Film details

Freedom Writers  2006

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

As the 1992 Los Angeles riots erupt, the violence and murder rates in the surrounding areas stay high even after the disturbances have been long quelled, Long Beach in particular suffering a steep rise in street violence and gang killings. 1994, and Erin Gruwell arrives to take her post as an English teacher at the Wilson High School in Long Beach. Her department head, Margaret Vail, tells her about the school and the class she will be teaching, mentioning the high incidence of gang membership among the pupils. Her class is comprised of mainly African-American, Latino and Asian students, and a violent fight breaks out in the classroom on her first day. A shooting in the area has several connections to the school and Eva, one of Erin's class, witnesses the attempted murder, but lies about the shooter in order not to implicate a fellow Latino. Finding racist drawings are being circulated, Erin confiscates them and shows them to the whole of the class, comparing them to Nazi propaganda. Making an application for books for her class to study, Erin finds that Margaret Vail refuses the request, believing it is not worthwhile providing such materials for a class of underachievers such as hers. Erin instead gives them blank notebooks and asks them to write about their everyday experiences, dealing with their home lives, social lives and what they see on the violent streets around them. Erin's dedication to her class starts to affect her own home life, her husband Scott starting to complain about the amount of time she devotes to her work. Taking a part-time job, which also does not go down well with Scott, she uses the money to buy the class novels concerning gang violence, and for some these are the first books they have ever read. Realising that some are interested in the Holocaust, she organises a trip to a Holocaust museum, and also arranges a dinner with some local Jewish survivors. After they all read The Diary Of Anne Frank, Erin manages to scrape together enough money to arrange a visit by Miep Gies, who was Anne Frank's protector as a young man. Encouraged by Anne Frank's courage, Eva testifies in court as to the real identity of the shooter and receives death threats as a result. Seeing her student's diaries are vivid and genuine pieces of writing, Erin starts to wonder if she can arrange a publishing deal, but as she does so Scott announces that he wants a divorce...

Production

Director
Richard LaGravenese
Producer
Danny DeVito, Stacey Sher and Michael Shamberg
Art Director
Peter Borck
Editor
David Moritz
Music
Mark Isham
Screenplay
Richard LaGravenese, based on the book The Freedom Writers Diary by Erin Gruwell
Director of Photography
Jim Denault

Review

Having made his feature debut with the enterprising and fresh Living Out Loud, and winning an Oscar for his screenplay for Terry Gilliam's The Fisher King, Richard LaGravenese makes a surprisingly conventional feature in Freedom Writers, based on the real-life story of teacher Erin Gruwell, who taught a multi-ethnic class of underprivileged teenagers in post-riot Los Angeles in 1992, and as with so many other 'inspirational' films would be utterly unbelievable if at least the core of the story were not true. Double Oscar-winner Hilary Swank plays Gruwell as a woman who devotes an extraordinary amount of time to those who are regarded by the school authorities (personified by Imelda Staunton with an uncomfortable accent) as hopeless cases, despite the hostility of both her father Steve (the excellent Scott Glenn - Vertical Limit) and her husband (Patrick Dempsey - TV's Grey's Anatomy).Trying to devise a program of teaching which will prove to these youngsters that their lives do have meaning, she includes such diverse teaching aids as Anne Frank's diary and the songs of rapper Tupac Shakur. Some of the students start to write about their lives, families and the problems they face every day, and LaGravenese includes some of the actual pieces as voiceovers. Dealing with much the same territory as the Michelle Pfeiffer starrer Dangerous Minds, the director has made a rather platitudinous film, with Gruwell verging on the saintly as her family dismiss her ambitions, several of her students also showing remarkable virtue when their artistic talents are allowed to grow. Her devotion to her class is seen when she does indeed lose her husband, Scott Gruwell realising that he now actually comes way down her list of affections. Gruwell seems to take the rather hackneyed attitude that there is no such thing as bad pupils rather too literally, and it would be interesting to know just how many of the students published in The Freedom Writers Diary went on to a career in media or publishing, or indeed andy sort of career at all. Undoubtedly sincere, to the point of lecturing, Swank may be a double Oscar-winner but is not exactly a box-office draw, and what appears to be well-worn territory is not an ideal vehicle for an actress who has always worked best under strong and distinctive directors.