Film details

Rendition  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Advance word on Gavin Hood's Rendition is extremely interesting, with many critics wondering just how Hood could take such a strong cast and a promising story which includes terrorism, kidnapping, secret CIA torture chambers and politically-sanctioned murder and yet make it so strangely mundane. An Oscar winner for his South African feature Tsotsi, Hood plays down the more sensational elements of the script, but to such a degree that Rendition plods along with very little in the way of narrative drive or actual excitement, despite dealing with very relevant subjects. Focus of the film is Anwar El-Ibrahimi (Omar Metwally), the Egyptian-born but American-educated husband of Chicagoan Isabella (Reese Witherspoon), abducted after returning home after a business trip to Africa. The evidence of his kidnapping, or 'extraordinary rendition', are a few mobile phone calls to a contact who has the same name as a wanted terrorist, but a name which is extremely common in Arab countries. Meanwhile a new CIA case officer, Douglas Freeman (Jake Gyllenhaal), is appointed to a North African country after the established official is killed in a suicide bombing. He is soon introduced to the torture methods used, ranging from the 'waterboarding' simulated drowning treatment to old-fashioned pummellings. This is where Anwar is sent as Isabella contacts an old school friend, Alan Smith (Peter Sarsgaard), who now works for the high-profile Senator Hawkins (Alan Arkin) in order to try to find what has happened to her husband. Despite this promising premise, surprisingly little seems to happen in Rendition apart from several people sitting around looking perturbed, and even the central villain, local cop cum torturer Abasi (Igai Naor) is given a lot of domestic problems and back story, as if to give him some sort of human side. Hood certainly has the elements to work with, but what seems to be an attempt to be scrupulously fair to all sides, even CIA torturers, renders Rendition surprisingly toothless.

Production

Director
Gavin Hood
Producer
Steve Golin and Marcus Viscidi
Art Director
Tony Noble, Harry Pain
Editor
Megan Gill
Music
Paul Hepker and Mark Kilian
Screenplay
Kelley Sane
Director of Photography
Dion Beebe

Review

Director Gavin Hood tackles the controversial issue of torture in 'Rendition'. The title is taken from "Extreme rendition" that refers to the American policy of moving terror suspects to facilities not on U.S. soil, where they are not subject to due process and can be tortured as a means of eliciting information. Arguments for this are that valuable intelligence can be gained, thereby saving lives. The equally valid argument against it is that the tactics are inhumane and can be used on innocent victims. Hypocritical for a country that prides itself on the "innocent until proven guilty" judicial motto. After a suicide bombing in North Africa, Egyptian-American Anwar El-Ibrahimi (Omar Metwally) is illegaly kidnapped from the US by the CIA and flown out to Marrakech. An American CIA operative, Douglas Freeman (Jake Gyllenhaal), questions his assignment after witnessing the interrogation that includes torture by Moroccan interrogator Abasi Fawal (Igal Naor) at the secret detention facility. Meanwhile Anwar's pregnant wife, Isabella (Reese Witherspoon), recruits the help of Alan Smith (Peter Sarsgaard), a top aid to Senator Hawkins (Alan Arkin) to locate her husband. Screenwriter Kelley Sane and Gavin Hood obviously take the stance that rendition is a gross abuse of power. The scenes of torture under the guise of Homeland Security are powerful and disturbing, but at the same time don't repel. The film has a good cast and despite having little to work with they do well. Peter Sarsgaard as aide Alan Smith is excellent, treading a political tightrope of helping his old friend Isabella while trying not to jeopardize his career. Sharp-talking Streep and Sarsgaard have a great moment at a party where they have an intense and heated exchange and Gyllenhaal plays the part of the CIA man, well in over his head with his first torture case. But unfortunately Hood shies away from delving too deeply into the rendition debate by introducing a subplot about a daughter and a suicide bomber which causes the film to lose some of its pace. This sacrifice may allow Hood's film to appeal to a wider audience especially with the way he manages to tie up all the loose ends even when it does stretch the boundaries of credulity, leaving unanswered questions. But by trying not to offend anyone, Gavin Hood muzzles what could have been a political film with bite.