Film details

Who Killed the Electric Car?  2006

Film still

Cast

  • Greg 'Gadget' Abbott
  • Alan Cocconi
  • Greg Hanssen
  • Alexandra Paul
  • Ralph Nader
  • Iris Ovshinsky
  • Stanford R. Ovshinsky
  • Chelsea Sexton
  • Joseph J. Romm
  • Wally E. Rippel
  • Ed Begley Jr.

Synopsis

Filmmaker Chris Paine makes a documentary on the demise of the electric car, specifically General Motors' EV1, an electric car which seemed to be the answer to the petrol-enginned vehicle, working well, running for a considerable distance on a charged battery, which was durable, left no emissions and had a considerable fan base who bought and happily drove the vehicle. Paine interviews satisfied customers and drivers including some high-profile EV1 owners including Mel Gibson, Ed Begley Jr, Baywatch's Alexandra Paul and Thirtysomething's Peter Horton. The birth of the EV1 came when in 1990 the Californian authorities passed a bill demanding that a percentage of all vehicles sold in the state by all manufacturers be zero-emission vehicles. General Motors introduced the EV1 which was an immediate popular success, despite the protests of other manufacturers. S. David Freeman, a former energy adviser to President Jimmy Carter, points out that the car companies also campaigned vociferously against compulsory seat belts in their cars, claiming everything from infringement of liberty to higher costs to, weirdly, physical danger should there be a crash. With the car exceeding expectations, General Motors suddenly withdrew the EV1 from sale and discontinued production as soon as new laws passed in California allowed it to do so without penalty. Paine interviews a number of academics, scientists and other interested parties in order to discover why GM withdrew a popular and profitable model, including such experts in their fields as Californian Air Resources Board officer Alan C. Lloyd, EV1 Program director John Wallace, auto journalist for The Los Angeles Times Dan Neil, and consumer campaigner Ralph Nader, as well as EV1 designers, development engineers, project managers and EV1-specific marketing executives. The film also looks at the claims made for hydrogen cell technology, also claimed to be energy efficient and emission-free, and the insistence by author Joseph J. Romm, the author of The Truth About Hydrogen, that the science does not work, and the fact that the Bush administration gave over $2 billion in federal subsidy to hydrogen fuel research is in fact a smokescreen to fund a system they know is inefficient and unworkable so as to make the petrol engine predominant as the only viable propulsion system for cars.

Production

Director
Chris Paine
Producer
Jesse Deeter
Editor
Michael Kovalenko and Chris A. Peterson
Music
Michael Brook
Screenplay
Chris Paine
Director of Photography
Thaddeus Wadleigh

Review

Starting his film by first establishing the reasons why an electric car is needed, particularly in the smog-enveloped city of Los Angeles, director Chris Paine is obviously sincere in pursuing just why the first of such vehicles to be made available in the US market, the General Motors EV-1, was so quickly pulled from the market, despite ringing endorsements in the motor press and a host of more than satisfied customers, several of whom are wheeled out (sorry), including a frighteningly bearded Mel Gibson. Suspecting that there was more than just consumer apathy to blame for the car's demise, although that is certainly brought in as a contributory factor, Paine investigates rival car manufacturers, multi-national oil companies, various Government bodies and rival marketeers, all eventually having a finger pointed at them. Paine also aims at the hydrogen fuel cell lobby, long touted as an alternative to electricity to powering cars. A science still in its' infancy, the hydrogen cell has had an enormous amount of hype despite barely getting off the drawing board. An interview with author Joseph J. Romm, the author of The Truth About Hydrogen, infers the fact that the Bush administration gave over $2 billion in federal subsidy to hydrogen fuel research to promote a science which essentially does not work to deflect attention from one which does, electric propulsion, reasserting the oil companies and car manufacturer's hold over transportation for the foreseeable future. Paine gets some interesting views and memories from those who worked on the EV-1 project, everyone from concept engineers to managers and marketing people, and Chelsea Sexton, an 'EV-1 sales specialist' seems to have been carrying the torch for the vehicle ever since. Paine is sincere about the car and its' untimely demise, but never manages to quite pin the blame on anybody, and in a country where the President himself comes from a family who have made billions out of oil deals, that's a pretty basic failing.