joan and Sophie, breaking up with the latter, and makes a clumsy pass at Lili. Both Bernard and Joan are summoned to see the school head after Frank's onanism is discovered, and Walt's plagiarism is also revealed. Bernard and Joan take the school's advice and Walt is taken to see an educational psychiatrist. With Bernard's relationship with Lili becoming difficult, and Frank wanting to spend more time with his mother and less with his father, the Berkman family seem to finally be destroying the bonds which once held them together.

Production

Director
Noah Baumbach
Producer
Wes Anderson, Peter Newman, Charlie Corwin and Clara Markowicz
Art Director
Jennifer Dehghan
Editor
Tim Streeto
Music
Dean Wareham and Britta Phillips
Screenplay
Noah Baumbach
Director of Photography
Robert D. Yeoman

Review

Admitting that the script is semi-autobiographical, although declining to explain to what degree exactly, Noah Baumbach's script for The Squid And The Whale won him an Oscar nomination for Best Original Screenplay, which in some ways seems scant reward for the years of his youth in which he gathered the material, but is a notable recognition that the film contains some painfully well-observed and meticulously detailed aspects of a relationship which has fallen apart, the essentially selfish natures of those involved in it, and the ramifications on those around them. The audience's sympathies are purely with youngsters Walt and Frank (fine performances from both Jesse Eisenberg and Owen Kline), since parents Bernard and Joan are simply monstrous, self-absorbed and yet utterly shallow. With the title of the film referring to the great creatures of the sea who are specieal enemies, and their clashes usually result in the eventual death of both of them, Jeff Daniels' bearded, morose Bernard is a particular horror, arrogant and humourless, fiercely competitive even when just playing games with his sons, and Baumbach manages to turn his self-absorption into cold laughs. Laura Linney gives another terrific performance as the equally vacuous Joan, a woman whose energies seem to be turned exclusively towards making every one around her feel inadequate and somehow lacking. Their influence has spread to their sons, with Walt's initial approaches to Sophie (Halley Feiffer) being tremulous and concerning literature, since this is how Bernard has told him to deal with women. but advises staying far away from them. Frank's problems manifest themselves in underage drinking and, more surprisingly, inappropriate masturbation in school, and the scene when the two parents are brought to school to discuss Frank''s problems are both bitterly funny and sadly maudlin. Baumbach simply portrays them as egotists who have ceased, due to their separation, to be of interest to anyone else than themselves, and see their children both as weapons to be used against one another and as excess baggage. Painfully well observed and undeniably terrifically played, The Squid And The Whale also manages to make a painful and scarring event darkly and crisply humourous, aided by the pitch-perfect performances of Daniels and Linney, and if Baumbach still bears the wounds (his own parents divorced in the late Eighties while he was a teenager) then at least getting the film onto the screen can be seen as some sort of well-earned therapy.