Film details

The Brave One  2007

Still unavailable

Cast

  • Naveen Andrews
  • Terrence Howard
  • Nicky Katt
  • Ene Oloja
  • Luis Da Silva Jr.
  • Blaze Foster
  • Jane Adams
  • Zoe Kravitz
  • Larry Fessenden
  • Brian Delate

Synopsis

Erica Bain is a New York radio talkshow host, her programme, Street Talk, being provocative, intelligent and popular. While in Central Park with her fiancee David Kirmani, walking their dog, they are attacked by three men, Erica suffering a severe beating while David is killed. Hurt and wanting revenge, she buys a handgun illegally, and uses it in a drugstore when a man goes berserk and kills his own wife. Erica shoots him in self defence and flees. Homicide Detectives Mercer and Vitale are assigned to the case. Her bosses want her to take a prolonged rest but Erica insists on returning to work, where she talks about the attack in the park. Mercer hears her broadcast and is intrigued. After being threatened on the subway by two men, Erica draws the weapon and shoots them both dead. The killings are announced by the press as the work of a vigilante in the city. Approached by the radio station, Mercer agrees to be interviewed by Erica. Before that can happen she kills again, rescuing a prostitute from a violent client who tries to run her over. Mercer receives a call from Erica, not knowing that it is her, before she shoots and kills a criminal he had been trailing. He begins to suspect that she is the city vigilante. They meet, and he takes her to see the prostitute she rescued, but the young woman does not betray her identity. Vitale interviews one of the witnesses from the subway killings who claims the shooter was a young woman. Mercer returns to Erica her ring, which was pawned by one of her attacker's girlfriend. Brought into a Police identity parade she recognises one of her assailents as one of the suspects but does not pick him out. Mercer hints to Erica that he knows her secret, and that if any more firm evidence is presented he'll have to arrest her. Hunting down the attacker's girlfriend, Erica demands his address from her. She refuses, but later texts Erica the address, along with mobile phone footage taken of the attack on her. Erica forwards it to Mercer along with the word 'Goodbye'. Arriving at the address she has been given, Erica finds her three attackers inside. The vigilante's final act of street justice is about to be carried out...

Production

Director
Neil Jordan
Producer
Susan Downey and Joel Silver
Art Director
Robert Guerra
Editor
Tony Lawson
Music
Dario Marianelli
Screenplay
Roderick Taylor, Bruce A. Taylor and Cynthia Mort, based on a story by Roderick Taylor and Bruce A. Taylor
Director of Photography
Philippe Rousselot

Review

Odd to see a director such as Neil Jordan (The Crying Game / Angel) working for a brash, commercial, crowdpleasing producer such as Joel Silver, and even odder to find the film he has helmed being a bizarre cross between The Accused (one of Jodie Foster's finest performances) and Death Wish. Foster once more takes the lead role of initially a victim, as she has recently been in films such as Panic Room and Flightplan, but who fights back, here very literally as she obtains an illegal gun with surprising ease, and stalks the streets, armed and looking for revenge. Unfortunately the symbolism of Foster's character turning into the sort of vigilante even Charles Bronson would have considered excessive is blatantly compared with the post 9-11 New York, Erica's retribution being overwhelming violent and, interestingly, meted out to almost anyone who crosses her path with little remorse. An interesting angle is added with the inclusion of Terrence Howard (Hustle And Flow) as Detective Mercer, whose seems to deduce Erica's involvement with the killings early on, but continues to keep his distance in order to keep the increasingly implausible plot going. It seems an odd project for Jordan, whose more obviously commercial efforts (i.e. Interview with A Vampire / In Dreams) are usually far less effective than his more personal pieces of work, such as the truly memorable The Butcher Boy, and a couple of the set-pieces, such as the subway shootings, seem to be oddly sincere homages to Death Wish and any number of Eighties vigilante movies, and despite the high profile cast and impressive production values, The Brave One seems to be treading a wellworn path, previously told by the likes of Tony Garnett's Handgun and Abel Ferrera's Ms. 45 / Angel Of Vengeance to name just two. More confusingly the script is morally ambiguous, like many others in this particular strand of exploitation, condemning for the perpetrator and the violence of their actions but also revelling in the bloodthirsty retribution, which probably wasn't Jordan's intention at all.