Film details

A Mighty Heart  2007

Film still

Cast

  • Dan Futterman
  • Archie Panjabi
  • Irrfan Khan
  • Denis O'Hare
  • Mohammed Afzal
  • Mushtaq Ahmed
  • Gary Wilmes
  • Daud Khan
  • Telai Saeed
  • Tipu Taheer

Synopsis

Daniel Pearl, a reporter for The Wall Street Journal, is in Pakistan in January 2002, researching a piece on the recently captured and incarcerated Robert Reid, the so-called 'shoe bomber'. With him is Mariane, his pregnant French-Cuban wife, who is also a journalist. They stay with their friend Asra Nomani, an Indian Muslim writer and journalist. Bashir, a contact, comes to Daniel, telling him he has arranged an interview with Sheikh Gilani, a prominent militant in the area. Daniel leaves to rendezvous with Bashir, but does not return. The authorities do not seem unduly unconcerned, but with Asra's assistance Mariane coerces them into investigating Daniel's disappearance, and also tries to get information from Masud, one of Daniel's major contacts and the man who introduced him to Bashir. As news of Daniel's disappearance and possible abduction starts to spread, Mariane and Asra find themselves getting support from a number of sources, including Randall Bennett, an operative within the US Consulate, and John Bussey, a New York-based Wall Street Journal editor who flies to Pakistan to offer whatever help the organisation can. The Pakistani Police investigation, headed by Captain Javad Nabib, establish Daniel's chain of contacts on the night he vanished and make a series of arrests. Needing higher levels of government to get involved, Mariane's request that the Pakistan interior ministry get involved are rejected, the minister claiming that the kidnapping is actually a plot by Indian agents in order to discredit Pakistan in the eyes of the US and other countries in the region. The international media start to carry the story of Pearl's disappearance, prompting his kidnappers to release a statement claiming he is in fact a CIA agent. Once it is revealed he is Jewish the abductors claim he is working for the Israeli secret service, Mossad. Mariane and Asra are shocked when news arrives that he has been killed, but the report is soon proved to be a false alarm. The Police arrest Sheikh Gilani but he denies being involved with Daniel, insisting his name was used by the abductors to lure Pearl into a trap. The Police, wary that they are being watched by the world's media, organise a round-up of militants and extremists, once of whom is 'Bashir', who in actuality is Omar Saeed Sheikh, a known and active militant. Mariane still waits for news of her husband until, on 1st February, a videotape is delivered....

Production

Director
Michael Winterbottom
Producer
Andrew Eaton, Dede Gardner and Brad Pitt
Art Director
Christophe Stull
Editor
Peter Christelis
Music
Harry Escott and Molly Nyman
Screenplay
John Orloff, based on the book by Marlane Pearl
Director of Photography
Marcel Zyskind

Review

What was originally regarded, and derided by some, as strange casting, with many questioning Angelina Jolie's suitability to play Mariane Pearl, the widow of murdered American reporter Daniel Pearl, the choice was not aided by the fact that hubby Brad Pitt is also one of the producers, and some also questioned the choice of Michael Winterbottom helming the project, but if there was a director able to give a balanced and serious telling of the story, without plunging into American sentimentality, it is certainly Winterbottom, the maker of such diverse films as Nine Songs, A Cock And Bull Story and 24 Hour Party People. The director and his well-chosen cast have a difficult job to pull off, to tell the story of Daniel Pearl and his abduction as a thriller, when the hideous final outcome is already known, and how to also not let the story sink under a tide of sentiment, but Winterbottom pulls off the task remarkably well, with Jolie giving one of the best performances in her career, playing Mariane Pearl as a strong and determined woman who is suddenly faced by a wall of non-cooperation which can be seen as both incompetence and tacit collusion. Only when the Western media start to focus on his case, something not afforded to non-Western kidnap victims, do the Pakistani authorities start to search in earnest. Pearl (played by Dan Futterman, the US actor also responsible for the screenplay of Capote) is actually seen in very little of the actual film, even though his presence is felt throughout as false alarms and misleading statements are constantly issued. Apart from Jolie and Futterman the cast is largely from the sub-continent, with Winterbottom refusing to cast any particularly well-known Bollywood names, although he has a few recognisable players in the cast, including the excellent Archie Panjabi (A Good Year) as Marlane's close friend Asra, and a very fine performance from Irrfan Khan as Captain Nabib, trying to walk the tightrope between Mariane and Asra's increasingly strident efforts to get the Pakistani Police to actually act, and towing the official governmental line. Even though the film hits a narrative lull about halfway through, where the women have to essentially wait for any news that may arrive, the performances, and Winterbottom's assured handling, keeps the audience watching, remarkably managing to keep alive the possibility that Daniel Pearl may actually survive, despite the truth of the matter. Jolie's performance is finely controlled, only losing her grip, and all hope, when the fateful videotape arrives, and Winterbottom knows how to use this for maximum, yet discreet effect. Its' a harrowing and sad story, but for once the casting is perfect for the tale rather than just being some sort of socially concerned vanity vehicle for a Hollywood star, and Michael Winterbottom has treated it with dignity and gravity rather than syrup and sentimentality.