Film details

The Ballad of Jack and Rose  2004

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Jack Slavin, an ecologically-minded idealist who established his own commune, now deserted, on an island off the east coast of America, lives there with Rose, his sixteen-year-old daughter, the only residents. The year is 1986. Jack is protesting against a developer who is constructing a housing project on the other side of the island. Having been diagnosed with a fatal and debilitating heart condition, Jack contacts Kathleen, his occasional lover, to come to the island to take care of himself and Rose. Kathleen eventually agrees, bringing her teenage sons, Thaddius, a handsome stoner, and Rodney, overweight but determined and honest. Jack and Kathleen soon become lovers once more, but are observed in bed by Rose, who asks Rodney if he will take her to bed also and take her virginity. He manages to evade her demands, instead cutting her hair into a more fashionable style. Jack and Kathleen are stunned when Rose walks into the bedroom with Jack's gun and fires a shot at them, just missing them both. Problems start to multiply on the island. Rose makes advances to Grey, the gardener who visits regularly, and Rodney has his female friend Red come over from the mainland. Rose is shocked to see Red having oral sex with Thaddius, and that night Rose manages to lure him to her bed. Jack realises what has happened when he sees Rose's bedsheets the next morning. Rose sets up the projector and shows some old home movies, showing the commune years ago when there were more people living there, before they abandoned both it and Jack. Jack gets into an argument with Thaddius, eventually hitting him, which causes Thaddius, Rodney and Red to leave the island, leaving Rose with Jack and Kathleen. Rose leaves Jack's enclave, moving into one of the unfinished houses on the other side of the island, giving Jack an ultimatum which he must agree to before she returns. Jack caves in, and asks Kathleen to leave. Driven to desperation, Jack forces a meeting with Marty Ranos, the property developer, but Ranos' reactions are not what he is expecting.

Production

Director
Rebecca Miller
Producer
Lemore Syvan
Art Director
Pierre Rovira
Editor
Sabine Hoffmann
Music
Michael Rohatlyn
Screenplay
Rebecca Miller
Director of Photography
Ellen Kuras

Review

The name Rebecca Miller is never mentioned without the suffix that she is the daughter of Arthur Miller, one of the greatest of all American playwrights and who died in 2005. This is unfortunate since it hampers Rebecca Miller with an enormous weight of expectation, a burden which The Ballad Of Jack And Rose, starring her husband, Daniel Day-Lewis, is unable to surmount. And unfortunately for someone with such a famous and lauded father, the obviously Oedipal aspects of the movie, Rose obviously idolising her father and Jack coming over as occasionally rather over-protective and over-interested in his daughter and her budding sex life, only add to both the uncomfortable aspects of the central relationship and disquieting undercurrents of the piece as a whole. That Jack and Rose lives as virtual hermits in what was once meant to be a self-sustaining hermetic commune only emphasises the upheaval which is caused with arrival of Kathleen (Catherine Keener - Being John Malkovich), and her sons, very different young men with different fathers, and with their arrival comes the threat of sex, and from what has been an isolated and 'pure' existence comes under-aged sex, voyeurism and various other variations on the theme, including some actions, such as Rose firing a gun at Jack and Kathleen in bed which would get any normal people locked up. Miller uses fine photography by Ellen Kuras to emphasise the beauty of the island, but this is merely to contrast how corrupted it seems when the 'outsiders', property developer Ranos (Beau Bridges) as well as Kathleen and her brood, arrive. An odd mixture of psycho-drama and occasional broad comedy with touches which would not seem out of place in melodramas of the 40s, such as Jack's discovery of his daughter's deflowering by examining her bedsheets. Miller obviously has some good ideas and potentially interesting characters, but by bringing together so many disparate elements, few of which are actually used to their full dramatic extent, makes The Ballad Of Jack And Rose rather confused and strangely disjointed. With its' very obvious potential for large and brazen performances perhaps it would work better on the stage.