Film details

A Guide To Recognising Your Saints  2006

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Writer Dito Montiel receives a phone call from his mother, Flori, telling him that his father, Monty, is very ill and asks him to come back home, for the first time in twenty years, to see him. Dito reluctantly agrees, and finds himself remembering the friends he had two decades previously, and what he want through with them. Back in 1986 he was part of a four-boy gang with Giuseppe and Nerf, led by the seemingly tough Antonio, Giuseppe's brother, but becomes friendly with a new boy at school, Mike. He also tells his on / off girlfriend Laurie that he wants their relationship to go further and wants to sleep with her. Antonio and the others cause a ruction with another local gang which leads to violent clashes and Dito receiving what seem to be very genuine death threats, and he starts to constantly feel in danger when out on the streets. Needing to earn some extra cash, he and Mike take a job helping Frank, a local dog-walker, and put together plans to get out of New York and instead move to California. Antonio is with his brother, Giuseppe, on the train lines when Giuseppe has an accident and is killed by a passing train, causing Antonio to go berserk, hunting down a member of the rival gang and attacking him, beating him to death in an uncontrollable rage. Mike finds himself the target of a retaliatory attack by the gang and is shot dead. Antonio is arrested for the bludgeoning of the gang member, found guilty and imprisoned. Finding himself back in Queens, and dreading having to meet his ailing father, Dito goes to find the other member of the old gang, Nerf, only to find him crippled with a major drug habit. Finding Laurie he discovers she is now a single mother, who tells him that he need to make things right with Monty before he dies. Dito knows he has two very difficult meetings while he is back in Queens, with his father and the still incarcerated Antonio, but it is the only way to heal the wounds of the past.

Production

Director
Dito Montiel
Producer
Charlie Corwin, Clara Markowicz, Trudie Styler and Travis Swords
Art Director
Jody Asnes
Editor
Jake Pushinsky and Christopher Tellefson
Music
Jonathan Elias, Jimmy Haun and David Wittman
Screenplay
Dito Montiel, based on his own book
Director of Photography
Eric Gautier

Review

Based on his own autobiographical novel, and with a cast which won the ensemble prize at the 2006 Sundance Film Festival, Dito Montiel's A Guide To Recognising Your Saints tells of his life in both 1986 and 2005 as Dito (Robert Downey Jr), a American-Italian writer who has managed to escape his upbringing, is called back to the family home in the suburb of Queens to visit his dying father (Chazz Palminteri - A Bronx Tale). A best seller in the relatively recent 'misery memoirs' genre, which includes the likes of Dave Peltzer, Augustine Burroughs and Frank McCourt, questions about the veracity of Montiel's actual memoirs have been raised, the director himself saying that a few incidents and characters have been changed for various personal reasons, but his detractors claim that large chunks of the book and film are simply fiction, created for dramatic purposes, and certainly the film seems rather too neat in the fact that the young Dito (Shia LaBeouf - Holes) has to deal with the gang culture which is starting to assert itself in the area, but only in the most peripheral way, and interestingly he is always the victim of the violence and threats, never seeming to actually do anything to warrant such attention. Guns, knives and drugs may be circulating but Dito is far too clever to ever get involved with them, and just wants to learn more about the world instead of accepting his father's closed-minded attitude to whatever lies outside New York. The performances are all well judged, and the transitions from young to older characters well cast, LaBeouf being a reasonably convincing young version of Robert Downey Jr, while Rosario Dawson (Sin City), playing Laurie, could easily be a grown-up version of Melonie Diaz, who plays her as a younger woman. Sadly Montiel's script all too often seems like transcriptions from the printed page, which rarely makes for convincing dialogue, and the film escalates in drama, Montiel eventually playing almost every scene as high drama, complete with an all too neat final reel which brings reconciliations all round. Montiel shows promise as a director, and seems to know how to handle actors well, but the material is tailored to his strengths, and puts his own character consistantly in the best possible light, to the detriment of the real drama and grittiness of the story.