Film details

The Wind That Shakes the Barley  2006

Film still

Cast

  • Cillian Murphy
  • Padraic Delaney
  • Gerard Kearney
  • William Ruane
  • Siobhan McSweeney
  • Mairtin De Cogain
  • Niall McCarthy
  • Fergus Burke
  • Orla Fitzgerald
  • Mary Riordan
  • Lawrence Barry

Synopsis

1920, and Irish rebels fight a vicious covert campaign against the Black and Tans, ruthless mercenary troops sent into the country by Britain in order to try to quell the rebellion and its' aims of a united Ireland and independence. Damien, a young doctor with an interest in socialist leanings, is about to leave for London to take up a medical post, but after seeing the ruthlessness of the Black and Tans when dealing with agitators decides instead to stay and help his brother, Teddy, in fighting the British. Setting up a base, and acquiring weapons, their location is soon discovered by the British soldiers, Damien and Teddy discovering that they were betrayed by one of their number, Chris, who had been pressured by his employer, Sir John Hamilton, into cooperating with the authorities and revealing the location. The soldiers arrest both Damien and Teddy and both are imprisoned, Teddy coming in for rough treatment, while Damien meets a fellow socialist, Dan, and the pair are sprung from jail by a British Private sympathetic to their cause. Hearing that several prisoners are to be hanged for their part in violent attacks which have resulted in deaths, Damien takes both Sir John Chambers and Chris hostage, threatening to kill them unless the prisoners are released, but his demands are ignored and he shoots both men dead. Lying low, he finds himself becoming involved with a local girl, Sinead, but also finds his devotion to his cause overwhelming his romantic leanings towards her. With the campaign of violence and politically motivated murders rising, the British call a truce against the rebels. A treaty granting partial independence is negotiated, which representatives from Sinn Fein agree to, and ratify by signing. Damien and many others are not satisfied with the treaty, which has led to the formation of the Irish Free State, accusing their political leaders of selling them out and giving up their ideals in exchange for limited political power, and argue that they should continue the struggle, despite what their leaders demand, although Teddy states that he supports the treaty, and is unwilling to continue fighting. With the rebels broken into pro and anti camps regarding the treaty and its' ramifications, they begin fighting among themselves, as violently as they had fought the British, Damien and Teddy now finding themselves on different sides. Teddy's men become part of the Irish Free State Army. Realising that they are running low on weapons and ammunition, Damien and Dan plan a raid on an army camp in order to steal more munitions, an act which will bring them face to face with Teddy once more and show just how far their true cause has died and withered.

Production

Director
Ken Loach
Producer
Rebecca O'Brien
Art Director
Michael Higgins and Mark Lowry
Editor
Jonathan Morris
Music
George Fenton
Screenplay
Paul Laverty
Director of Photography
Barry Unsworth

Review

It almost comes as a surprise that it has taken Ken Loach so long to get round to the Irish rebellion of the 1920s, being such obviously fertile material for the director, allowing him too indulge in his condemnation of everyone and everything British, but The Wind That Shakes The Barley finds itself in a cleft stick by having who he sees to be the heroes, a large percentage of the rebels, doing what he obviously sees as the unthinkable and signing a political accord, establishing the Irish Free State. The consequence of this, at least in frequent collaborator Paul Laverty's script, is to makes Sinn Fein and the pioneers of Irish independence the eventual villains of the piece, an awkward situation which leads to the film being strangely unfocused. His sympathies are obviously with the Irish, with the violence of the ruthless Black and Tans being shown as institutionalised and savage, while the killings inflicted by the rebels, including the shootings of Sir John Hamilton (Roger Allam - Speed Racer) and his employee Chris (Padriac Delaney - TV's The Tudors) by the determined Damien (Cillian Murphy - Batman Begins) is seen purely as political necessity, Chris in many ways having forced Damien's hands by not only betraying him and his men to the British but also for having the temerity to be employed by an Englishman. Unfortunately as played by Murphy, with that angular face and cold, cold eyes, Damien makes for a rebel as determined and ruthless as those he is fighting against, and the script is unsubtle in its' handling of the independence treaty, Loach obviously regarding Sinn Fein as traitors to their old people, and the replication of early scenes involving the Black and Tans with very similar shots involving the Irish Free State Army is an emphatic way of Loach insisting that one sort of tyranny has been replaced by another. As with all his work Loach paints thickly with a wide brush. Anybody not Irish and on the side of the rebels is virtually subhuman, and blessed with either zero intelligence or a brain full of murder, treachery and cruelty, the rebels by contrast are angelic cherubs, and even the photography by his longtime DoP Barry Aykroyd show them as such, the lyrical shots of the Irish countryside being the backdrops for Damien and his men, and one wonders just what sort of bedside manner Damien would have had if he continued his medical studies, which anybody else is framed against grime, darkness and dirt. And such upper black / white polarity doesn't for any form of subtlety, rendering the final scenes, in which Damien and Dan are captured by Teddy, their former friend and ally, and in Damien's case brother, there is no real emotion involved, since teddy is now some state-sponsored killer, working for the hateful British since the Free State, in Loach and Laverty's opinion, is just obvious a front for perfidious Albion. Loach has never been a filmmaker of nuances, believing if a film has to have a message the viewer must be repeated pummelled with it until he screams for mercy, but even his staunchest supporters may see him as getting into an ethical tangle with The Wind That Shakes The Barley, since he clearly sees the Irish who established the Free State as traitors. One wonders just how he would handle a film on the Good Friday Agreement?