Film details

Taking Liberties  2007

Still unavailable

Cast

  • Walter Wolfgang
  • Mark Thomas
  • Boris Johnson
  • Kenneth Clarke
  • Clare Short
  • Michael Mansfield
  • John Tulloch
  • Clive Stafford Smith
  • Moazzam Begg
  • Toby Rhodes
  • David Morrissey Narrator
  • Ashley Jensen Narrator

Synopsis

A documentary claiming that civil liberties in the UK have been steadily eroded since the election of the Labour Government in 1997. After citing that the loss of the right of habeas corpus, the legal guarantee that no one can be imprisoned unlawfully, could provoke riots in 18th Century London when it was suspended, now that right has been almost eliminated under layers of law and regulation. Stating that many human and civil rights have been eroded, the lessening of the right to legal protest is illustrated with the examples of Walter Wolfgang, a long-time Labour Party member and pensioner who was removed from the hall and arrested and held under the Terrorism Act after heckling at the Labour Party Conference. Home Secretary Jack Straw is seen after an agreement was made with the US allowing British terrorist suspects to be extradited without the necessary evidence, but that agreement is only one-way, with US citizens not subject to the same rules. Ex-Guantanamo Bay internee Moazzam Begg claims that he was tortured and his human rights infringed with the full knowledge of the British government. Other instances cited include the turning away of buses full of protesters on their way to RAF Fairfield in order to protest bombing flights leaving from the airfield. Police removing protesters from outside a weapons guidance systems factory on the South Coast, and the removal of Brian Haw, who has staged a one-man protest outside the Houses of Parliament to highlight the Iraq War.

Production

Director
Chris Atkins
Producer
Nicky Moss
Art Director
Not credited
Editor
Nick Fenton
Music
Vincent Moss
Screenplay
Chris Atkins
Director of Photography
Chris Smith and Jules Lewis

Review

Accepting the common knowledge that there is really no such thing as an impartial documentary, Chris Atkins' Taking Liberties comes with a very hard and certain political agenda, that the Blair Government has eroded civil liberties, but uses selective information and footage, and clear distortion, or perhaps a crucially centrally flawed concept at best. The film repeats several times that Brian Haw, whose one man protest sprawled across the pavement on the Embankment was 'unlawfully' removed because the government rescinded his right to protest on Parliamentary property. In actuality this is a fallacy, since there has never been such a law or allowance on the statute book, anybody protesting being subject to the same laws of obstruction or trespass as anybody else, so Atkins' main bone of contention, making Haw into some sort of martyr, is actually based on a flawed premise to begin with. Although some of the protesters involved certainly have grievances, Atkins manages to be remarkably blinkered about certain aspects of UK Government and none of the civil infractions of the Thatcher or Major regimes are mentioned, such as the stopping and compulsory photographing of protesters travelling to support miners during the strikes of the Eighties, or Thatcher's close personal friendship with detestable dictator and mass murderer General Augusto Pinochet, hardly a champion of human rights in his native Chile, but then such mere details would undermine the director's attack. His interviewees are similarly hand-selected, with the 7/7 survivors who appear all being remarkably calm about the atrocity in which they were involved, and certainly no one is featured who wants control orders and curfews for extremists and suspected terrorists. Atkins also seems to find surprisingly few MPs to actually go on the record for his film from any side of the house, his only interviews conducted primarily for the film and not culled from previous footage comprising the rather surprising trio of Boris Johnson, the largely marginalised Ken Clarke and the discredited Clare Short, not particularly political heavyweights, and Short's contribution seems purely fuelled by a personal grudge against Tony Blair rather than any serious political reasoning. Atkins is shouting loudly, but also very selectively, and is really pushing his message towards the choir, the bias and flawed proposition on which the film is centred being unlikely to make any new converts. As a neat aside Atkins' film was highly praised and recommended on pro-fox hunting websites, which were probably not the sort of people the director was thinking of appealing to when he assembled his footage, or maybe they are, and that's the real agenda behind such a skewed piece of work.