Film details

Lonely Hearts  2006

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Ray Fernandez, a handsome, clever young man, has a lucrative line of business in 1947, fleecing the lonely women who answer his multiple lonely hearts ads, one of them being the equally sharp and savvy Martha Beck, but instead of conning Beck, Fernandez forms a strange, obsessive relationship with her, and the pair go into the scamming business together. Meanwhile Police Detective Elmer C.'Buster' Robinson is struggling to come to terms with the suicide of his wife, causing a difficult relationship with his teenage son Eddie, and his reluctance to enter into any new relationship, despite the urgings of a colleague, Rene Fodie, who has fallen for him. His partner on the job, Detective Charles Hilderbrandt, is worried that Robinson is close to a breakdown. By April 1949, Ray Fernandez and Martha Beck are doing very well out of their corrupt scheme, Beck pretending to be Fernandez's sister, and he seduces Janet Long, a lonely middle-aged widow. Long withdraws all her money from the bank and plans to move into a rented house in Valley Stream, New York, with Ray, but one night, overhearing them have sex in the next room, Martha bursts into the room and beats the woman to death with a hammer while Ray watches impassively. Having been assigned the case of a young woman who committed suicide after being conned out of everything by a pair of grifters, Robinson and Hilderbrandt follow a trail which leads them to the house in Valley Stream where they discover Janet Long's body, having missed the killers by hours. Fernandez makes another contact through the personals, Delphine Dowling, who also has a two year old daughter, Rainelle, and the pair once more pose as siblings as Ray gets to know her. Beginning a relationship with Delphine, and staying at her home near Grand Rapids, Michigan, Fernandez is working on Delphine to get her to empty her bank account when she gives him the news that she is pregnant. On hearing the news, Beck demands Ray kills her immediately, which he does. Knowing they will also have to kill Rainelle, who can identify both of them, the situation rapidly gets out of control, both Fernandez and Beck murdering others as they debate what to do with the little girl, but Robinson and Hilderbrandt have found a trail of clues leading them to the Grand Rapids house, and they are about to swoop.....

Production

Director
Todd Robinson
Producer
Boaz Davison and Holly Wiersma
Art Director
David Eckert
Editor
Kathryn Himoff
Music
Mychael Danna
Screenplay
Todd Robinson
Director of Photography
Peter Levy

Review

Barely released in the US, and quickly pulled off the few screens it did play, Lonely Hearts would seem to have everything going for it, being based on a grimly fascinating true story and having a heavyweight cast, including John Travolta (Pulp Fiction) Salma Hayek (Frida) and James Gandolfini (TV's The Sopranos). Based on a genuine case of the 40s, the story of murderers Raymond Fernandez and Martha Beck has already been filmed twice before, as The Honeymoon Killers (1970) and the Spanish-language film Profondo Carmesi / Deep Crimson (1996). Fernandez (here played by Jared Leto) and Beck (Hayek) were a couple who preyed on spinsters and widows who advertised in the personal columns, and the director, TV movie veteran Todd Robinson, has a remarkable connection to the real-life case, being the grandson of Detective Elmer C. Robinson (played here by Travolta). Director Robinson rather tampers with the evidence of the case in order to heighten the drama and gore level, with one of the most obvious being the casting of the gorgeous Hayek when in reality Beck was extremely large and overweight, and played by the equally ample Shirley Stoller in The Honeymoon Killers. Robinson's screenplay also provides motives of jealousy from Beck which were never proved in the actual court case, and who actually instigated the murders and carried them out, although both were certainly complicit, was also never fully established, nor was the actual number of victims. Robinson manages to get the period details perfectly right, as well as the tough camerarderie between the cops themselves, with their methods often being borderline illegal, and isn't afraid to show the brutality involved in the killings, but also manages to undermine the drama with some awkwardly sentimental scenes as the grieving Robinson tries to bond with his young son, and finally accepts the advances of work colleague Rene (Laura Dern - Jurassic Park) in a rather thankless role. Lonely Hearts is certainly well crafted, and shows, perhaps to its' detriment, the sheer slog of Police work rather than any inspired detection or sudden revelations, but despite the care lavished on what is on screen, there is still something obviously lacking.