Film details

Down in the Valley  2005

Film still

Cast

  • Evan Rachel Wood
  • David Morse
  • Ellen Burstyn
  • Bruce Dern
  • John Diehl
  • Geoffrey Lewis
  • Rory Culkin
  • Elisabeth Pena
  • Kat Dennings
  • Hunter Parrish
  • Heather Ashleigh

Synopsis

Lonnie Sommers is an eleven year old boy, living with his teenage sister Tobe and their father Wade, a cop who is largely absent from the family home, in a coastal town in California. On the beach Tobe meets Harlan Fairfax Carruthers, a man in his thirties who styles himself as a modern-day cowboy, even down to his stetson. That night she goes to his motel and ends up in bed with him. The following evening Harlan invites Lonnie along as he and Tobe go out for dinner. Lonnie returns home afterwards as Tobe and Harlan go on to a club. Tobe arrives home the next morning to be confronted by an angry Wade. She and Harlan borrow a horse and go riding, only to be challenged by the horse's owner, who is armed, when they return. Harlan makes out that the man is a friend of his, and calls him Charlie, but the man claims never to have met Harlan and calls the police. Wade tells Tobe she is not to see Harlan again, and she tells Harlan she is going away for the weekend on a family visit. Harlan goes to her house and finds Lonnie, who shows him his father's gun collection. Harlan takes Lonnie riding but when he returns him to his house Wade pulls a gun on Harlan, ordering him to leave and not come back. Harlan returns to his hotel and gets drunk, accidentally firing the gun he keeps in the room. Harlan is ejected from the hotel and breaks into a local home. He steals some valuables and finds photographs which seem to be of himself as a young child. Also breaking into Tobe's house, he tells her that the two of them must run away together. She refuses and they fight, Harlan accidentally shooting her as they tussle. He runs away, Wade finding her when he returns from work and taking her to the hospital. Needing an alibi Harlan shoots himself in the leg, returning to the house, knowing that Wade and Tobe are at the hospital, and tells Lonnie that Wade shot both himself and Tobe. Lonnie leaves with Harlan, both of them planning to get out of town. Wade is soon on their trail and gets information from another officer as to Harlan's real identity and connection to the town. The Police are closing on Harlan and Lonnie, but Harlan is still armed, and dangerous.

Production

Director
David Jacobson
Producer
Stavros Merjos, Edward Norton, Adam Rosenfelt and Holly Weirsma
Art Director
Michael Attwell
Editor
Lynzee Klingman and Edward Harrison
Music
Peter Salett
Screenplay
David Jacobson
Director of Photography
Enrique Chediak

Review

One of the problems of packing a film with multiple references to other productions, especially when they are of the stature of Taxi Driver, Night Of The Hunter and Badlands, is that it reminds you what milestones they are and how comparatively shallow most others are in comparison. Re-edited after a less than warm reception at the Cannes Film Festival, David Jacobson's Down In The Valley desperately wants to be a modern Western, with Edward's Norton's Harlan coming over a cross between Shane and the archetypical good ol' boy, or so Norton thinks, and his relationship with Tobe (Evan Rachel Wood - Pretty Persuasion / The Upside Of Anger) seems unlikely considering the regard with which Harlan seems to hold himself. Unfortunately in wanting to make a Western the director telegraphs everything, and once a rather naive Lonnie shows Harlan his father's gun collection and they start being drawn at virtually every opportunity, is it any surprise that the ending is going to be a showdown. Norton's character is fairly impenetrable, with his motivation once his real identity is revealed being no clearer, and if he is a local as it is claimed then how come no one seems to recognise him. And after he has put a bullet in Tobe, tried to frame her father, abducted her brother and shot and killed a Police officer, would the family actually show the act of kindness, or inexplicable idiocy, which is the final scene. Certain homages to other movies are rather obvious, such as Harlan practising his quick draw in front of a mirror, which echoes Taxi Driver to a degree where one is thinking about De Niro when one's mind should be on Norton. Down In The Valley may have received a hostile reception at Cannes, but it would be interesting to know how the original cut varied from this strange and unfocused hybrid.