Film details
This Film is Not Yet Rated 2006
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Kirby Dick
-
Matt Stone
-
John Waters
-
Atom Egoyan
-
Allison Anders
-
-
Darren Aronofsky
-
Mary Harron
-
Wayne Kramer
-
Bingham Ray
-
Kevin Smith
-
Becky Altringer
Synopsis
Kirby Dick, director of Sick - The Life And Death of Bob Flanagan, Supermasochist, embarks on a documentary about the MPAA, the Motion Picture Association of America, the ratings board to which all films theatrically released in the US are submitted. The board issues ratings such as PG, PG-13 and R, but also can issue the NC-17 rating, in which no one under 17 may be admitted. In addition to limiting the audience, many newspapers, magazines and TV stations will not accept advertisements for NC-17 movies and some will not even review them. Various directors talk about their dealings with the MPAA, including Wayne Kramer, helmer of the NC-17 rated The Cooler, whose female lead Maria Bello explains that the rating was warned through a glimpse of her public hair; Kimberly Pierce, director of Boys Don't Cry, tells of how her film had to be cut when the studio refused to release it with the NC-17; South Park co-creator Matt Stone relates how Team America was submitted to the Board with over four minutes of a sex scene involving puppets, complete with extreme footage they knew would be cut because they had to give the board 'something to bite on'; John Walters insists that his film A Dirty Shame, bearing the severe rating, actually featured no sex, just dialogue involving arcane terms dealing with quite ridiculous deviations and perversions ('Which nobody ever does....'), and Allison Anders posits the idea that the Board is against seeing people having pleasurable sex, claiming 'No one gets to come anymore'. Montages and examples show that the board is very lenient on showing violence and death. Dick also hires private detective Becky Altringer and her associates to hunt down and identify the MPAA members and raters, leading to Altringer following cars as they leave the MPAA building, following workers into diners on their lunch break, and taping and surreptitiously photographing them in cafes and on the street, then trying to identify exactly who they have been following. Suspecting one individual of being an MPAA rater, Altringer steals their rubbish in the dead of night and goes through it, feeling victorious when they find a document relating to the evaluation of Memoirs Of A Geisha. Captions show that claims made about the board and its' members, such as having school-age children, are generally false. Dick eventually submits his film to the MPAA, and receives the NC-17, the Board refusing to budge in their judgement. Going to the Appeals Board he finds he is not allowed to discover who is on the Board or ask them anything about their decision, which he likens to the 'Star chamber' secret courts of the middle ages. The rating remains unchanged, but Dick manages to identify the members of the committee, which include the CEOs of several cinema chains and the CEO of Fox Searchlight Pictures, as well as a Catholic Bishop and an Episcopalian priest.
Production
- Director
- Kirby Dick
- Producer
- Eddie Schmidt
- Editor
- Matt Clarke
- Music
- Michael S. Patterson
- Screenplay
- Kirby Dick and Eddie Schmidt
- Director of Photography
- Shana Hagan, Kirsten Johnson, Michael Parry, Amy Vincent and Ben Wolf
Review
Director Kirby Dick probably condemns his future films to Ratings Board hell in this expose of the MPAA, the American movies ratings board whose decisions, often seeming arbitrary and wildly inconsistent, are essentially final, very few films which appeal against their rating ever succeeding - unless they are major studio films, of course. Headed until his retirement in 2005 by Jack Valenti, a staunch Republican who was a former speechwriter for both Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon, the board's decision is final, and very often swayed by various special interest groups andlobbyists. More sinister is the lack of information about the board members and those who actually rate the movies, which takes Dick's film on a path which ultimately derails it as he becomes involved with the oddly obsessive and strangely dislikeable Becky Altringer, whose methods verge on the psychotic as she stalks innocent people and isn't above throwing her 4x4 through several lanes of traffic at high speed when tailing a car, a scene in which Kirby Dick, filming on DV, is clearly alarmed. In a split-screen montage in which scenes from R and NC-17 rated films are compared, Dick isn't exactly playing on a level field. A sex scene from Gregg Araki's Mysterious Skin (NC-17) is compared with very similar scene from the R-rated Unfaithful, insinuating that the first is only given the higher rating through being a gay scene, not mentioning that Araki's film also had severe violence and a character relating a long and truly disturbing story about sex with an eight-year-old. The interviewees are much more interesting than the stalkers Dick deals with, with pungent comments from Maria Bello on why her pubic hair in The Cooler earned the film the NC-17, from Mary Harron on why chainsaw death in American Psycho was acceptable but three-way sex wasn't (I blame the Phil Collins soundtrack personally), and Matt Stone, explaining why Team America has such outrageous sex, between puppets, just so the MPAA could have something to take action against, but be warned that some of the cut footage from Parker and Stone's movie is included, and while hilarious is also revolting. One of the most unsettling points is made by the ever droll John Waters, whose A Dirty Shame earned the dreaded rating and who points out that these isn't actually any sex in it, just the use of terms such as 'feltching' (look it up, if you dare), which he insists nobody ever does ('And I know a lot of perverts....'), leading him to opine that you used not to be able to show sex in films, and now you can't even talk about it. Dick's film takes an even more surreal turn when he submits it to the MPAA and gets the inevitable NC-17 then goes to the Appeals Board, to find not only is he not allowed to know who is actually on the Appeals Board, but cannot ask them their names when he appears before them, a weirdly draconian and probably illegal practice under the US Constitution, but then the MPAA has always been a law unto itself, and as long as it massages the studios, won't be changing anytime soon.