Film details

An American Haunting  2005

Film still

Cast

  • James D'Arcy
  • Rachel Hurd-Wood
  • Matthew Marsh
  • Thom Fell
  • Zoe Thorne
  • Gaye Brown
  • Sam Alexander
  • Miquel Brown
  • Vernon Dobtcheff
  • Shauna Shin

Synopsis

After a mother living in Red River, Tennessee, gets worried about the nightmares her teenage daughter has been having, she finds that they were triggered by the discovery of a packet of old documents in the attic of their home. They are the work of Richard Powell, a school teacher in the town between 1817 and the following year, and tell of a legal clash between respected townsman John Bell and Kate Batts, who was accused of witchcraft. The lawsuit is not settled in favour of either party, and Batts is believed to put a curse on both Bell and Betsy, his young daughter. Betsy starts to become the victim of nocturnal attacks by a poltergeist, which seems to beat and slap her, throwing her into the air. Richard Powell does not believe the initial rumours of what is happening to the girl, but sees the manifestations himself and changes his mind. The events in the house escalate, Bell himself being assaulted by the vengeful spirit, forcing his wife, Lucy, to fear for their lives. Betts sends a slave over to their house to return bloodied clothing belonging to Betsy and her father, clothes which had been missing from their wardrobes for over a year. Frightened by Kate Batts and what he sees as her supernatural powers, John Bell tries to make peace with her, offering to sacrifice his life if she will call off the demons which seem to be assailing his family, but she tells him she laid no curse, and that what is causing his torments is of his own making. Richard Powell realises that the attacks only seem to occur under the Bell's own roof so tries to persuade them to leave their house, but as they do so the evil entity seems to leave with them and causes a serious coach accident. As the Bell family stagger from the wreckage of the carriage, both Betsy and her mother have a shared recollection, a memory which seems to throw light on the terrible events which seem to have befallen the Bell family.

Production

Director
Courtney Solomon
Producer
Courtney Solomon, Christopher Milburn and Andre Rouleau
Art Director
Ioana Corciova
Editor
Richard Corneau
Music
Caine Davidson
Screenplay
Courtney Solomon, based on the novel The Bell Witch - An American Haunting by Brent Monahan
Director of Photography
Adrian Biddle

Review

A genuine event in American history, the Bell Witch Case, as it is known, is remarkable for being on the legal statute books as the only case ever to end in a verdict of death by supernatural means, unique in American law and probably most countries in the civilised world. The truth of what happened makes it all the stranger that writer and director Courtney Solomon, maker of the rather risible Dungeons And Dragons, chooses not to stick to the known facts of the case and its' remarkable resolution but rather provides another, alternate solution, topped and tailed by a rather needless modern-day setting which seems to want to provide the hook for a sequel. By having the present-day teenager have nightmares which flashback to the events of 1817 the audience is tipped off early about what is going to happen, and it is to the director's credit that he doesn't totally sabotage the enterprise by his elaborations, managing to build some fine atmosphere and decidedly creepy situations once the story reverts to Red River two centuries previously. The script, adapted from a novelisied version of the events, borrows a lot from other sources, notably The Exorcist, as the seemingly possessed Betsy starts to levitate and writhe under the apparent possession by demonic forces, her eyes turning glassily white, while the town itself would not look out of place in a Washington Irving story. Two performances manage to stand out amid the self-consciously brooding photography, Donald Sutherland as John Bell, increasingly edging towards madness as he tries to both save his own daughter and hide his own shameful secret, and Rachel Hurd-Wood (P.J. Hogan's Peter Pan) as Betsy, coming across as frighteningly vulnerable as she is abused by forces both spectral and, tellingly, mortal. Effective in parts, even if some of the scare tactics work purely through being so well-worked before, An American Haunting is quite a story, so one wonders why Solomon didn't stick to the facts instead of interpreting them in such a way.