Film details

Goodbye Bafana  2007

Still unavailable

Cast

  • Joseph Feinnes
  • Dennis Haysbert
  • Shiloh Henderson
  • Mehboob Bawa
  • Warrick Grier
  • Patrick Lyster
  • Terry Pheto
  • Leslie Mongezi
  • Jennifer Styne
  • Adrian Galley
  • Claire Berlein

Synopsis

1968, and in South Africa the Nationalist Party government is implementing its' apartheid policies with an unyielding hand. Nelson Mandela, a high-profile ANC opposition leader has been arrested and tried, and is sentenced to serve his time in the prison on Robben Island. James Gregory, one of the staff, is assigned specifically to guard him. Having grown up in the Transki region, where he learned the local Xhosa language, Gregory is chosen so he will be able to eavesdrop on the conversations between the prisoners. Gregory supports the apartheid regime, and his views are shared by his wife, Gloria, who is raising their two sons with the same doctrine. Mandela receives news that his oldest son has been killed in a car crash, and Gregory starts to feel sympathy with the man, refused permission to attend his son's funeral. Gregory starts to think back to his childhood, and especially Bafana, a young black boy with whom he had a close friendship and who gave him a protective tribal bracelet. Gregory reveals to Mandela that he speaks Xhosa, and starts to have conversations with him in the language. He also obtains a copy of the ANC's Freedom Charter, a publication officially banned throughout South Africa. He starts to interfere with the prison mail service, fearing secret information is being leaked in some coded references, and several black activists are killed as a result. Gregory starts to be racked with guilt, and contacts Nelson Mandela's wife, Winnie, managing to get to her a gift from her husband. Others start to realise a change in Gregory's manner, and he is attacked and beaten up in a bar, having been accused by the other white patrons of being a 'kaffir lover'. Worried that his family could be placed in danger through his actions, he gets himself transferred to another post, away from Robben Island. In 1982 he is transferred back, and once more assigned to guard Nelson Mandela. The authorities, wanting to engineer some sort of peace deal with Mandela and his followers, offer him a compromise agreement, but Mandela refuses to sign it. Six years later, in 1988, Gregory's son is killed in a car crash, and Mandela shows him the same empathy as Gregory did to him years previously. In 1990 it is announced that Nelson Mandela, after more than two decades on Robben Island, is to be released...

Production

Director
Bille August
Producer
Ilann Girard, Andro Steinborn and Jean-Luc Van Damme
Art Director
Jonathan Hely-Hutchinson
Editor
Herve Schneid
Music
Dario Marianelli
Screenplay
Greg Lafter, adapted by Greg Lafter and Bille August from the book by James Gregory and Bob Graham
Director of Photography
Robert Fraisse

Review

With the apartheid history of South Africa now being on the filmmaking agenda (i.e. Catch A Fire), director Bille August (Pelle The Conqueror / Smilla's Sense Of Snow) offers a view from the other side of the divide as usually shown, in telling the story of James Gregory, the man who was Nelson Mandela's guard for over twenty years during his imprisonment on Robben Island. Played by Joseph Feinnes (Shakespeare In Love), Gregory at first sees the job as guarding, as he has been told, one of the most dangerous men in the country, Mandela being played by the excellent Dennis Haysbert (Far From Heaven / TV's 24), but eventually comes to be friendly with Mandela although still being loyal to the state of South Africa and the Government of the time. Although this is essentially the essence of the story, the source material is rather more contentious, with many claiming that Gregory's memoirs are essentially fake. It is claimed he barely knew Mandela, despite the time spent at Robben island, and that much of his supposed knowledge of the man was gleaned through his letters, which Gregory had access to as they were being censored before being allowed to be sent, and the long and rambling conversations which supposedly occurred between guard and prisoner simply never happened, thus the book, and film, are essentially fiction. Gregory has staunchly defended the veracity of his book, and Mandela has not commented on the matter one way or the other. Thus Goodbye Bafana comes across as rather self-serving, with Fiennes' Gregory seeming to be an extraordinarily perceptive prison guard when he, and seemingly he alone, can see that Nelson Mandela is not a terrorist, but a man of peace, and this at a time when the South African government was secretly trying to pass a death sentence on him. As with almost any film dealing with the complex social and political history of South Africa there is a degree of simplification involved, but August's film once more turns it into a simple case of - unfortunately - black and white. Mandela is treated so respectfully, by both director and actor, that he comes across as a candidate for living beatification. Gregory's family are little more than uneducated Boer settlers, although he of course had black friends as a child and even learned the complex Xhosa language. The supporting cast has Diane Kruger (Troy) as Gregory's wife Gloria, who starts to see the change in her husband as he begins to realise that while he still believes in the apartheid state, perhaps there is a way of at least partial integration and equality, or at least so Gregory later claimed. Goodbye Bafana seems so intent on making saints of both Mandela and Gregory that any real drama is lost in the respectful silences and solemnity.