Film details

The Heart Of The Matter  1953

Still unavailable

Cast

  • Elizabeth Allen
  • Maria Schell
  • Peter Finch
  • Gerard Oury
  • George Coulouris
  • Michael Hordern
  • Earl Cameron
  • Colin Gordon
  • Eileen Thorndike
  • Cyril Raymond

Synopsis

Sierra Leone, sometime during the Second World War, the country still being under colonial rule. Assistant Police Commissioner Harry Scobie, is unhappy, both with his career, which seems to have stalled, he seeing this posting as a convenient way of him being forgotten about, and his relationship with his wife Louise is cold and unloving. Wanting to send her back to England for a vacation, perhaps to try to salvage what remains of their marriage, he borrows the money he needs from Yusuf, an unscrupulous money lender, wondering if being indebted to him is going to lead to favours being asked of him. Laura leaves, but while she is away Harry meets and falls for Helen Rolt, a young widow who is one of the survivors of a ship sunk by a U-boat. He knows his marriage is now little more than a sham, and that Helen is the woman he is destined to really love, but there is an unsurmountable problem in that both he and his wife are strict Catholics, and for such a couple there can never be a divorce. Some form of solution has to be found, but all they can see is unhappiness.

Production

Director
George More O'Ferrall
Producer
Ian Dalrymple
Art Director
Joseph Bato
Editor
Sidney Stone
Music
Edric Connor
Screenplay
Ian Dalrymple, based on the novel by Graham Greene, adapted by Lesley Storm
Director of Photography
Jack Hildyard

Review

A fine adaptation of Graham Greene's novel, even though the ending is changed from the printed page, is given resonance by firm direction by George More O'Ferrell (The Woman For Joe / The Holly And The Ivy) and very strong performances from all three leads, with Trevor Howard being both pitiful and sympathetic as the jaded, splenic Harry Scobie, Elizabeth Allen as his equally disillusioned wife, volatile and cowed by turns, and Maria Schell as Helen, the young widow whose arrival is the catalyst to the escalating events. Being Greene of course there are the recurrent subjects of staunch Catholicism, the stigma and impossibility of divorce, the pleasure mixed with guilt an affair brings, along with the realisation that one's marriage has been a long-running mistake, themes which would crop up throughout his work, in such novels as The End Of The Affair, The Quiet American and The Fallen Idol. Now, more than fifty years after the novel was written, the fact that the idea of divorce is regarded as so sinful and morally wrong may seem surprising, but for men of Greene's generation, and by dint most of his male characters, it was a reality, and a reiteration that marriage was very much till death, which makes so many of his essentially romantic males so desperate. A strong and thoughtful piece of work, aided by very fine performances, and with a supporting cast which has talent in depth. Although one of Greene's more accessible novels, this is the only film version, although it was remade as a TV mini-series in the early Eighties, backed by German money and with Jack Hedley (The New York Ripper / TV's Colditz) in the Trevor Howard role.