Film details

Lions For Lambs  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

As the US launch a new military strategy in Afghanistan, Senator Jasper Irving grants veteran political TV reporter Janine Roth an exclusive one-to-one interview, wanting her to be the first with the news of the latest Army plans and his ideas for the next military moves and strategies. Meanwhile Stephen Malley, a Professor of philosophy at a Californian University, is having a private meeting with Todd Hayes, a student who Malley believes is wasting his potential, having become disengaged from the political life of the campus. Malley thinks Todd could have a career in some political sphere but Todd is disillusioned and tired of cynical politicians and their motives. Malley tells him of two former students, Ernest Rodriguez and Arian Finch, who have joined the Army both through feelings of patriotism and also to have Army service on their CVs for their potential futures in politics. As Malley and Todd are speaking, Rodriguez and Finch are in the mountains of Afghanistan, wounded and isolated from their unit as Irving's military plans go badly awry. Waiting for reinforcements or medical evacuation, they remember how Professor Malley tried to dissuade them from joining up, despite their deep involvement in world politics and their ambition to make a difference. Roth tries to argue with Irving that his absolute certainty that any insurgency can be defeated with overwhelming troop numbers and firepower is disproved by any reading of historical parallels, while Malley tries to shake Todd free of his indifference by comparing his attitude and cynicism to the devotion and commitment shown by Rodriguez and Arian. As the discussions continue in both Washington and California, soldiers Rodriguez and Arian wait for a rescue which now seems more unlikely as time passes and the battle rages around them.

Production

Director
Robert Redford
Producer
Matthew Michael Carnahan, Tracy Falco, Andrew Hauptman and Robert Redford
Art Director
Francois Audouy
Editor
Joe Hutshing
Music
Mark Isham
Screenplay
Matthew Michael Carnahan
Director of Photography
Philippe Rousselot

Review

In years to come the directorial career of Robert Redford may probably be seen as more interesting and more important than his acting, with such films as A River Runs Through It and Quiz Show showing a real filmmaker's skill and very deft work with characterisation. Lions For Lambs, his first film for seven years, may also be his most ambitious film, dealing with the conflict in Afghanistan and the effects it has on a number of people, running three distinct, separate and yet interlinked strands. Redford himself plays Dr. Malley, a West Coast University lecturer who inspired two of his students, Arian (Derek Luke - Antoine Fisher) and Ernest (Michael Pena - World Trade Centre) to follow his advice and do something meaningful with their lives, but to this pair that means travelling to join the Army to fight in Afghanistan. Malley is now talking to disengaged student Todd (Andrew Garfield), who is reluctant to get involved in the political side of his studies, Malley finding himself trying to inspire some sort of passion and response within him, while in Washington, Senator Jasper Irving (Tom Cruise), is briefing a crusading TV journalist (Meryl Streep) concerning the war in Afghanistan and his own strategies for going forward, refusing to listen to any of Roth's counter-arguments and her warning to study the history of such conflicts. As the discussions volley back and forth, Arian and Ernest are awaiting a medical evacuation from the Afghan battlefield, with their hopes of rescue dwindling. Ms. Streep would seem to be a bit of a fixture in this sort of politically-oriented drama / thriller, after her role as the cold and calculating CIA terrorism consultant in Gavin Hood's Rendition, but his role as the slimy, cold Senator proves that, as with such films as Magnolia, Tom Cruise is far better suited to the roles of the intelligent and utterly convincing villains than grinning heroes. Interestingly the cast also includes Peter Berg, the director of the equally US-critical Riyadh-set The Kingdom, also written by Matthew Michael Carnahan, but which takes a rather different approach to the argument than Redford's reasoned and measured drama. Many will regard this as a thinly veiled anti-war polemic, and despite the effectively staged and shot battle scenes the film really is two separate duologues, but both Redford's direction and performance are totally convincing, and the three leads give excellent portrayals of people totally devoted to their own points of view, and reluctant to listen to any sort of argument.