Film details

In The Valley Of Elah  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Hank Deerfield, a Vietnam veteran living out his retirement in Munro, Tennessee, receives the news that his son Mike, whose unit has just returned from active duty in Iraq, has been reported AWOL from his army base in Fort Rudd, New Mexico. His wife Joan is against him getting involved, but Hank drives down to Fort Rudd, his questions to Lieutenant Kirklander, Mike's platoon commander, being expertly fielded, giving Hank no firm answers at all. He contacts the local Police, only to be told by the helpful Detective Emily Sanders that the case comes under the jurisdiction of the Army and not the local law enforcers. When Hank gives Mike's badly damaged mobile phone to Gabriel, a local phone technician, he tries to restore the scenes of video footage recorded on it. Mike's badly mutilated body is found by a roadside in the New Mexican desert, having been repeatedly stabbed before being burned and semi-dismembered. His platoon mates Spc. Gordon Bonner, Corporal Steve Penning, Private Robert Ortiez and Spc. Ennis Long are interviewed, being the last soldiers to see him alive, and they reveal that he seemed agitated and disturbed. The Police insist they cannot investigate, since the killing happened outside the city limits, but Hank, himself a former Military Policeman, persuades the sympathetic Emily to help with his own unofficial investigations. Her own department, as well as the Army, prove un-cooperative, but Emily finds that Mike and his friends were out drinking on the night he vanished, and witnesses reveal a violent argument broke out. Gabriel contacts Hank, having retrieved the footage on Mike's phone, but Hank is horrified to find it is scenes of Iraqi civilians being tortured and abused, one of the main perpetrators being Mike himself. Realising Hank has discovered what was really happening in Mike's platoon, Lt. Kirklander tries to suggest that Mike had got involved with Mexican drug dealers, and had tried to doublecross them, his murder being savage revenge, but Hank does not accept this explanation. Emily finds that a diner receipt, supposedly signed by Mike and which established him in the diner at a certain time, is a forgery, the signature having been faked by Steve Penning. Hank knows that the four men know more than they are telling, and to expose what really happened to his son he will have to put pressure on them, but the Army starts to close ranks, knowing there are some aspects of the Iraq War it has to keep secret...

Production

Director
Paul Haggis
Producer
Patrick Wachsberger, Steven Samuels, Darlene Caamano Loquet, Paul Haggis and Laurence Becsey
Art Director
Greg Hooper
Editor
Jo Francis
Music
Mark Isham
Screenplay
Paul Haggis, based on a story by Paul Haggis and Mark Boal, based on reportage by Mark Boal
Director of Photography
Roger Deakins

Review

Paul Haggis received copious praise and awards for his rather simplistic look at race relations in America, Crash, and with In The Valley Of Elah he may have done little to assuage his detractors, writing and directing another solemn and slow tale with a rather obvious message, that war is bad and affects people in more ways than one, which as blinding insights go isn't exactly news. Based on a true story reported by Mark Boal in, of all publications, Playboy, and dealing with the Iraq War and it's aftermath, Hank Deerfield (Tommy Lee Jones), is a Tennessee ex-Vietnam vet who hears that his son, Mike, has gone missing since his unit has returned from Iraq. With surprising rapidity Hank goes to the unit's New Mexico base hoping to find his son, but no one there is talking and the officers seem to be covering something up. When a body is found and a crime scene declared, the local Police seem more than keen to hand it over to the base MPs, but Hank, with local cop Emily Sanders (Charlize Theron), naturally the only woman in her department and heavily put-upon by the other sexist, misogynist cops, want to investigate further. An interesting premise, and one Boal insists is based on more than one factual incidence, is hobbled by Haggis' heavy-handed message, his broad characterisations - every single Army man is a shifty, tight-lipped borderline psycho - and such obvious emotional touches as Theron's character being a put-upon single mother, having to fight every day in both her professional and private life. The pretentious title refers to the location where David was said to have taken on, and defeated, Goliath, but the film is at least partially rescued by Jones, an actor whose performances are now rather hit and miss, depending on whether or not he can be bothered to give an actual performance, as the increasingly disillusioned Hank, a man with a strong moral line which he believes others should also adhere to. The final scene, Hank flying the Stars and Stripes upside down is, like the title, obscure, with few viewers probably knowing it is a recognised international distress signal. What could have been a drama with an intelligent and cogent concept, with considerable possibilities, becomes moralising and plodding, rather like the over-praised Crash.