Film details

Sleuth  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Jude Law once again steps into a role first taken by Michael Caine, as he did with the rather disastrous remake of Alfie, but here Law goes one further by co-starring with the man himself, Caine taking the role played by Laurence Olivier in the original 1972 film version of Anthony Shaffer's play. Director Kenneth Branagh, working from a Howard Pinter adaptation of the original script, loses rather a lot of the surprise that the play and film first caused over three decades ago in that Shaffer was pulling a large trick on the audience by listing several completely fictional actors, such as 'Alec Cawthorne', complete with bogus CVs and details, in the programme, when in fact the play is purely a two-hander, even though there is actually more than two 'roles' being played on screen, as it were. What the story boils down to is a piece of psychological warfare as rich and aging Andrew Wyke, a jealous and manipulative writer, invites Milo Tindle, the young actor who has stolen Wyke's much younger wife, down to his country estate in order to talk about the situation and what to do about it. Of course Wyke is planning to turn on Tindle and make him fear for his life, but things take a nasty turn which requires the Police to be called in... Its' an interesting play with some smart lines, but much of the element of surprise of the piece is gone, meaning that one will be watching a clever but very theatrical work, with some very apparent trickery happening before your very eyes, which may not have been so obvious when viewed from theatre stalls. A nice idea, and it will be interesting to see Caine spar with the man who is so obviously trying to be the heir to his throne, but any surprises are long gone.

Production

Director
Kenneth Branagh
Producer
Simon Halfon, Jude Law, Simon Moseley, Marion Pilowsky and Tom Sternberg
Art Director
Tim Harvey
Editor
Neil Farrell
Screenplay
Harold Pinter, based on the play by Peter Schaffer
Director of Photography
Hans Zamborloukos

Review

Whilst being nominally a remake of Joseph L. Mankiewicz's 1972 film of Anthony Shaffer's stage play, Kenneth Branagh's new film version of Sleuth jettisons many of the elements of the earlier film. The screenplay by Harold Pinter wants to attempt something grittier, more relevant to today's audience. Therefore the characters are presented in a more realistic manner. Pinter seems less concerned with the country house mysteries of Shaffer's original and more interested in the power play between a rich bully and a vain but insecure young man. Unfortunately Pinter's character study sits uncomfortably alongside Shaffer's far-fetched plot and theatrical contrivances. One thing the film does share with the original is the presence of Michael Caine, this time playing the role taken in the original film by Laurence Olivier. Unfortunately for Caine, by updating the character of Wyke, Pinter has made him an unpleasant boor, whereas Olivier's original was an eccentric snob, probably equally as unpleasant if you actually met him, but much more entertaining to watch. Milo, the role originally taken by Caine, is played this time by Jude Law (who also produced). This is the second time Law has taken a role played originally by Caine, the first being the ill-advised remake of Alfie. Law is a perfectly good actor but he doesn't have the screen charisma of the young Caine (or indeed the older one) and if he is wise he'll make this the last time he offers himself up for comparison. As a director Branagh works hard to disguise the film's stage origins, a difficult task given that he's basically working with a set and two characters. If you're a fan of Law or Pinter, you might enjoy this film, but if you're a fan of the original you might not.