Film details

Definitely, Maybe  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Will Hayes, a man in his thirties, in the process of splitting up from his wife, is telling his only child, eleven-year-old daughter, Maya, how he met the woman who was her mother, but changes the names in his story as he tells her, so she will not know which woman it reaslly is. 1992, and Will, originally from Wisconsin, goes to New York to work as a volunteer on Bill Clinton's Presidential campaign, leaving his girlfriend and college sweetheart Emily behind. Will meets the two women who, along with Emily, will come to mean most to him in his life - April, a clever and argumentative debater and Summer Hartley, a schoolfriend of Emily and a journalist with very definite ambitions. Having rehearsed his marriage proposal to Emily with April, he asks Emily herself but she cuts him short, telling him that while he was away she has hand an affair. Two years pass, and Will is still working in politics and is involved with Summer. April is travelling, but still in contact with Will, the pair regularly exchanging letters. Will is preparing to propose to Summer, but when April returns to New York she is upset that Will is considering marrying her. Summer then publishes a political expose concerning the politician Will is helping to promote, and he believes she used their relationship in order to get close to her 'material'. He changes his mind about marrying her. By 1998 Will is jaded with life in the political world, his initial feelings of altruism and dedication having drained away. Meeting April their conversation soon becomes heated and combative, and afterwards he tries to apologise and repair their friendship, but knows they cannot get back together, she now being involved in a new relationship. A meeting with Summer brings Emily back into Will's life once more. Maya guesses correctly that Emily is the woman who is her mother, which is correct, but then tells Will something he has been avoiding for years, something he refuses to admit even to himself...

Production

Director
Adam Brooks
Producer
Eric Fellner and Tim Bevan
Art Director
Peter Rogness
Editor
Peter Teschner
Music
Clint Mansell
Screenplay
Adam Brooks
Director of Photography
Florian Ballhous

Review

Although co-produced by the British Working Title Films, responsible for the likes of Four Weddings... and Love Actually, which immediately makes them divisive in the opinions of many critics and potential viewers, Definitely, Maybe, sharing its' title with the Oasis song, would seem to be fitting into the same template, with attractive leads, multiple relationships, and a true love story in the middle, even including a cute child this time around, played by Abigail Breslin from Little Miss Sunshine. What the film, written and directed by Adam Brooks, actually proves to be is a rather darker spin on the old tale of how I met your mother (which would make a very good title for a TV comedy series - oh, wait..), and it basically uses that as a hook, political analyst Will (Ryan Reynolds - Blade: Trinity) leaving his home town, and childhood girlfriend Emily (Elizabeth Banks - The Uninvited / TV's Scrubs) behind to go and work in New York, meeting and becoming involved with two other women, April (Isla Fisher - Wedding Crashers) and then, fittingly, Summer (Rachel Weitz - The Mummy / The Constant Gardener). For all the intricacies of his relationships with them there is one overriding element, politics, and the fact that he is more involved with the political world than the emotional one, personified when it seems that Summer has been in a relationship for him purely to be able to get material on the candidate he is representing. Will is hurt by most people in his life, from the women he believes he loves to those Senators and even Presidents who do not prove worthy of his trust. Since director Brooks also wrote Wimbledon and the Bridget Jones sequel, this is actually a more serious outing into the problems of relationships than either of those two, and even at the end, when the precocious but actually very funny Breslin has divined who of the disguised three is actually her mother, the decision Will has been avoiding for years is brought centre stage, with him realising that he has literally got all his relationships wrong for most of his life, and is forced to try to make a reconciliation with the woman he realises he should have been with all along. With the leads all giving winning performances, and Reynolds showing he can be a very convincing actor in the right role, which doesn't essentially allow so much self-satisfied preening, Definitely, Maybe, may surprise many because of the essential sadness at its' core as Will realises the wrong choices he took, and Brooks peppers the soundtrack, spanning some fifteen years, with terrific tracks, ranging from such known anthems as Unbelievable by EMF and Fleetwood Mac's Don't Stop to decidedly more offbeat fayre such as The Flaming Lips' excellent Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots and The Boy With The Arab Strap by Belle And Sebastian, showing very wide and extremely good taste in music. As satisfying in its' own way as anything the company have been involved it, Brooks' film is well written and deftly directed, and while it isn't as gleefully optimistic and rose-tinted as the likes of Love Actually, is all the better for a shot of both acid and tears in the mix.