Film details

A Good Year  2006

Cast

  • Albert Finney
  • Abbie Cornish
  • Tom Hollander
  • Didier Bourdon
  • Valeria Bruni-Tedeschi
  • Freddie Highmore
  • Isabelle Candelier
  • Archie Panjabi
  • Catriona McCoil
  • Ali Rhodes

Synopsis

Max Skinner, a City stockbroker with a reputation for relentless work and not suffering fools, hears that his uncle Henry has died, and left him La Siroque, his chateau in Provence, France. Realising he has no time to spend there, being devoted to long hours and hard work, Max travels to the chateau to evaluate it and set into motion the process of putting it on the market, remembering the happy summers he spent there with his uncle. Once there he finds the vineyard attached to the property is still in excellent condition, being tended to by Francis Duflot, a local labourer, while Duflot's wife, Ludevine, acts as housekeeper, and seems genuinely pleased that Max has come to stay, not knowing he intends to sell it. He receives news from London that he has been suspended while some of his share-trades are investigated by a standards committee, and Max decides to stay in Provence while the case proceeds. He starts to have second thoughts about selling the chateau, even though his friend Charlie Willis, keeping him informed of the proceedings in London, urges him to offload it during one of their many phone conversations. Max starts to flirt with Fanny Chenal, the attractive young owner of the local restaurant, but is stunned by the arrival of Christine Roberts, a young woman who claims to be his long-lost daughter from a brief relationship years previously. Max is suspicious, and wonders if she is acting for someone trying to get hold of the estate, but she remains at the chateau, and Max begins to believe her story the more he gets to know of her. Charlie arrives from London for a visit and becomes besotted with Christine, much to Max's annoyance. The case in London comes to a verdict, but Max finds that he is now too involved with La Siroque, and a potential scandal involving the vineyard, to return immediately, and starts to wonder of the the City life is actually worth returning to.

Production

Director
Ridley Scott
Producer
Ridley Scott
Art Director
Robert Cowper and Frederic Evard
Editor
Dody Dorn
Music
Marc Streitenfeld
Screenplay
Marc Klein, based on the novel by Peter Mayle
Director of Photography
Philippe Le Sourd

Review

Ridley Scott, one of the few directors who has ever worked with Russell Crowe more than once, and indeed ever expressed an urge to, links up with the Gladiator star once more for what seems to be a change in direction in both the director and star's usual CV, in this adaptation of the very successful Peter Mayle novel. Mayle, who made his name with his autobiographical A Year In Provence, used the book to address some more aspects of the foreigner abroad, and was previously made into the horribly misjudged BBC TV series starring John Thaw and Lindsey Duncan. Unfortunately casting Crowe, with all his attendant baggage regarding both his on-screen and off-screen image, and having a director such as Scott whose biggest films (Alien / Gladiator etc.) are stories of drama, adventure and eventual violence, means both show that light comedy is just not in their remit. Crowe in particular is in a bifurcated role, his City scenes showing Max as a particularly cold, geeky and emotionless money mover, and as it is revealed probably not adverse to breaking the rules when it suits him, but in France he reverts to Hugh Grant default territory, trying to come across as the enchanted nice guy, suddenly blossoming when he reaches French soil, which only goes to prove just how well Grant can handle this sort of role and how others can't. The script tries for some diversity with the arrival of who could possibly be Max's long-lost daughter, played by the excellent young Australian actress Abbie Cornish (Somersault / Candy) in one of the more contrived plot developments, and Max's flashbacks to the time spent with his Uncle Henry (an underused Albert Finney) link to Max's regrets that he let his Uncle down, but in ways which are never revealed, hinting at scenes on the cutting-room floor, and a subplot revolving around chicanery at the vineyard is similarly dispensed with in a few sentences. The scenery is certainly captivating and the pleasures of French provincial life seem alluring if made overly simplistic, and there are some good names soaking up the French sunshine including Marion Cotillard (Maria / Taxi 3), Tom Hollander (The Libertine), Valeria Bruni-Tedeschi (5x2) and Lucio Fulci regular Catriona McColl, but Crowe's miscasting tends to overshadow their efforts. A Good Year? Not for Crowe or Scott, particularly....