Film details

Mr. Brooks  2007

Film still

Cast

  • Dane Cook
  • Marg Helgenberger
  • Danielle Panabaker
  • Lindsay Crouse
  • Ruben Santiago-Hudson
  • Reiko Aylesworth
  • Matt Schultze
  • Yasmine Delawari
  • Aisha Hinds

Synopsis

Earl Brooks is a successful middle-aged industrialist, living in Portland, Oregon with his wife Emma, their teenage daughter Jane being away at college. But Earl has an alter ego and a dark secret. Marshall, his imaginary, cajoling companion urges Earl on when he becomes a psychotic serial killer, slaying with both ferocity and cold creativity. He visits AA meetings, watching others confess their addictions, but does not reveal his own. Earl has not claimed any victims for a while, but egged on by Marshall's constant badgering, he commits a vicious double murder. The murder is witnessed by a young photographer, who takes pictures and presents himself at Brooks' office the following day. Introducing himself as Mr. Smith, he shows Earl the photographs he took through the open curtains. Marshall, invisible to all but Earl, urges killing him quickly, but Smith does not demand any money, rather that Earl lets him come with him on his murderous outings. Investigating the latest killings, Detective Tracy Atwood ascribes it to the serial murderer known as The Thumbprint Killer, a name earned by a piece of evidence found at an earlier slaying. A murderer known as The Hangman, a killer previously caught and incarcerated by Atwood, escapes jail, intent on making her his next victim. Jane confesses to her parents that she's pregnant, just as a student at her college is found gruesomely murdered and an investigation launched, Jane being counted among the suspects. Earl realises that Jane may indeed be the killer, so goes to her college and commits another murder with an identical modus operandi in order to divert suspicion from his daughter. Satisfied the job is done, he returns to Portland and takes Mr. Smith with him when he attacks Detective Atwood's ex-husband, who he knows she hates with a vengeance, and also the lawyer handling the husband's divorce. When the bodies are discovered Atwood herself falls under suspicion, although she believes it is the work of the escaped Hangman, but with more than one serial killer on the loose, the killing spree is far from over....

Production

Director
Bruce A. Evans
Producer
Kevin Costner, Raynold Gideon and Jim Wilson
Art Director
William Ladd Skinner
Editor
Miklos Wright
Music
Ramin Djawadi
Screenplay
Bruce A. Evans and Raynold Gideon
Director of Photography
John Lindsey

Review

Certainly not the box-office draw he briefly was just over a decade ago, though we're still kind of fond of Waterworld, Kevin Costner is still making films, even if they tend to be rather smaller scale these days, character comedies such as The Upside of Anger, or studio misfires such as the misguided The Graduate sequel everybody quickly passed over. Mr. Brooks is certainly a change of style for Costner, playing the title character, Earl Brooks, a perfectly ordinary and peaceful man who is a psychotic, murdering maniac, complete with a harrying, cajoling imaginary companion, played beautifully by William Hurt, an actor who finally seems to be fulfilling his early promise as he matures. Hurt's character is not used as a plot twist, as in A Beautiful Mind or De Palma's Raising Cain, director and co-writer Bruce A. Evans making it perfectly clear that Marshall is purely a projection of Brooks' crazed mind. Costner as villain, or at least a disagreeable character, always seems to be more convincing, and certainly more sincere, than his good guy roles, and Evans makes Brooks a truly horrendous character when in murder mode, but unfortunately the film is just packed with too much macabre incident and convoluted plotting. Adding another escaped serial killer, as well as his own daughter possibly having inherited her father's talent for murder, as well as the slaying of a Detective's hated ex-husband and his lawyer in order to have her as a suspect rather muddies the waters, and forces the script into contortions in order to accommodate them all rather than focusing on the compelling double act of Brooks and Marshall. The film wants to pack an awful lot in, but unfortunately this only actually dilutes the fascinating core of the movie. Evans deals well with a varied cast including another has-been - sorry, but the truth hurts - in the form of Demi Moore, and rather more reliable players such as Marg Helgenberger (TV's C.S.I.), Lindsay Crouse (House Of Games) and Reiko Aylesworth (Alien Vs. Predator 2). Costner has gone on record as saying that this would be the first part of a trilogy, which the uninspiring US box-office figures probably suffocated at birth.